The Greatest Game Ever Played Blu-ray Review
Score: 71
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
A beautifully crafted film with standout performances, 'The Greatest Game Ever Played' excels in both its clear picture and perfect sound, making it a must-have Blu-ray.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 73
The Blu-ray of 'The Greatest Game Ever Played' showcases vibrant and tonally rich colors with a pleasant 1080p, 1.85:1 transfer. It excels in detail, especially in clothing and facial close-ups, and maintains impressive clarity even in shadowy scenes. Minor issues like boosted whites and occasional blurriness don't detract from its high-quality, film-like presentation.
Audio: 70
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix in 'The Greatest Game Ever Played' delivers engaging surround sound, effective front-to-rear pans, and clear dialogue. With strong bass during intense scenes and distinct music score reproduction, it creates an immersive, well-balanced soundstage that enhances the film's atmosphere.
Extra: 63
"The Greatest Game Ever Played Blu-ray extras include two informative yet sometimes tedious audio commentaries by Director Bill Paxton and Writer Mark Frost, a 15-minute on-set featurette, a concise 6-minute documentary on the real-life inspirations, and a valuable 25-minute 1963 interview with Francis Ouimet.”
Movie: 80
'The Greatest Game Ever Played' transcends the sports film genre, presenting a meticulously directed, emotionally powerful tale of underdogs in the rigid class systems of the early 1900s, with standout performances from Shia LaBeouf and Stephen Dillane, immersive visual effects, and compelling cinematography.
Video: 73
The Blu-ray presentation of "The Greatest Game Ever Played" delivers a visually arresting experience. The 1080p, 1.85:1-framed transfer provides bold, vibrant, and tonally rich primary colors that are particularly eye-catching in high definition. Enhanced contrast occasionally overdrives whites, but it generally amplifies the film's brightly colored outdoor scenes. Black levels are consistently deep, and shadow detail remains strong, though stability can vary slightly from scene to scene. Notably, the video presentation exhibits excellent image delineation, crisp refinement, and appreciable dimensional perspective during long-range camera pans. A subtle layer of film grain adds a finishing touch to its nearly pristine quality, granting it a theater-like appearance that enhances the viewing experience.
Detail in "The Greatest Game Ever Played" impresses throughout. The texture in the period clothing and intricate patterns on tablecloths and wallpaper are rendered with stunning clarity. Facial close-ups reveal fine details like pores and hairs, contributing to the film's overall lifelike appearance. Particularly striking are the greens of the golf course and the lush fairways, rendered with a beautiful vibrancy that stands out. The montage during the soggy third round of the U.S. Open showcases lifelike rain effects that drench the screen convincingly. Although flesh tones sometimes veer slightly towards red and some scenes appear a bit soft — an innate characteristic of the photography — these are minor quibbles in an otherwise extraordinary video transfer.
In addition to its technical strengths, the transfer benefits from a Kodachrome-like look, evoking an early 1900s aesthetic that fits the film's historical setting. Detailed scenes, like a character puffing a smoke ring that remarkably encircles a ball on a pool table, add to the visual allure. Apart from a minuscule bit of aliasing in specific camera pans, there are no significant flaws deterring from the disc's top-tier video quality. This Blu-ray's well-rounded presentation ensures a high-quality and immersive viewing experience on large displays.
Audio: 70
The audio presentation of "The Greatest Game Ever Played" on Blu-ray is a robust DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix that impressively utilizes all channels to create an immersive experience. The sound design features dynamic and engaging surround sound, with a noticeable emphasis on front-to-rear pans, simulating a three-dimensional effect particularly well when the golf ball is driven directly from the tee into the camera. Rhythmic low-frequency energy intensifies as the ball approaches, adding tactile strength and enhancing the realism. The excellent integration across the front and rear soundstages ensures seamless effects and proportional levels correlating well with the on-screen action.
Brian Tyler's rousing score is a standout, with distinctly clear instrumentation that occupies the front soundstage complemented by well-balanced rear channel ambience. Strong percussive transients provide deep, rich bass, enveloping the listening area. Dialogue is well-defined and lucid through the center channel, positioned slightly in front of the left/right speakers within its acoustic space in the sound field. This allows for effortless distinction of pitch and inflection changes in voices. The front channel separation and imaging are excellent, while surround activity is prevalent, creating an enveloping atmosphere with sounds of the game, crowd reactions, and outdoor ambiance.
