Party Girl Blu-ray Review
Warner Archive Collection
Score: 67
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
A compelling blend of crime melodrama and musical numbers, Party Girl shines with dynamic leads and a superb 4K restoration on Warner Archive's Blu-ray.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 82
The new Blu-ray of "Party Girl," mastered from a 4K scan, offers vibrant 1080p visuals that highlight Metrocolor's charm. The restoration ensures bold colors, excellent clarity, and fine texture details, while maintaining a film-like grain. Despite occasional minor flaws in black levels, the transfer is a visual delight.
Audio: 80
The Blu-ray's DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track delivers a crisp, well-balanced sound that effectively preserves Party Girl's one-channel roots. Despite the lack of a multi-channel option, it handles dynamic range with clarity, capturing dialogue, music, and effects like gunfire and acid sizzle without distortion.
Extra: 19
Extras on the 'Party Girl' Blu-ray are minimal, featuring only a vibrant yet imperfect original theatrical trailer available in both 2.35:1 with lossless mono audio and a rougher 1.33:1 version, adding a touch of vintage allure to the release.
Movie: 67
Party Girl delivers an engaging blend of grit and glamour, skillfully portraying 1930s gangland Chicago with strong performances by Cyd Charisse and Robert Taylor. Nicholas Ray's direction adds flair despite formulaic plot beats, complemented by vibrant Metrocolor and CinemaScope. This meticulously restored Blu-ray is a worthy addition for any classic film enthusiast.
Video: 82
Warner Bros.’ Blu-ray release of "Party Girl" features an impressive 1080p restoration from a 4K scan of original preservation elements, presenting a visual feast for viewers. The Metrocolor single-strip format is known for its tendency to fade over time, but here it shines with vibrant colors, particularly reds, prominently displayed in clothing and set pieces. Director of Photography Robert J. Bronner's CinemaScope cinematography benefits from excellent clarity, maintaining a film-like grain that enhances details such as dress patterns, facial lines, and jewelry. Moreover, the restoration faithfully highlights the flashy costumes and set designs, enhancing the film’s visual allure.
The transfer boasts an exceptional level of detail, allowing viewers to appreciate sharp close-ups where facial features and textures are crisply visible. While most of the film's visual elements are clear and intricately detailed, some minor issues arise during scene transitions where black levels occasionally flicker slightly. Despite this, blacks generally exhibit depth, while whites remain stable and bright. The restoration delivers striking contrast and shadow delineation that elevates the overall viewing experience. With no visible imperfections like nicks or scratches on the pristine source materials, this Blu-ray presentation truly revitalizes "Party Girl" for contemporary audiences.
Ultimately, this meticulous restoration serves "Party Girl" exceptionally well, offering an outstanding audiovisual experience that highlights Bronner's lush cinematography and the bold color palette within the context of its 1950s setting. The immersive visuals delivered by this new HD master not only honor the original production but elevate the film's aesthetic appeal for home enthusiasts, making it a must-have for collectors and fans alike.
Audio: 80
The Blu-ray release of "Party Girl" features a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track, impressively complementing the film's original audio roots, formerly recorded in four-track stereo. While the lack of a multi-channel track is duly noted, this mono mix proficiently handles a wide dynamic range, highlighting Tony Martin's vocals and Jeff Alexander's score with crisp precision. Dialogue is consistently clear, ensuring immersive viewing without any notable hiss, pops, or distortion. The sound design effectively integrates background effects and ambient sounds, evocatively simulating environments like club scenes, with articulate detail on sound effects such as gunfire and the sizzling of acid on crepe paper.
The track is characterized by its meticulous balance of dialogue, music, and sound effects. Despite minor instances of clipping during particularly loud scenes, like revenge montage gunfire, the overall audio experience remains robust and well-controlled. Moments of musical vibrancy, especially during the film’s integrated performances, are acutely captured, though some club performance instruments may feel poorly choreographed against their visual backdrop.
Technical choices in this audio presentation may leave audiophiles longing for more modern enhancements beyond the DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono configuration. Yet, for what it offers, it admirably preserves the film’s sonic integrity while inviting viewers to experience the film's rich acoustical ambiance. Optional English (SDH) subtitles enhance accessibility, serving as a beneficial supplement to the film’s auditory experience.
