Ip Man 3 Blu-ray Review
Score: 69
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Ip Man 3 is a melodramatic yet entertaining kung-fu film with stellar A/V presentation, overshadowed only by the absence of Bruce Lee's deeper story and 3D features.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 74
Featuring a 2.35:1 1080p AVC encoded transfer from Well Go USA, 'Ip Man 3' delivers sharp, well-defined visuals with excellent fine detail, contrasting muted and bold color schemes, and robust imagery, though lacking the intended 3D effect which diminishes some immersive sequences.
Audio: 84
The Cantonese DTS:X and DTS-HD MA 7.1 tracks of 'Ip Man 3' deliver an immersive, dynamic audio experience with crystal clear dialogue, precise imaging, and powerful low-frequency effects, elevating the action sequences with unparalleled fidelity and spatial engagement. However, the English Dubbed DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix falls short, sounding canned with poor translation.
Extra: 43
The Blu-ray extras for 'Ip Man 3' offer a concise series of HD features, including a brief making-of segment and engaging interviews with stars Donnie Yen and Mike Tyson, but overall, the content lacks depth.
Movie: 53
Ip Man 3, starring Donnie Yen, offers satisfying martial arts action with impressive choreography by Yuen Woo Ping, despite its fiction-heavy plot involving Mike Tyson as the villain and limited screentime for Bruce Lee. The Blu-ray presentation by Well Go USA includes a Region A BD50 disc with fluid camera work but does not fulfill expectations for historical accuracy or deep drama.
Video: 74
The Blu-ray video presentation of "Ip Man 3," as offered by Well Go USA, is marked by its intentionally stylized visual design. The film employs a muted color scheme that complements its thematic and setting elements, utilizing shades of gray, black, and occasional splashes of crimson and muted sepia tones. This approach, enhanced by warm accents, maintains a monochromatic essence throughout. The balanced contrast enriches whites and grays without compromising detail, while blacks, though slightly washed out, still reveal discerning details in shadowy backgrounds. The video quality is notable for its clean rendering, enhancing depth and revealing fine details in objects, clothing, and characters' physical features.
Shot digitally with Arri Alexa cameras, the 1080p transfer in 2.35:1 AVC encoding provides a typically sharp and well-defined image with robust fine details. Close-ups showcase the intricate finery of costumes and the rough texture of elements like rickshaw handles. Despite the absence of 3D capability in this US release, a strong sense of depth remains due to the solid black levels. Some scenes display yellow and blue tinges due to actual lighting techniques rather than post-production alterations. While dimly lit interior sequences occasionally exhibit murkiness, especially in blue-tinged scenes, overall imagery maintains sharpness and precision without stability issues or compression anomalies.
Moreover, the visual presentation includes some well-executed slow-motion sequences that offer impressive fine detail resolution, such as water droplets dispersing post-kick. The palette, though favoring heightened blues or yellows in some scenes, appears robust and natural. While the absence of the 3D release for the US market limits some of the film's intended visual impact—particularly in action sequences designed for depth—the 2D transfer remains impressive in detail and composition, effectively capturing the intricate period-costuming and production design work.
Audio: 84
"Ip Man 3" Blu-ray boasts an exceptionally immersive audio presentation with both Cantonese DTS:X and DTS-HD MA 7.1 tracks. The 7.1 DTS-HD MA mix, available in multiple languages including English, Spanish, and French, is particularly impressive in its clarity and dynamic range. Dialog is presented with crystal-clear intonation, full-bodied texture, and impeccable room penetration. During the action sequences, the sound of breaking objects, hand-to-hand combat, and Kenji Kawai’s beautifully orchestrated music shines through with sparkling clarity. Imaging across the front soundstage is precise, and the low-frequency detail resonates with palpable impact, providing an engaging and authentic home theater experience.
The Cantonese DTS:X track elevates the experience further with enhanced spatial effects and overhead wafting of sonic information. Directionality is expertly handled, ensuring that the placement of combatants within the frame is fully realized. The whack of wooden poles and the silvery sound of blades meeting each other are rendered viscerally, adding depth to each scene. Dialogue remains cleanly rendered and well-prioritized throughout, contributing to a problem-free auditory experience. The sense of space and dimension is particularly notable in larger fight scenes, while even smaller, more intimate settings maintain clear imaging and direction. However, it’s worth noting that the English Dubbed DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix falls short, sounding canned and offering a poor translation that can miss important dialogue moments.
