Made of Honor Blu-ray Review
Score: 56
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
The Blu-ray of "Made of Honor" boasts excellent audiovisual quality and humorous extras, but the film itself is clichéd and problematic in its portrayal of stereotypes.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 64
Despite its lackluster script, 'Made of Honor' boasts an impressive Blu-ray presentation with its theatrically correct 2.35:1 aspect ratio, encoded at 1080P using the AVC-MPEG4 codec. The BD-50 dual-layered disc delivers immaculate flesh tones, vivid color stability, rich black levels, and fine detail, particularly in the scenic highlands of Scotland.
Audio: 54
Featuring a lossless Dolby TrueHD 5.1 track, 'Made of Honor' offers clear dialogue and a well-balanced audio mix, with ambient surround effects and minimal low-frequency engagement, making it serviceable but not standout.
Extra: 56
The Blu-ray extras for 'Made of Honor' offer a range of high-definition featurettes, deleted scenes, and director Paul Weiland's witty commentary, enhancing the overall experience with insights into production design and behind-the-scenes humor, although some content remains standard promotional material.
Movie: 36
"Made of Honor" divides viewers between enjoying its light-hearted comedy targeted at female audiences and seeing it as a hollow, clichéd, and offensive romantic comedy. Despite some appealing Scottish landscapes, the film's reliance on stereotypes and tired tropes detracts from its overall value.
Video: 64
Presented in its theatrically correct aspect ratio of 2.35:1 and encoded at 1080P using the AVC-MPEG4 codec, the Blu-ray presentation of "Made of Honor" demonstrates commendable visual fidelity. The picture quality on this BD-50 dual layered disc is outstanding, with flesh tones rendered immaculately throughout the film. The color palette is vibrant and rich, devoid of any color bleed or "fizz" often seen in bright hues like yellow or red. Stabilization of colors is notably solid, consistent with Sony's recent high standards in their releases. Detail levels remain high across the board; although a minor presence of grain exists, it does not detract from the viewing experience. Scenes filmed in New York's Central Park, especially, are sharply detailed, showcasing impressive clarity in the background skyscrapers.
Moreover, the AVC codec utilized here averages around 30 Mbps, further enhancing the crystal-clear presentation. Contrast is handled exceptionally well, with finely tuned film grain contributing to a highly textured and authentic visual experience. Black levels are deep and rich, without any hint of blooming flaws in the bright whites. Textural details on skin, clothing, and hair are particularly pronounced, delivering a life-like quality without any distracting digital noise reduction or mastering artifacts. The faithful color reproduction is highlighted notably in the Scottish highlands scenes, which stand out as a visual treat. Overall, this Blu-ray release exhibits no mastering flaws or film artifacts, ensuring a top-tier viewing experience even if the film's narrative doesn't quite measure up to its visual prowess.
Audio: 54
The audio presentation of the Blu-ray for "Made of Honor" features a lossless Dolby TrueHD 5.1 track. Sony has included tracks in multiple languages, like English, Portuguese, and French in TrueHD, and Spanish and Thai in Dolby Digital 5.1. The film’s dialogue-heavy nature ensures that clarity is paramount, and the TrueHD English track handles this adeptly, with dialogue consistently clear and firmly anchored to the center channel. Ambient sounds are distributed through the rear channels, enhancing outdoor scenes and providing a subtle but effective surround experience.
While "Made of Honor" does not push the boundaries of audio dynamism, it offers a well-mastered mix. Surround effects are minimal, comprised mostly of ambient noises and occasional musical cues that populate the rear channels. The low-frequency effects (LFE) are used sparingly, providing some heft during party scenes and minimal action sequences. Although it doesn't feature the explosive or gunshot-heavy sequences that typically showcase a system's full capabilities, the audio mix serves its purpose effectively, ensuring dialogue intelligibility and maintaining an overall pleasant listening experience without any notable flaws.
Extras: 56
The Blu-ray release of "Made of Honor" offers a robust suite of extras, enhancing its appeal with high-definition content and engaging behind-the-scenes insights. Key supplemental features are presented in HD, creating an immersive experience. Director Paul Weiland provides an entertaining and detailed commentary, filled with humorous anecdotes and scene-specific insights. The "Save the Date: The Making of Made of Honor" featurette offers a brisk but informative look into the film's production, capturing candid moments from cast and crew. Production designer Kalina Ivanov's "Three Weddings and a Skyline" provides a fascinating dive into the thematic and aesthetic choices that shaped the film's set designs. Included deleted scenes extend existing sequences, adding further context to the narrative. Additionally, promotional content, including trailers for various Sony Pictures releases, rounds out the disc's offerings.
Extras included in this disc:
- Save the Date: The Making of Made of Honor: A look into the film’s production process.
- Three Weddings and a Skyline: Insights from the production designer on set design and color themes.
- Deleted Scenes: Additional content expanding on existing film sequences.
- Directors Commentary: Scene-by-scene insights with director Paul Weiland.
- High Definition Trailers: Previews of other Sony Pictures releases.
Movie: 36
"Made of Honor" entrenches itself in clichéd romantic comedy territory, appealing primarily to a female audience with a focus on frothy humor. At its core, the narrative follows the conventional 'childhood friends who find love' trope, set against the glitzy backdrop of New York City. This movie attempts to blend light-hearted comedy and romance but often finds itself smothered by clichés and stereotypical portrayals that end up overshadowing any potential charm. The lead performances by Patrick Dempsey as Tom and Michelle Monaghan as Hannah are modestly engaging, but they struggle against a script that offers little originality or depth.
