Jimi: All Is by My Side Blu-ray Review
Score: 51
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Despite mixed filmmaking results and lack of Hendrix's original music, Andre Benjamin's performance and a challenging narrative make it worth a watch for fans.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 66
XLrator Media's 1080p, AVC-encoded Blu-ray of 'Jimi: All Is By My Side' delivers a detailed, richly saturated image with accurate emotional textures, despite a low average bitrate and added grain for a period look. Although the black levels are not the deepest, the digital origin aids in artifact-free compression.
Audio: 56
The 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio soundtrack effectively captures Hendrix's musical essence, with Andr� Benjamin's vocals and Waddy Wachtel's guitar offering clear and distinct renditions. While music moments excel, dialogue clarity occasionally falters, reflecting a balance that favors musical over narrative elements.
Extra: 11
Extras provide a brief look at the musical contributions to the film, including an interview with Waddy Wachtel (1080i), a theatrical trailer (1080p), and additional startup trailers, but the absence of director John Ridley is notable.
Movie: 61
John Ridley's 'Jimi: All Is by My Side,' despite criticisms and absence of Hendrix's original music, shines with André Benjamin's compelling portrayal, capturing both the mystical aura and inner struggles of Jimi Hendrix, all set against an evocative backdrop of 60s London.
Video: 66
The Blu-ray presentation of "Jimi: All Is By My Side" offers a detailed and densely saturated image, though it might not precisely reflect the historical period's textures, it effectively conveys the film's emotional essence. Encoded in 1080p with an MPEG-4 AVC codec and presented in a 2.40:1 aspect ratio, the video transfer is commendable but not without its shortcomings. The film's digital photography by Tim Fleming emphasizes rich reds, browns, and golds, particularly enhancing the visual portrayal of Jimi Hendrix. Scenes set in Harlem are intentionally flat and desaturated, conveying Hendrix's sentiments about his time there.
Despite a few limitations, such as an average bitrate of 20.50 Mbps—which is somewhat low given the frenetic musical performances and rapid cuts—the digital origination and letterbox bars serve the compression well, minimizing visible artifacts. The film adopts a deliberate period look with added grain and a generally unpolished aesthetic. This results in a bit of a muddled appearance that might not appeal to all viewers but does not detract from its overall clarity. Depth and dimension are particularly well rendered in performance scenes, although black levels appear slightly faded, and the color reproduction, dictated by the film's style, still manages to bring vibrancy to the varied costumes.
In terms of visual fidelity, flesh tones are well-represented with decent facial textures, even if some aesthetic flaws are noticeable. The presence of grain adds to the film's raw look but can prove distracting for those accustomed to pristine transfers. Overall, the video quality of this Blu-ray release aligns well with the film’s creative intent and period-specific visuals while maintaining sufficient clarity and depth to engage viewers fully.
Audio: 56
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "Jimi: All Is by My Side" prominently features a lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack, centering around the music performances of Jimi Hendrix, recreated vocally by André Benjamin and on guitar by Waddy Wachtel. These performances resonate with fidelity to Hendrix's iconic style, delivering clarity that surpasses many original recordings. Standout scenes include the rendition of "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band" performed at the Savile Theatre and "Wild Thing" over the closing credits, both of which inject an authentic Hendrix atmosphere into the sound mix. Various period-specific songs also enhance the film's musical landscape, often serving as source music within the narrative.
The audio format is presented in English DTS-HD Master Audio, with English SDH subtitles available. Dynamics are handled with an old-school cinematic approach utilizing modern equipment, resulting in a nuanced yet occasionally subdued track. The low-frequency extension is adequately serviced by the accompanying music, offering sufficient engagement for the subwoofer during key moments. The surround sound presentation maintains a well-balanced mix, particularly shining during musical sequences where it becomes most effective in enveloping the listener.
Dialogue reproduction is somewhat inconsistent; while most lines are clear, Benjamin's near-perfect mimicry of Hendrix's speech can sometimes obscure clarity, reflecting Hendrix’s historically enigmatic diction. Despite this minor drawback, the overall soundscape constructed by the DTS-HD MA 5.1 track is immersive and faithful to the film’s homage to Jimi Hendrix’s legacy.
Extras: 11
The extras on the Blu-ray of "Jimi: All Is by My Side" offer a modest but intriguing look into the making of the film. The brief interview segment, "Music by Waddy, Lyrics by Danny," provides valuable insights from those who contributed to the film’s score, although it could have benefited from a more perceptive interview style to discern the musicians' deeper thoughts. The theatrical trailer resonates well, encapsulating the essence of Hendrix's journey with its impactful message. Start-up trailers, while skippable, are not otherwise accessible after the initial load.
Extras included in this disc:
- Music by Waddy, Lyrics by Danny: Short interview with Waddy Wachtel about scoring and performing guitar solos for the film.
- Theatrical Trailer: Captures the essence of Hendrix's journey with a powerful message.
- Additional Trailers: Includes previews for The Machine, Poker Night, and Ironclad: Battle for Blood.
Movie: 61
Jimi: All Is by My Side portrays the enigmatic rise of Jimi Hendrix with a focus on the year prior to his stardom. What stands out is André Benjamin's captivating portrayal of Hendrix, capturing both his mystical and vulnerable sides. Director John Ridley’s choice to eschew Hendrix's original music due to estate conflicts results in an inventive narrative that centers on Hendrix’s journey in the Greenwich Village scene of 1966, his relationship with Linda Keith (Imogen Poots), and his eventual discovery by Chas Chandler (Andrew Buckley). The assemblage of The Jimi Hendrix Experience, including bassist Noel Redding and drummer Mitch Mitchell, is depicted with the added flavor of historical authenticity despite slight fictional liberties.