Extras: 43
The extras on the Blu-ray of "Ip Man 3" boast a variety of insightful and engaging content, although some sections are notably brief. The "Making Of" featurette, divided into two parts focusing on story and action, provides a modest overview but lacks in-depth exploration. The interviews are a highlight, particularly those with Donnie Yen and Mike Tyson, which offer fascinating behind-the-scenes perspectives. Tyson’s reflections provide an intriguing look at his experience working on the film. The behind-the-scenes footage is commendable, giving viewers a glimpse of the production process. Despite the limited duration of some features, the included trailers round out a well-curated selection of extras.
Extras included in this disc:
Making of: Story: Brief EPK feature on the story elements.
Making of: Action: Brief EPK feature on the action sequences.
Interview with Donnie Yen: Insights from lead actor Donnie Yen.
Interview with Mike Tyson: Mike Tyson discusses his role and experience.
Interview with Donnie and Mike Tyson together: Joint interview capturing their dynamic.
Interview with Wilson Yip: Director's perspective on the film.
Behind-the-Scenes look: Glimpse into the production process.
Teaser Trailer: Short promotional teaser.
Theatrical Trailer: Official theatrical trailer.
International Trailer: Global edition trailer.
Movie: 53
"Ip Man 3" immerses viewers in 1959 Hong Kong, where Master Ip (Donnie Yen) faces off against Frank, an intimidating property developer portrayed by Mike Tyson. The plot revolves around Ip Man's mission to protect his son's school from Frank's menacing gangsters. As the school becomes a battleground, Yen's unparalleled martial arts prowess is on full display, delivering intense set pieces and an array of bone-crunching confrontations. While this entry leans heavily on fictionalized elements, it provides the physical theatrics expected from the franchise without delving deep into historical accuracy.
A notable narrative thread features rising martial artist Cheung Tin-Chi (Zhang Jin), who competes with Ip Man both personally and professionally. Their sons' rivalry spills over into a broader conflict, culminating in a crescendo of combat scenes. Despite the simplistic and melodramatic subplots, the film shines through its choreography and Yen's commitment to the role. However, the tepid portrayal of Bruce Lee (Danny Chan), reduced to cameo appearances, fails to satisfy those looking for an in-depth exploration of the iconic student-teacher relationship. While Tyson's Frank adds a layer of schlock cinema charm, his character lacks the depth to be taken seriously.
For martial arts enthusiasts, "Ip Man 3" offers a visually engaging experience with fluid camera work and dynamic choreography by Yuen Woo Ping. However, its detachment from historical context and reliance on over-the-top dramatization may disappoint those seeking a true-to-life depiction of Ip Man's legacy. Donnie Yen's performance remains compelling, yet the film's inability to connect substantial elements of Ip Man’s famous mentorship with Bruce Lee marks it as a showcase of martial prowess rather than a definitive biographical piece. Despite its flaws, "Ip Man 3" captivates through sheer entertainment, drawing on the quintessential spirit of action-packed cinema.
Total: 69
"Ip Man 3" delivers a blend of action and drama that leans heavily on Donnie Yen's magnetic martial arts performance, albeit falling short on the depth many fans anticipated. While the storyline is at times melodramatic and occasionally ventures into camp, particularly during Mike Tyson’s scenes, the technical execution of this Blu-ray release is laudable. The film’s cinematography, fight choreography, and overall visual fidelity are captured in stunning detail, presenting a compelling case for enthusiasts of martial arts cinema.
From an audio-visual standpoint, Well Go USA has done an exemplary job with this Blu-ray edition. The crisp picture quality and robust sound design ensure an engaging viewing experience, despite some audiences potentially feeling disappointed by the lack of a 3D viewing option. The supplemental features are minimal, but the sheer enjoyment derived from the high-quality presentation of the film's expert choreography compensates for this shortcoming.