Technically, the film is a predictable venture filled with attractive but largely implausible characters. Patrick Dempsey's "McDreamy" image cannot rescue the stale plot twists, and the supporting cast does little to enhance the overall quality due to their tokenized roles. There’s an underlying thread of xenophobia with the portrayal of Scottish characters and culture, which only adds to the movie's list of cinematic missteps. While there are some aesthetically pleasing shots of Scottish landscapes, these moments are fleeting and fail to compensate for the lackluster storyline. The film’s supposed humor and attempts at modern-day romance are periodically ruined by its superficial treatment of character dynamics and societal norms.
Despite its light-hearted premise, "Made of Honor" disappoints by relying heavily on expletives and crude content to fill the narrative void. Its execution is marred by tasteless comedic attempts and a rather offensive undertone towards gender and cultural representation. Rather than enriching its genre, this film leaves viewers grappling with why such uninspired content continues to receive the green light from Hollywood studios. The overall experience feels padded and unnecessarily stretched, making this romantic comedy a regrettably forgettable cinematic venture.
Total: 56
"Made of Honor" as a Blu-ray release provides a high-caliber audio-visual experience, consistent with Sony's top-tier production standards. The high-definition picture quality is commendable, showcasing well-executed cinematography with vibrant colors and crisp details. The sound design is equally impressive, featuring a balanced and immersive auditory experience that enhances the film’s romantic and comedic elements. The Blu-ray edition also includes several featurettes that carry over the film's humor, offering viewers behind-the-scenes insights and glimpses of the cast's on-set camaraderie.
Regarding the film itself, "Made of Honor" is a standard romantic comedy with a predictable plotline and stereotyped characters. It follows familiar tropes without innovating or adding substantial value to the genre. The narrative relies heavily on clichéd story devices and doesn't shy away from overt and subtle gender-based stereotypes, which detract from its overall appeal. Despite these criticisms, some viewers, particularly within its target demographic, may enjoy its light-hearted and humorous aspects. The film succeeded in engaging certain audiences, evident in their laughter and enjoyment during viewing sessions.
As a Blu-ray package, "Made of Honor" boasts impressive picture and sound quality, underscoring Sony's commitment to delivering high-quality home entertainment products. The supplementary content, though brief, adds a layer of enjoyment for fans of the film. While the movie may not resonate with all viewers due to its clichéd storyline and problematic character portrayals, it can serve as a satisfactory option for a cozy night in with loved ones. Thus, if you're looking to unwind with a romantic comedy, this might just fit the bill as long as you temper your expectations regarding the film's originality and depth.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 80
Detail is high all the way through also - there is a small element of grain but it doesn't detract from the overall viewing experience....
Audio: 70
But what we do have is a soundtrack that does its job very well - the aforementioned dialogue is clear and concise and is cemented firmly to the centre channel....
Extras: 60
Made Of Honour comes complete with all the extras that were included on the SD DVD - but the majority have been given a High Definition makeover...lets have a look at what's on the wedding present table...
Movie: 70
Made with the female audience at the forefront of the makers mind, I found the comedy side a little more interesting than the romantic one....
Total: 70
The extras package carries some of the humour from the film over into the all too brief featurettes and shows that this must have been a fun film to make....
Blu-ray.com review by Lindsay MayerRead review here
Video: 90
Textures on skin, clothes, and hair sport a fine amount of detail, and no evidence of digital noise reduction or any other mastering tricks is apparent....
Audio: 80
Being light in tone, the film obviously doesn't give the ol' speakers a workout, but the scoring and the audio mix overall are well-mastered and boast a good level of clarity....
Extras: 60
Two brief Deleted Scenes are also provided - Locker Room has a bit of additional discussion between Tom and his buddies, and Highland Games is essentially an extended edition of the existing highland games...
Movie: 10
It was a harsh example of the financial concerns of major Hollywood studios in crumbling economic times; it shows that even names with a generous amount of clout behind them, like Spielberg and Jackson,...
Total: 40
How do projects like these receive financing, when a whole library full of well-written premises and imaginative takes on well-known plot devices stagnate on a shelf, or in the minds of would-be creators?...
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 0
Audio: 0
Extras: 0
Movie: 0
Total: 0
Director: Paul Weiland
Actors: Patrick Dempsey, Michelle Monaghan, Kevin McKidd
PlotTom Bailey is a successful and charming New York City ladies' man who enjoys his single life, indulging in casual flings and short-term relationships. His best friend since college, Hannah, is the one constant female presence in his life. As Hannah makes plans to travel to Scotland for work, Tom begins to realize he has stronger feelings for her than mere friendship. When Hannah returns from her trip, she surprises Tom with the news that she has gotten engaged to a wealthy and handsome Scotsman named Colin.
Tom is initially devastated but resolves to support Hannah by agreeing to be her “maid of honor.” This role puts him in an unexpected position, challenging his friendship and newfound feelings for Hannah, all while contending with his dislike for Colin. As the wedding preparations progress, Tom's feelings for Hannah deepen, and he struggles with whether to reveal them or risk losing her forever. Tom must navigate the complexities of love and friendship as he grapples with revealing his true emotions before it’s too late.
Writers: Adam Sztykiel, Deborah Kaplan, Harry Elfont
Release Date: 02 May 2008
Runtime: 101 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, United Kingdom
Language: English, Gaelic