12 Angry Men Blu-ray Review

Presented in an aspect ratio of 1.66:1 and utilizing a high-definition digital transfer created on a Spirit 2K from a 35mm fine-grain master positive, Criterion's Blu-ray release of "12 Angry Men" exhibits an exceptional video presentation for a film over half a century old. Both MTI’s DRS and Pixel Farm’s PFClean were employed to manually remove thousands of instances of dirt, debris, scratches, splices, warps, jitter, and flicker. Additionally, Image Systems’ DVNR was used for small dirt, grain, and noise reduction. The outcome is a beautifully restored transfer where the detail is generally excellent and clarity remains consistently strong. The varying monochrome palette is impressively rendered with well-defined shades of grey, bright whites, and deep blacks, showcasing optimal contrast and dynamic range.

The close-ups in the film are particularly striking, highlighting the texture of fabrics, the wood grain on tables, and even the minute details of facial expressions and skin porosity. Criterion's restoration efforts ensure that no over-zealous digital noise reduction (DNR) or edge enhancement detracts from the authentic experience; a light but filmic and well-resolved grain persists across the runtime. Previous aged prints of "12 Angry Men" showed significant wear and tear, but this meticulously clean transfer is devoid of large damage marks, cuts, stains, or warps and free from excessive noise or frame transition issues.

Viewers will appreciate that black levels are rich and sturdy while whites remain resilient against harsh lighting. The result is an engrossing grayscale that adds considerable depth and texture to the film’s visual narrative. Details such as the weave of Jack Warden's straw hat or the sweat glistening on foreheads manifest with stunning clarity. Thus, Criterion has once again delivered a top-flight effort, presenting this classic film in its best possible form.

The audio presentation of "12 Angry Men" on Blu-ray is remarkably handled, with its monaural soundtrack meticulously remastered at 24-bit from a restored 35mm magnetic print. Utilizing Pro Tools HD for the removal of clicks, thumps, hiss, and hum, and AudioCube’s integrated workstation for attenuating crackle, the track is impressively clear. The English LPCM 1.0 track, although technically limited in dynamic range, effectively showcases the film's dialogue-heavy content, ensuring clarity and coherence even during intense vocal exchanges.

The restoration effort has paid off significantly, with no noticeable distortion throughout, even in Lee J. Cobb's impassioned outbursts. While there is occasionally slight background hiss, it remains non-intrusive. Subtle elements like fist-pounding and ambient sounds, such as the heavy rain outside the jury room, are well captured and integrated into the overall soundscape. The music score by Kenyon Hopkins, although sparsely used, complements the dialogue well with its clear and warm tones.

Overall, the audio track may not overwhelm with dynamic range or complexity but does an exceptional job at presenting the material authentically and cleanly. This makes for a much-improved listening experience, one that fans will appreciate for bringing them closer to the intense and nuanced performances of this classic film.

Criterion's Blu-ray release of "12 Angry Men" comes with a robust and well-curated selection of extra features, enhancing the viewing experience for cinephiles and history buffs alike. The original television episode of "12 Angry Men," which launched the feature film, is a standout inclusion, showcasing Emmy-winning performances and providing fascinating insight into its creation. The disc also features in-depth analyses by experts like Ron Simon and Vance Kepley, interviews with renowned director Sidney Lumet and his collaborator Walter Bernstein, and an extended look at cinematographer Boris Kaufman's influential work. Complemented by a scholarly booklet from Thane Rosenbaum, these extras make this a definitive edition.

Extras included in this disc:

• Original Television Production: The first live TV production of "12 Angry Men" from 1954.
• Introduction by Ron Simon: A 15-minute piece by the Paley Center for Media curator.
• 12 Angry Men: From TV to the Big Screen: Vance Kepley explores its evolution from teleplay to film.
• Sidney Lumet: Compilation of 23-minute interview footage.
• Reflections on Sidney: 12-minute interview with Walter Bernstein.
• On Reginald Rose: Ron Simon discusses the writer's legacy.
• Tragedy in a Temporary Town: A 55-minute television episode written by Rose and directed by Lumet.
• On Boris Kaufman: John Bailey discusses Kaufman's cinematography.
• Trailer: The original 2-minute theatrical trailer.
• Booklet: Thane Rosenbaum's essay "Lumet’s Faces".

Sidney Lumet's "12 Angry Men" stands as an unparalleled classic in courtroom drama, exhibiting a mastery of minimalistic plotting, exceptional character development, and a script of superior strength. This film is a gripping legal drama that provides an enduring socio-political commentary on the law, justice, and the inherent dangers of trial by jury. Taking place in a small, stifling room on a hot summer day, it follows twelve jurors deliberating the fate of a young man charged with patricide. The characters remain unnamed apart from their juror numbers, and Lumet masterfully creates an atmosphere of claustrophobia and moral conflict. Henry Fonda, playing Juror No. 8, delivers a mesmerizing performance of quiet intensity, surrounded by a stellar ensemble cast including Lee J. Cobb and E.G. Marshall.

The film's transition to Blu-ray, courtesy of the Criterion Collection, brings it to life as never before. The 1.66:1 transfer is exceptionally crisp with a commendable level of grain and excellent image detail, particularly in its numerous close-ups. Remarkably clean and free of digital manipulation, the presentation enhances the intense, dialogue-driven drama. The monaural LPCM audio track is clear, delivering the film's crucial dialogue with precision, and minor instances of hiss do not detract from the experience. Optional English SDH subtitles are thoughtfully included.

Criterion's Blu-ray release also provides a wealth of supplemental features that add significant value. These include the original 1954 television play directed by Franklin Schaffner, archival interviews with Sidney Lumet, a video essay by curator Ron Simon, and interviews with notable figures such as cinematographer John Bailey and film scholar Vance Kepley. An illustrated booklet featuring an essay by Thane Rosenbaum enriches the viewing experience further. This comprehensive package not only honors the film’s legacy but also highlights its relevance and enduring impact on cinema and society.

Review of "12 Angry Men" Blu-Ray by Criterion Collection

"12 Angry Men," directed by Sidney Lumet, stands as a monumental achievement in American cinema, masterfully examining the complexities of the legal system and the human condition within the confines of a jury room. The Criterion Collection's Blu-ray release is an outstanding upgrade that does justice to this classic film. Shot in black and white, the transfer maintains the film's authentic grain structure and offers superb image clarity, particularly in close-ups. The 1.66:1 aspect ratio preserves the film’s visual integrity, while overall image cleanliness is praiseworthy and devoid of digital manipulation artifacts.

Accompanying the exemplary video quality is an LPCM mono track that faithfully delivers the dialogue-driven narrative. While minimal instances of hiss are detectable, they are not disruptive to the viewing experience. To complement the main feature, Criterion has included an array of invaluable supplements. These include the original 1954 teleplay directed by Franklin J. Schaffner and Sidney Lumet’s "Tragedy in a Temporary Town" from 1956. This edition also provides a production history, an essay by Thane Rosenbaum, archival and contemporary interviews regarding the film’s cast and crew, and the original theatrical trailer—each adding depth and context to the main feature.

Ultimately, "12 Angry Men" remains a riveting exploration of justice and human behavior, energized by Henry Fonda’s compelling performance and Lumet’s incisive direction. The Criterion Blu-ray not only revitalizes this legal drama in outstanding visual and audio quality but also enriches it with comprehensive additional content. This release undeniably merits its reputation as a quintessential addition to any film enthusiast's collection. Very highly recommended.