Though primarily driven by dialogue and music, the soundtrack also excels in replicating environmental effects scattered across the front half of the soundstage. Crowd applause, insect buzzing in early Massachusetts mornings, and detailed directional effects such as a golf ball rolling across a wooden floor are rendered precisely. This sound mix doesn't aim to overwhelm but effectively supports the material, providing a believable atmosphere and ensuring that intense scenes are accompanied by appropriate deep bass. Overall, the audio mix elevates the film's period setting and narrative.
Extras: 63
The Blu-ray of "The Greatest Game Ever Played" offers a substantial collection of bonus features that provide insightful context and enriching experiences for fans. Leading the lineup are two robust commentary tracks: Director Bill Paxton elaborates on technical aspects, from shot composition to thematic elements, while Writer Mark Frost delves into historical backgrounds and character insights, linking real-life events to their cinematic portrayal. "A View from the Gallery" gives a behind-the-scenes glimpse with cast and crew discussions, while "Two Legends and the Greatest Game" presents a concise documentary focusing on the true stories of Harry Vardon and Francis Ouimet. Most notably, "From Caddie to Champion" showcases a vintage 1963 interview with Francis Ouimet, bringing invaluable historical perspective that is both engaging and informative.
Extras included in this disc:
- Filmmaker's Audio Commentary: Director Bill Paxton details the film's production.
- Writer's Audio Commentary: Mark Frost discusses historical accuracies and character insights.
- A View from the Gallery: On the Set: Behind-the-scenes look at filmmaking.
- Two Legends and the Greatest Game: Documentary on Harry Vardon and Francis Ouimet.
- From Caddie to Champion: Francis Ouimet: 1963 interview providing historical context.
Movie: 80
"The Greatest Game Ever Played," from Walt Disney Pictures, is an exemplary sports drama that masterfully highlights the triumph of human spirit over societal constraints. Directed by Bill Paxton, the film captures the indomitable will of young Francis Ouimet (Shia LaBeouf) as he defies social boundaries to compete against his idol, Harry Vardon (Stephen Dillane), in the 1913 U.S. Open. LaBeouf delivers a heartfelt performance as Ouimet, a Massachusetts caddie turned golfer who battles class prejudice, particularly from his pragmatic father, played with raw depth by Elias Koteas. Stephen Dillane's portrayal of Vardon, haunted by his modest origins despite his legendary status, provides a poignant counterbalance, making both competitors equally compelling.
The movie transcends the boundaries of a conventional sports film by delving deep into issues of class struggle prevalent in the early 1900s. Francis and Vardon's parallel stories of overcoming humble beginnings add layers of emotional resonance and societal critique. The tension between Francis and his father underscores the cultural expectations of the time, articulating themes of persisting through adversity and chasing one's dreams. Meanwhile, Vardon's battles with his aristocratic overseers add an additional layer of complexity, enhancing the film’s thematic richness.
Paxton’s direction is complemented by Shane Hurlbut’s evocative cinematography and Brian Tyler’s rousing score. The use of visual effects to simulate golf shots offers an immersive experience that enhances the narrative without distracting from it. Whether it’s the sweeping fairways or the meticulously detailed period settings, every frame is crafted to draw the viewer into this historically poignant underdog tale. With standout performances from the cast, including a scene-stealing turn by young Josh Flitter as Ouimet’s caddy, and a meticulous attention to authenticity, "The Greatest Game Ever Played" is both a stirring sports drama and an intricate portrait of early 20th-century societal barriers.
Total: 71
"The Greatest Game Ever Played" Blu-ray delivers an exceptional cinematic experience with top-notch technical execution, cementing its status as one of the finest films in the sports genre. The film, directed with keen precision and filled with standout performances, captivates audiences with its dramatic narrative and compelling emotional depth. Disney's meticulous attention to detail is evident in every frame, resulting in a high-definition transfer that is both crystal clear and remarkably film-like. The visual fidelity presents the rich period details and lush landscapes of early 20th-century golf in exquisite quality, making the historical drama visually engaging and immersive.
Accompanying the superb visuals is a pristine lossless soundtrack that enhances the viewer's immersion, delivering clear dialogue, atmospheric ambient sounds, and a robust musical score. The audio mix is well-balanced, ensuring that every sound element complements the on-screen action seamlessly. Despite some limitations in special features, which could have provided additional context and behind-the-scenes insights, the Blu-ray package remains impressive due to its superior audio-visual quality.
