Benny & Joon Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray release of "Benny & Joon" features a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio that is generally satisfactory. The print shows occasional wear with minor scratches and specks, but these imperfections are minimally distracting, maintaining an authentic film quality. The overall grain structure appears natural, contributing to the film's intrinsic visual texture without the detrimental effects of edge enhancement or smeary DNR.

Considering the cinematographic choices by John Schwartzman, who employed diffusion filters for a softer look, the Blu-ray exhibits the intended softness with less intrinsic fine detail. While color grading could be perceived as slightly subdued, the black levels remain generally deep, albeit with some nighttime scenes appearing somewhat gray. The overall image clarity does benefit from the high-definition upgrade, even though detail depth and contrast are not particularly pronounced.

In essence, while the transfer may not be groundbreaking, it honors the film's artistic vision. The colors appear balanced with decent skin tones and an inviting warm glow throughout. This Blu-ray offers a largely accurate representation of "Benny & Joon," making it a reasonable upgrade for dedicated fans despite some minor visual shortcomings.

The Blu-ray release of "Benny & Joon" features a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 stereo track that effectively matches the film’s low-key romantic comedy style. Although the film’s sound design remains largely untouched, the audio presentation excels at delivering clear and balanced dialogue. The music, devoid of significant subwoofer output, still punches through effectively with pronounced clarity. This is particularly evident in the film’s main theme, "I’m Gonna Be (500 Miles)" by The Proclaimers, which sounds dynamic without any harsh high ends. While the addition of a 5.1 mix could have enhanced certain scenes, the stereo track sufficiently meets the film’s auditory requirements.

In addition to the primary English 2.0 DTS-HD MA track, viewers are provided with a Spanish Mono track and a French Dolby Surround track. The English track, although slightly thin, maintains mostly clean and crisp dialogue. The mix demonstrates decent directionality between the left and right channels, enhancing the overall audio experience. Although the dynamic range is somewhat flat and bass presence is minimal—apart from a few songs—the balance between dialogue, music, and effects is commendable. Despite showing some age-related fidelity issues, this audio track serves "Benny & Joon" well, sustaining its charm and emotional resonance.

Overall, this stereo track is well-suited for the film's demands, ensuring an enjoyable audio experience that complements its visual presentation effectively.

The Blu-ray extras for "Benny & Joon" offer a robust selection of features that cater to fans looking for deeper insights into the production process. Director Jeremiah Chechik's audio commentary is information-rich, covering aspects from balancing the film's tone to respectful portrayal of mental illness, even if it lacks some energy. Deleted scenes offer intriguing content, though commentary overlays distract from the experience. The Costume, Make-Up Test, and Stunt Reel feature cinematographer John Schwartzman's commentary on technical aspects, providing valuable insights into the film's visual style. For a nostalgic touch, the inclusion of The Proclaimers' iconic music video is a fun addition.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary by Jeremiah Chechik: In-depth look into production, direction, and script changes.
• Deleted Scenes: Two scenes with director commentary; full version of "The Mutilator."
• Costume, Make-Up Test, and Stunt Reel: Director of Photography's detailed technical commentary.
• Music Video - The Proclaimers I'm Gonna Be (500 Miles): Nostalgic music video.
• Theatrical Trailer: Provided in 1080p and Dolby Digital sound.

"Benny & Joon," a 1993 romantic dramedy directed by Jeremiah Chechik, straddles the line between whimsical romance and grounded drama, making it a unique entry in the romantic comedy genre. The film stars Mary Stuart Masterson as Joon, a mentally troubled young woman living with her protective older brother Benny (Aidan Quinn). Enter Johnny Depp as Sam, an eccentric drifter who captures Joon's heart with his playful antics and silent film star charm, invoking the likes of Buster Keaton and Charlie Chaplin.

Masterson delivers a deeply empathetic performance as Joon, skillfully navigating a character that could easily veer into caricature. Depp's portrayal of Sam is imbued with an infectious charisma, transforming mundane moments into comedic gold. Their chemistry is undeniable and serves as the emotional nucleus of the film. While the plot, which involves Benny grappling with the idea of committing Joon to a group home, progresses predictably, it avoids mawkishness, instead posing complex questions about mental health, autonomy, and love.

Chechik’s directorial choices blend naturalism with occasional flashes of whimsy. While his restrained approach lends a timeless quality to the characters, it sometimes mutes the script’s more fantastical elements. Certain visual moments, particularly involving Depp’s character, shine with a quasi-magical quality that hints at a more imaginative potential. Despite the conventional plot structure and some missed opportunities for heightened creativity, "Benny & Joon" stands out due to its strong performances and thought-provoking themes, distinguishing itself from typical romantic comedies by dealing sensitively with real issues.

"Benny & Joon" arrives on Blu-ray with a visual representation that, while not flawless, is certainly an upgrade from previous DVD releases. The picture quality showcases the film’s charming aesthetic, though viewers may notice occasional specks, flecks, and moments of softness. Despite these minor drawbacks, the high-definition transfer revitalizes the viewing experience, delivering an overall pleasing presentation. The audio quality is respectable, delivering clear dialogue and a balanced soundtrack, yet it does not distinguish itself as particularly outstanding.

The film itself, a delightful mix of romance and comedy, transcends the typical rom-com label through its intelligent storytelling and engaging performances. Johnny Depp’s whimsical portrayal of Sam and Mary Stuart Masterson’s endearing take on Joon are complemented by Aidan Quinn's solid performance as Benny. This combination ensures a heartfelt and genuine narrative that resonates on multiple emotional levels. Although the plot adheres to conventional structures, the strong character work and nuanced screenplay elevate the film beyond standard genre fare.

Supplementary materials included in this Blu-ray release enhance its value considerably. A variety of extras, potentially featuring behind-the-scenes footage, interviews, and commentary, offer fans deeper insights into the film’s creation and legacy. While these additions do not necessarily elevate the technical presentation, they contribute to a well-rounded package that long-time admirers and newcomers alike will appreciate.

In conclusion, "Benny & Joon" is romantic, and it's a comedy, but I resist applying the rom-com label to Benny & Joon, a film that's better—and smarter—than that classification often implies. Although MGM appears to have put the bare minimum of effort into this Blu-ray release, the film looks good in high definition—minus some specks, flecks, and occasional softness—enough so that fans will probably feel justified in upgrading from their worn-out DVD copies. Recommended.