Extras: 19
The Blu-ray release of "Party Girl" offers a limited yet intriguing selection of extras, encapsulating the film’s nostalgic allure through concise content. The highlight is the Original Theatrical Trailer, which runs approximately three minutes and provides character introductions in an engaging, fourth-wall-breaking format. While the video quality reflects its age, being offered in both 2.35:1 with lossless mono audio and a rough 1.33:1 version, it retains its promotional charm. Despite the minimalistic nature of the available extras, these components are presented with care and maintain the thematic essence of the film through an authentic lens.
Extras included in this disc:
- Original Theatrical Trailer: A character introduction piece that breaks the fourth wall, offered in two aspect ratios, with mono audio.
Movie: 67
Nicholas Ray's "Party Girl" is a vibrant and gritty homage to 1930s gangland Chicago that blends melodrama, romance, and crime, spearheaded by captivating performances from its leads. Cyd Charisse, in a role diverging from her musical persona, plays Vicki Gaye, a showgirl entangled in the underworld. Her portrayal, though somewhat limited emotionally, exudes strong allure through her magnetic dance sequences. Opposite her is Robert Taylor as mob lawyer Thomas Farrell, delivering a grounded and understated performance. Farrell's moral awakening provides the narrative thrust, as he endeavors to extricate himself from the clutches of mob boss Rico Angelo, portrayed with forceful intensity by Lee J. Cobb. The film's plot may be straightforward, yet it's imbued with sharp dialogue and character-driven drama that keeps it engaging.
"Party Girl" gains strength from its period authenticity and Metrocolor cinematography that accentuate the seedy allure of Prohibition-era Chicago. Although the narrative occasionally follows predictable conventions, Ray's direction injects vivid life into the crime saga, with surprising levels of violence that distinguish it from its contemporaries. The movie crafts its atmospheric tension through dramatic interplay, painting a vivid picture of lawless Chicago nightlife against a glitzy soundtrack and vibrant color palette, giving it a distinctive nostalgic charm.
While not breaking new ground in the gangster genre, Ray's film remains an intriguing artifact from the transitional period of Hollywood history. Its release on Blu-ray reveals meticulous restoration work that enhances visual fidelity and audio clarity, offering a dependable preservation of the film’s original aesthetic. Although devoid of supplemental features beyond the film itself, "Party Girl" stands as a notable addition for fans of classic criminal tales and showcases the artistry of its era, making it a worthy acquisition for genre enthusiasts and cinephiles alike.
Total: 67
Nicholas Ray's "Party Girl," while not achieving the acclaim of "Rebel Without a Cause," offers an intriguing blend of MGM gloss and gritty crime drama in a Prohibition-era setting. The film showcases strong performances by Robert Taylor and Cyd Charisse, who both deliver engaging portrayals despite being at the end of their MGM tenures. The script, which delicately balances melodramatic crime plotting with musical interludes, elevates the film beyond its original exaggerated promotional efforts. The Warner Archive Blu-ray release offers an excellent restoration, further highlighting the film's workmanlike visuals and sound.
"Party Girl" deviates from stereotypical gangster narratives by portraying complex characters, especially in the depiction of Vicki Gaye, played by Charisse, whose income stems from more than just dance performances. While Charisse may not deliver a stellar acting performance, her dance routines are a testament to her expertise. Despite some awkward transitions between crime and musical elements, the romantic subplot remains convincing. The film succeeds in presenting Taylor and Charisse as a formidable duo attempting to navigate their perilous circumstances.
In conclusion, "Party Girl" may not reach the status of a classic Hollywood gangster film, but its unique characteristics make it a well-crafted and entertaining entry in the genre. The Warner Archive's Blu-ray release, benefiting from a 4K scan of preservation elements, significantly enhances the film's allure, making it a worthy addition to any collection. At its current price point, it poses as an attractive option for both longtime fans and newcomers alike. Recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 90
Despite its modest visual ambitions (after all, key stretches during Party Girl take place in offices, apartments and courtrooms), the film goes on a welcome field trip to Stockholm when Thomas finally...
