Munich Blu-ray Review
Score: 77
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'Munich' impresses with its craft, relevance, and bold pursuit of peace; it's highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 81
Munich's Blu-ray release showcases sharp, detailed visuals with a mood-setting color palette, despite minor aliasing. The transfer, faithful to Spielberg and Kaminski's design, offers a realistic, immersive experience.
Audio: 81
Munich's 5.1 DTS-HD MA soundtrack offers a realistic and expressive experience, capturing detailed soundscapes and dialogue clearly, complemented by John Williams' score, ensuring an immersive audio journey.
Extra: 51
The Munich Blu-ray extras, ported from a limited 2006 DVD, explore its making, cast, design, and Spielberg's intentions, minus the DVD's booklet.
Movie: 96
Munich" is a masterful Spielberg drama on the ethics of vengeance, blending historical tragedy with a soulful exploration of its moral toll.
Video: 81
Steven Spielberg's "Munich," captured through Janusz Kaminski's expert lens, presents a visual feast in its Blu-ray incarnation. The film, uniquely processed photochemically, stands out with a transfer that boasts incredible sharpness and a remarkably detailed image. The 1080p, AVC-encoded presentation exhibits a purposeful color grading that delineates the varied locales Spielberg's narrative traverses. From the verdant expanses of Papa's farm to the desaturated hues of Paris, each setting is imbued with a distinct palette achieved through meticulous filtering and developing processes. This transfer, aside from small instances of aliasing possibly due to slight sharpening, delivers a cinematic quality that perfectly aligns with Spielberg's vision for an immersive, almost documentary-like experience. The historical and recreated sequences blend seamlessly, bolstered by deep black levels and a fidelity that brings the era to life with astounding immediacy.
However, the video is not without its faults, albeit minor. The occasional presence of aliasing, notably in scenes involving intricate patterns or fast motion, slightly detracts from an otherwise pristine presentation. This issue, potentially a result of Universal's known tendency for light sharpening, is infrequent enough to not mar the overall viewing experience significantly. In addition to the visual prowess displayed in the clarity and precision of every frame, the average bitrate of 27.16 Mbps – reaching into the thirties during more dynamic sequences – guarantees that both action-packed and quieter moments retain their intended impact without compromise.
The presentation’s attempt at achieving visual authenticity does occasionally lead to scenes where contrasts are pushed to extremes, creating moments that feel overly harsh or drained of color. Despite this choice potentially alienating some viewers, it contributes to a stylistic consistency that complements the film's thematic undertones. Grain is purposely visible, enhancing the filmic texture without overwhelming the clarity that defines much of the release. Overall, with its lifelike textures, well-saturated primaries (with intentional subduing), and clean secondary hues, this Blu-ray release manages to capture the intricate details and cinematic scope of "Munich," making it an essential experience for aficionados of Spielberg's work.
Audio: 81
The Munich Blu-ray’s audio presentation is a marvel in its 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio soundtrack, designed meticulously to be as authentic and immersive as its visual counterparts. Sound designer Ben Burtt has masterfully woven an aural tapestry that brings the diverse European settings to life, from the bustling streets to the precision of a quiet room where only the pivotal sounds are accentuated. This immersive environment is further enriched by the distinct sounds of period-specific automobiles, the tension-building rumbles of airplanes, and the crisp detail of gunfires and explosions, all adding layers of depth and realism. The auditory experience is elevated by a crystal-clear delivery of dialogue, ensuring every accent and subtlety in language is captured, alongside the elegantly woven score by John Williams that seamlessly integrates with the ambient sounds, enhancing the emotional and narrative depth of the film.
Action scenes are rendered with a dynamic balance, showcasing a broad mid-range that captures the chaos of debris and bullets with staggering clarity and precision, making each moment engaging. The rear channels don’t just serve as an echo chamber but contribute to a genuinely three-dimensional space where ambient city sounds and wildlife noise provide a subtle yet convincing backdrop to the drama unfolding in the foreground. The seamless channel transitioning provides an enveloping experience, convincingly drawing the viewer into Spielberg's meticulously crafted world.
Despite not reaching the pinnacle of reference quality, especially when compared to its visual presentation, the audio mix stands out for its immersive qualities and technical excellence. The robust and responsive bass complements the meticulously separated and distinctly presented soundscape, from Williams’ stirring score to the nuanced environmental sounds and dialogue. The commitment to sonic detail ensures that both audiophiles and cinema fans will find the audio experience of Munich on Blu-ray both satisfying and deeply immersive, ensuring that every sound contributes meaningfully to the storytelling.