In conclusion, while "Ip Man 3" may not fully satisfy those longing for a deeper exploration of Bruce Lee's early years with Master Ip, it excels as a piece of entertaining kung-fu cinema. The impeccable Blu-ray transfer significantly enhances its appeal, marking this release as highly recommended for both long-time fans of the series and martial arts enthusiasts alike.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
The image is typically sharp and well defined, with some excellent fine detail in close-ups revealing the finery of some of the nice costumes or elements like the roughhewn handles of a rickshaw....
Audio: 100
Directionality is extremely well handled, with nice attention paid to where various combatants are in the frame....
Extras: 40
Mike Tyson (1080i; 7:27) Donnie Yen and Mike Tyson on Ip Man Press Day (1080i; 5:27) Wilson Yip, Director (1080i; 9:05) Behind the Scenes (1080p; 2:19) Teaser (1080p; 1:19) Trailer (1080p; 2:07)...
Movie: 60
The various representatives claiming control of Bruce Lee's likeness may have successfully prevented a decent depiction of the relationship between master and student, necessitating several trips to a...
Total: 70
As it stands, Ip Man 3 presents a needlessly melodramatic tale that is a bit on the campy side at times (at least when Mike Tyson lumbers into view), but which provides Yen ample opportunity to flex his...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Because of the strong black levels, there is still a nice sense of depth to the image, but at times, you can just feel the 3D effects trying to reach out and hook you into the film....
Audio: 100
There is also an English Dubbed DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix, but it sounds horribly canned, and if you leave the subtitles on, it's a pretty poor translation as you actually miss a number of important dialogue moments....
Extras: 40
Broken out between "Story" and "Action" this is an incredibly brief EPK extra feature that doesn't get into much detail....
Movie: 60
Apparently Donnie Yen says he's through with the franchise, but he said that after 'Ip Man 2,' so if this franchise does continue, my hope is that they abandon any and all references to Bruce Lee and just...
Total: 60
However, if you let that hiccup go and just accept this film as a piece of B-Movie schlock kung-fu entertainment, 'Ip Man 3' delivers a lot of fun....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 90
Otherwise I find the quality of the video to be high, with clean rendering that draws out plenty of subtle refinement and delineation that enhances depth and reveals fine detail in objects, clothing, and...
Audio: 90
The sounds of breaking objects, hand to hand combat, and Kenji Kawai’s beautifully orchestrated music is reproduced with sparkling clarity....
Extras: 60
Two Part Making of feature that looks at the story and action – 6 minutes (HD) Interview with Mike Tyson – 5 minutes (HD) Interview with Donnie Yen – 6 minutes (HD) Interview with Donnie and Mike Tyson...
Movie: 50
In order to protect the school Master Ip recruits his students and finds himself in a large scale face off against the developer’s henchmen after they kidnap children from the school....
Total: 73
Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player Samsung UBD-K8500 Ultra HD Blu-ray Player Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo"...
Director: Wilson Yip
Actors: Donnie Yen, Lynn Xiong, Jin Zhang
PlotIn 1959 Hong Kong, the legendary Wing Chun grandmaster faces new challenges as he settles into a quieter life with his family. His son, Ip Ching, attends an elementary school that becomes the target of a ruthless property developer looking to usurp the land for his own gain. The developer hires a local gang led by a crude and powerful adversary to intimidate the school into submission. As tensions rise, the grandmaster takes it upon himself to protect the school and its people, relying on his extraordinary martial arts skills. During this conflict, he encounters Cheung Tin-chi, another Wing Chun practitioner whose ambitions and family circumstances create an intricate dynamic between them.
Amid these external threats, the grandmaster also faces personal trials, including his wife’s ailing health, which puts immense emotional strain on him. His dedication to his family and his principles are tested as he balances multiple responsibilities. Through numerous confrontations and alliances, both physical and emotional, he remains steadfast in his commitment to justice and honor. The grandmaster’s unwavering resolve and martial prowess underscore the complexities of a life devoted to protecting others, even as darkness looms from many directions.
Writers: Tai-Lee Chan, Lai-Yin Leung, Edmond Wong
Release Date: 24 Dec 2015
Runtime: 105 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: China, Hong Kong
Language: Cantonese, English