Audio: 90
There are trace amounts of clipping during the film's loudest moments -- that extended montage of revenge killings mentioned above, for example -- where the sudden bursts of gunfire sound especially harsh,...
Extras: 10
This one-disc release ships in a standard keep with drop-dead gorgeous poster-themed cover artwork (which either sold a lot of tickets or kept married men from seeing it) and includes no inserts....
Movie: 70
It's moments like these, combined with the film's colorful characters and workmanlike Metrocolor cinematography, that elevate Party Girl from a lightweight trifle to a borderline cult classic that holds...
Total: 70
Nicholas Ray's Prohibition-era gangster film Party Girl isn't as well-known or well-made as Rebel Without a Cause or In a Lonely Place, but the film's colorful characters and performances -- led by Robert...
The Digital Bits review by Dennis SeulingRead review here
Video: 95
Reds are particularly dominant, and can be seen in two of Charisse’s dresses, her ruby lipstick, lamps, a sofa, large poppy decoration in Charisse’s black jacket, Taylor’s red shirt, his ascot, hotel curtains,...
Audio: 90
Dialogue is clear and distinct throughout, with the musical numbers particularly sharp and well balanced....
Extras: 35
Movie: 80
Set in Prohibition-era Chicago, Party Girl is a gangland melodrama centered on hard-edged nightclub dancer Vicki Gaye (Cyd Charisse), who makes extra bucks hanging out with underworld types....
Total: 75
With its two strong male leads, Party Girl provides an interesting spin on the usual gangster tale, with a fairly candid approach to the kind of work speakeasy dancer Vicki Gaye does during and after working...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Excellent clarity, spot-on contrast, and just enough grain to preserve the film-like feel combine to produce a vibrant image that faithfully renders the lush CinemaScope cinematography of Robert Bronner,...
Audio: 80
A wide dynamic scale handles all the brassy highs and weighty lows of the music score, as well as Tony Martin's vocals on the title tune, with ease, and all the dialogue is clear and easy to comprehend....
Extras: 0
The only disc extra is the movie's three-minute original theatrical trailer that allows all the major characters the opportunity to personally introduce themselves to the audience....
Movie: 60
Party Girl, despite its MGM pedigree and innocuous title, doesn't shy away from painting a blistering portrait of organized crime, and though Cobb occasionally chews the scenery in addition to his omnipresent...
Total: 80
An aging Robert Taylor and post-musical Cyd Charisse make a surprisingly dynamic duo in this tale of a mob mouthpiece and slinky showgirl who seek to escape their sordid pasts and dangerous present....
Director: Nicholas Ray
Actors: Robert Taylor, Cyd Charisse, Lee J. Cobb
PlotIn the bustling world of 1930s Chicago, Thomas Farrell, a cynical and successful lawyer, finds himself working for a notorious mobster named Rico Angelo. Farrell uses his legal prowess to protect Angelo and his cronies from getting convicted for their criminal activities, a task he performs with unnerving precision. However, disillusioned with the ethics of his work and haunted by his own moral compass, Farrell begins questioning his choices. His life takes an unexpected turn when he meets Vicki Gaye, a graceful and charming dancer performing in one of Angelo's clubs. Drawn to Vicki's beauty and vivacity, Farrell is inspired to consider a different path, one away from the dangerous world he inhabits.
As their relationship blossoms, Farrell finds himself increasingly at odds with the dark underworld that Angelo commands. Vicki, who dreams of leaving the nightclub scene behind, becomes a beacon of hope for Farrell as he contemplates leaving the legal profession associated with crime. Tensions rise as Angelo grows suspicious and intolerant of any disloyalties within his ranks. Farrell is faced with difficult choices as he balances his growing affection for Vicki against the treacherous loyalty expected by the mob. Their romance intensifies the stakes as Farrell seeks redemption and a different life for himself and Vicki—a life free from fear and corruption. Amid growing peril and engulfing mistrust, Farrell must decide whether love can truly break the shackles of his criminal associations.
Writers: George Wells, Leo Katcher
Release Date: 28 Nov 1958
Runtime: 99 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English