Extras: 51
The Blu-ray extras for "Munich" carry over from the 2006 2-Disc Collector's Edition DVD, notably lacking the previously included booklet of stills. The collection encompasses a range of featurettes that delve into the making of the film, highlighting discussions on the adaptation of real-life events, the meticulous effort in casting an international ensemble, and the challenges of authentically recreating the 1970s across various European locales. Spielberg's introduction sets the stage, addressing the film's controversial aspects and intentions. The detailed retrospectives on script development, production design, and emotional on-set experiences offer a comprehensive backstage passage into Spielberg's vision. Contributions from a vast selection of cast and crew, including insights on editing and sound design by industry veterans, round out an extras package that provides significant value to fans interested in the meticulous craft behind "Munich."
Extras included in this disc:
- Introduction by Director Steven Spielberg: Spielberg addresses the film's fictional aspects and his intentions.
- The Mission, The Team: A deep dive into script development and casting with Spielberg and other key figures.
- Memories of the Event: Cast and crew recount the Munich massacre and its impacts.
- Portrait of an Era: Production design insights reveal how various cities were recreated to bring the 1970s to life.
- The On-Set Experience: Emotional and technical challenges faced during production are explored.
- The International Cast: Focuses on the challenges and achievements in casting for the film's extensive character list.
- Editing, Sound, and Music: Insights into the film's post-production processes.
Movie: 96
Steven Spielberg's "Munich," a film that threads the delicate balance between historical retelling and fictional drama, resonates as a poignant exploration of the moral complexities surrounding vengeance. Released in theatres during the winter of 2006, the movie unspools the narrative of Israel's covert retaliation following the harrowing 1972 Summer Olympics massacre. This operation, dubbed Operation Wrath of God, sends Avner Kaufman (played with gripping intensity by Eric Bana) and his team on a clandestine mission to assassinate those responsible for the Munich tragedy. Adapted from George Jonas's book "Vengeance" by screenwriters Tony Kushner and Eric Roth, "Munich" delves deep into the psyche of individuals who cross moral lines for perceived righteous causes. The film is a meticulously crafted cinematic experience that marries Spielberg's directorial finesse with historical fact and ethical ambiguity, aiming to engage viewers in a dialogue rather than provide clear-cut answers.
At the heart of Spielberg's narrative is the theme of family—a motif that extends beyond the biological to encompass notions of national identity and belonging. Each member of Avner's squad is depicted as grappling with their own moral compass, as their lethal mission forces them to reckon with the personal costs of their actions. The distinctions between friend and foe blur as Spielberg weaves a complex tapestry of characters, each driven by their convictions, loyalties, and—invariably—love for their families. From Avner's painful separation from his pregnant wife to the dynamics within the Israeli hit squad and the conversations with their adversaries, "Munich" underscores how deeply personal the political can be. Spielberg’s deft handling of these themes elevates the narrative, ensuring that each sequence, from deadly confrontations to quieter moments of reflection, contributes to a multifaceted portrayal of revenge and its repercussions.
Visually, "Munich" is a testament to Spielberg’s mastery over the medium, with Janusz Kaminski’s cinematography capturing the escalating tension and stark realities of espionage. Through strategic use of reenactments intertwined with historical footage, the film achieves a gripping realism that both enthralls and educates viewers. Notably, Spielberg employs his craft not just to recount events but to challenge audiences to ponder the ethical dimensions of retribution. “Munich” does not glorify vengeance; instead, it invites a more nuanced contemplation of justice, loyalty, and the human costs of violence. As such, this presentation on Blu-ray not only preserves but enhances the potency of Spielberg's cinematic inquiry into these timeless dilemmas, ensuring its relevance remains undiminished by technological advancements or shifts in political landscapes.
Total: 77
Steven Spielberg's "Munich," based on George Jonas's 1984 insightful book, is an evocative portrayal of the intricate moral complexities surrounding vengeance, and how this relentless pursuit extracts a profound price from its seekers. With its release still stirring as much controversy now as it did initially, "Munich" demonstrates Spielberg's audacious talent in tackling such a radioactive topic. Emphasizing the continued topicality of its narrative, especially in light of world events since its release, the film emerges not only as an engrossing cinematic endeavor but also as a bold prayer for peace—a testament to Spielberg's unparalleled courage and artistry. The Blu-ray edition augments this experience with its reference-quality video and outstanding audio presentation, ensuring viewers appreciate the craft, artistry, and ingenuity Spielberg imbues in every frame.