In conclusion, "The Greatest Game Ever Played" on Blu-ray is a must-have for both sports enthusiasts and movie collectors. The strong film-like transfer combined with the excellent soundtrack ensures a sporting narrative that's as gripping as it is visually stunning. Disney’s dedication to maintaining high standards in their releases is clear here; thus, "The Greatest Game Ever Played" comes highly recommended for anyone seeking a high-quality viewing experience.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Although flesh tones sometimes veer towards the red end of the spectrum and the occasional shot takes on a slightly blurry appearance, this transfer generally appears well-done and film-like throughout....
Audio: 80
The soundtrack also features a nice array of environmental effects that play across the front; whether crowd applause during the golf sequences or the buzzing of insects heard in the distance of the early...
Extras: 60
On the Set of 'The Greatest Game Ever Played' (480p, 15:22) features Director Bill Paxton and others speaking on the film's unique style, the assemblage of the cast and crew, sets, costumes, the performances...
Movie: 90
Depicted as a good man who golfs not for country, money, or the satisfaction of others but rather for himself and to prove that he's the best, Vardon's background and shunning of the sport's set-in-stone...
Total: 80
Featuring a fantastic story wrapped up in a fine cinematic technical achievement, The Greatest Game Ever Played makes for one of the best films of its kind, a truly moving and heroic picture that manages...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
I did spot just a miniscule bit of aliasing as the camera pans over a thatched roof cottage, but it didn't distract from the film....
Audio: 100
There are a lot of crowd scenes in this film - a ballroom, a bar, and of course a packed golf course - and the surround channels handle it perfectly....
Extras: 60
This is the standard cast and crew back-patting segment where Paxton and Frost relate what it was like to work with the actors, composer, cinematographer, etc....
Movie: 80
We get to travel along with the ball as it soars through the air, and when Harry is up at the tee, he imagines the crowds of people, the trees, and all the distractions disappearing until all that's left...
Total: 80
Maybe you can gripe about the sparse special features, but when the audio and video quality are this good, there's nothing else to worry about. '...
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 86
Those few nitpicks aside this is a well rounded and rather pristine video presentation that occasionally offers eye popping visuals that enhance its theater like quality....
Audio: 88
Surround activity is prevalent as the many sounds of the game, music, and exterior venues are played back with appreciable spatial dimension that create an enveloping atmosphere in the rear of the room....
Extras: 80
A view from the gallery: On the set of The greatest game ever played - 15 minute featurette Two legends and the greatest game - 6 minute documentary From caddie to champion: Francis Ouimet - 25 minute...
Movie: 80
Soon, with the help of his spunky 10-year-old caddy Eddie, Francis boldly breaks down all barriers with a thrilling display of unrivaled drive, skill, and heart...and challenges the golf pro for the U.S....
Total: 84
Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Philips TSU9400 Pro Series Touch Panel Remote Control Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio QS8 Quadpolar speakers SV Sound PB-13 Ultra (Rosenut...
Director: Bill Paxton
Actors: Shia LaBeouf, Stephen Dillane, Elias Koteas
PlotIn the early 20th century, a young amateur golfer from a working-class background, Francis Ouimet, dreams of competing at the highest level of the sport. Growing up near The Country Club in Brookline, Massachusetts, Francis is deeply inspired by legends such as Harry Vardon, a British champion golfer from humble beginnings himself. Despite the social barriers and the disapproval of his father, Francis is determined to prove his worth in a game dominated by the wealthy elite. His natural talent catches the attention of local golfers and club members, but his journey is fraught with obstacles, including his family's financial struggles and the rigid class distinctions of the time.
With the support of his mother and a young caddie named Eddie, Francis embarks on a quest to qualify for the U.S. Open. The story delves into his relentless training and indomitable spirit as he faces off against seasoned professionals and societal prejudice. Along the way, Francis forms an unexpected bond with his idol, Harry Vardon, who is also dealing with his own set of challenges, including the pressure to maintain his status as one of the world's top golfers. The narrative follows Francis’ journey through the trials and tribulations leading up to one of the most memorable moments in golf history, highlighting themes of perseverance, passion, and breaking down social barriers.
Writers: Mark Frost
Release Date: 30 Sep 2005
Runtime: 120 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States, Canada
Language: English