Ridley’s script, criticized by some close to Hendrix for its composite character portrayals and historical inaccuracies, presents a compressed yet compelling glimpse of this legendary musician's early days. André Benjamin thoroughly embodies Hendrix’s aloofness and otherworldly charm. However, the film extends beyond his on-stage charisma, diving into the intricacies of his personal relationships, particularly with lovers Kathy Etchingham (Hayley Atwell) and groupie Ida (Ruth Negga). These interactions highlight Hendrix’s complex emotional availability and struggle with newfound fame, all against the backdrop of the turbulent 60s.
Technically, the film achieves an authentic 1960s setting through meticulous production design, shooting in Dublin for scenes set in London, and using period-appropriate footage. Editor Hank Corwin employs avant-garde editing techniques—jump cuts, overlays, and sound dropouts—which echo the psychedelic ethos without relying on clichéd visual effects. Ridley’s adept use of these elements creates a visceral representation of Hendrix’s world and underscores music’s profound emotional impact. Despite its narrative liberties, Jimi: All Is by My Side succeeds in capturing the essence of an icon on the cusp of greatness.
Total: 51
"Jimi: All Is By My Side" attempts to navigate the enigmatic figure of Jimi Hendrix, portrayed by Andre Benjamin, offering an introspective look at the early days of his career. Although the film struggles with the evident absence of Hendrix's actual music—a notable omission due to legal constraints—it compensates with a thoughtful narrative and solid performances. The cinematography and period-appropriate design are laudable, contributing to the overall authenticity and atmosphere of the biopic. However, certain aspects of the filmmaking could have been refined to enhance the storytelling, such as pacing and character development.
The Blu-ray release of the film is somewhat underwhelming in terms of technical excellence. Picture quality is serviceable but lacks the vibrant clarity expected from high-definition formats, which might disappoint some viewers hoping for a visually striking presentation. The audio track, although acceptable, does not fully leverage surround sound capabilities to immerse the audience in the musical scenes. Additionally, the disc's sparse extra features may leave admirals of Hendrix craving more in-depth content about his life and legacy.
In conclusion, "Jimi: All Is By My Side" may not be the definitive Hendrix biopic, but it provides a compelling glimpse into the formative years of the guitar legend. While its shortcomings—most notably the absence of Hendrix's original music—are hard to ignore, Andre Benjamin’s performance and the film’s respectful handling of its subject matter make it worth watching. Given the years it took to bring this story to life, it could be a while before we see another cinematic portrayal of Hendrix. Thus, despite some technical and narrative flaws, Ridley’s film captures the sense of incompleteness inherent in telling the story of an artist gone too soon.
Blu-ray.com review by Michael ReubenRead review here
Video: 90
XLrator Media's 1080p, AVC-encode Blu-ray features a sharply detailed, densely saturated image, whose rich reds, browns and golds may not precisely represent the textures of the period, but they accurately...
Audio: 80
Examples include the cover of "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band" that the Experience famously performed at the Savile Theatre on June 4, 1967 before an audience containing both George Harrison and...
Extras: 20
Additional Trailers: At startup, the disc plays trailers for The Machine, Poker Night and Ironclad: Battle for Blood, which can be skipped with the chapter forward button and are not otherwise available...
Movie: 70
As both a performer and a musician, guitarist Jimi Hendrix hit the world of popular music like a bolt of lightning, and it may be impossible to convey the sheer intensity of the impact to anyone who wasn't...
Total: 70
It's the nature of artists who die young to remain mysterious, because, no matter how advanced or mature their talent, their development as people has been cut short long before that talent has had an...
Why So Blu? review by Aaron NeuwirthRead review here
Video: 70
Black Levels: There’s a faded aspect to the film that keeps the black levels from being as deep as they could be, but they are still mostly solid....
Audio: 60
The old school approach to making this film with modern equipment does not backfire, but it does reflect a less than stellar track that is not always as lively when it needs to be.Low Frequency Extension:...
Extras: 10
This would have been a great time for John Ridley to make his presence, but alas, he is nowhere to be found....
Movie: 60
Total: 50
Still, Andre Benjamin does a commendable job as the famed guitar player in a film that I felt worked overall, especially if the viewer has at least a vague understanding of Jimi’s life....
Director: John Ridley
Actors: André 3000, Hayley Atwell, Imogen Poots
PlotSet in the vibrant London music scene of the 1960s, the story follows the early career of an unknown guitarist who would soon be catapulted to fame. The narrative begins with his discovery at the Cheetah Club in New York by Linda Keith, an influential figure with connections to the Rolling Stones. Persuaded by his undeniable talent, she convinces him to move to London to pursue his dream. Arriving in England, he faces cultural and professional challenges, but his exceptional prowess quickly garners the attention of key industry figures. They encourage him on a path that will reshape rock music.
Despite personal and professional hurdles, Including evolving complex relationships with Kathy Etchingham and others in his orbit, he slowly assembles a band that showcases his unique blend of blues, rock, and psychedelic sounds. As he begins to perform at iconic venues, it becomes clear that his revolutionary music style is unlike anything the world has seen before. His electrifying performances gather a following and lay the groundwork for his future legacy. However, balancing his rapid ascent with the demands of fame proves challenging as the pressures mount around him.
Writers: John Ridley
Release Date: 24 Oct 2014
Runtime: 118 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, Ireland, United Kingdom
Language: English