The technical details of the Blu-ray contribute significantly to immersing viewers in the film's tense atmosphere. The continuously moving camera operated under Spielberg's direction intensifies this effect, capturing the essence of the story's moral dilemmas with striking clarity. Accompanied by a valuable assortment of supplements, this Blu-ray edition offers audiences an enriched viewing experience, delving deeper into the intriguing backstories and ethical questions that "Munich" raises. This comprehensive package is recommended not just for its cinematic brilliance but also for its technical superiority.
In conclusion, the Blu-ray presentation of "Munich" stands as a monumental achievement in home cinema. It not only showcases Spielberg's exceptional ability to navigate complex narratives with finesse but also elevates the viewing experience through stellar audiovisual quality and insightful extras. This Blu-ray edition is an essential acquisition for aficionados of cinema who appreciate films that provoke thought, challenge perceptions, and articulate an earnest yearning for peace amidst chaos. Its relevance persists, reminding us of cinema's power to reflect on past events while engaging with the present.
Blu-ray.com review by Michael ReubenRead review here
Video: 90
It is possible (note that I say "possible") that this results from the application of some light sharpening in some scenes, a practice for which Universal is well known, but the instances are sufficiently...
Audio: 100
John Williams' beautifully elegiac score, which incorporates the national anthem of Israel, underpins and sometimes soars above the aural mix with a quiet authority....
Extras: 70
Portrait of an Era (480i; 1.33:1; 13:17): Spielberg and production designer Rick Carter describe how Malta and Budapest became what Spielberg calls "backlots" for the many locations of Munich, including...
Movie: 100
It is probably this scene, more than any other, that has fueled charges that Munich justifies the PLO, but such charges have to overlook the increasingly brutal depictions of the Olympic massacre in the...
Total: 90
Spielberg was mocked in some quarters for calling Munich "a prayer for peace", but how many other filmmakers would have the guts (or the clout) to make an epic-scale film about such a radioactive subject�and...
High-Def Digest review by M. Enois DuarteRead review here
Video: 100
But in spite of these innovative choices, the high-def presentation, which for all intents and purposes probably comes from a new master of the original elements, is a sight to behold....
Audio: 90
The front soundstage exhibits a crisp, detailed mid-range with excellent separation and distinction in the action and John Williams's score, and movement between the channels is fluid....
Extras: 40
The On-Set Experience (SD, 14 min) — Exactly as the title sounds, the piece is littered with lots of BTS footage and film clips as the cast & crew talk about working with each other and the camaraderie....
Movie: 100
Director Steven Spielberg carefully manages the topic and the interchange with steady, skillful confidence, not favoring one side over the other as much as simply making known that revenge is born from...
Total: 80
Adapted from George Jonas's 1984 book, the film delves into the moral quandary of vengeance and the price paid by those obsessively seeking it while Spielberg keeps tensions high with a camera that's continuously...
Director: Steven Spielberg
Actors: Eric Bana, Daniel Craig, Marie-Josée Croze
PlotIn the aftermath of the shocking massacre at the 1972 Munich Olympics, where eleven Israeli athletes were brutally killed by the Palestinian group Black September, the Israeli government launches a clandestine retaliatory operation. Avner Kaufman, an experienced Mossad agent, is chosen to lead a specialized team assigned to hunt down and assassinate those responsible for the atrocity. The group is composed of a diverse set of specialists, including bomb makers, document forgers, and a cleanup expert. The mission sends them across Europe and the Middle East in a shadowy and dangerous world of espionage and moral ambiguity.
As they execute their assignments with cold precision, the team members grapple with their personal ethics and the escalating physical and emotional toll the mission exacts on them. They find themselves sinking deeper into a quagmire of uncertainty and paranoia, questioning the righteousness of their actions and the true identities of their targets. Concerns over who to trust and the legitimacy of their intelligence sources grow, while the retaliation cycle of violence spins out of control, blurring the lines between right and wrong. The psychological burden and the relentless fear of reprisal begin to erode their resolve, testing their loyalty to their cause and each other.
Writers: Tony Kushner, Eric Roth, George Jonas
Release Date: 06 Jan 2006
Runtime: 164 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, Canada, France
Language: English, German, French, Hebrew, Arabic, Italian, Greek, Russian, Dutch