The Punisher 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 75
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
The Punisher films: grim fun, improved A/V quality; a must for fans.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 74
The Punisher's 4K UHD transfer offers a natural, detailed, and less garish image compared to its 1080p version, with notable improvements in color, shadow detail, and depth despite some issues with dark scenes and CGI.
Audio: 77
The Punisher's 4K UHD release excels with a vivid Dolby Atmos track, enhancing immersion with dynamic, precise sounds and a broad soundscape, vastly outdoing its original Blu-ray audio.
Extra: 77
Lionsgate enriches The Punisher 4K UHD with extras previously missing on Blu-ray, offering upscaled HD content like director commentary, deleted scenes, behind-the-scenes, and more, enhancing fan experience.
Movie: 63
Lionsgate unloads old Blu-rays with new 4K packs; 'The Punisher' film blends action and revenge yet deviates from the original comic, receiving mixed reactions.
Video: 74
The Punisher" on 4K UHD Blu-ray offers a significant leap in quality over its 1080p counterpart, preserved in a 2160p resolution with an aspect ratio of 2.35:1. This release, brought to us by Lionsgate Films, showcases the distinct difference between the two presentations, favoring the 4K UHD for its more natural and less digitally sharpened appearance. The grain that characterizes the original film is retained, presenting a more authentic image, even if it appears somewhat coarse in places. Notably, the 4K version corrects some of the garishness seen in the 1080p Blu-ray, offering a more pleasurable viewing experience. Although improvements in color and detail through Dolby Vision and HDR are modest, they make certain elements like the vivid greens and the detail on vehicles stand out more starkly.
Detail and clarity are the main beneficiaries of this upgrade. The native 4K scan brings out subtleties previously lost, such as facial textures and environmental grit, enriching the film's visual narrative. Black levels and shadow detail also see advancement, enhancing the dimensional depth and making dark scenes more discernable while preserving essential details. However, some sequences do present challenges; CGI elements, especially, tend to stick out, and occasional crush in blacks can detract from the viewing experience. Yet, these moments are few and overshadowed by the overall enhancement of the film's visual presentation.
Encoding with HEVC/H.265 on a BD-66 layer enhances clarity and detail across the board, making "The Punisher" not only more visually appealing but also lending a more cinematic feel to movement and action sequences. Flesh tones are reliably natural throughout, and despite the film's generally subdued palette, HDR allows for bursts of color - from lime green muscle cars to fiery explosions - that genuinely pop. This transfer's handling of black levels is particularly praiseworthy, offering a depth and texture that add to the film's gritty atmosphere without falling into crushing. Noise and artifacts are markedly reduced, ensuring a clean viewing that makes "The Punisher" on 4K UHD a substantial improvement over previous releases, if not quite reaching demo material status.
Audio: 77
The Punisher's 4K UHD Blu-ray audio presentation makes a monumental leap from its predecessor, chiefly through the introduction of a meticulously crafted Dolby Atmos track. From the onset, notably during the opening credits, this sonic upgrade immerses viewers by utilizing the Atmos setup to its fullest - gunfire and action effects not only soar above but also envelop from all sides, creating an encompassing audio landscape. This envelopment is sustained across the board, with a notable emphasis on lifelike environmental sounds that shine, particularly in the island scenes. The film's ambitious set pieces benefit from both discrete channeling and dynamic panning effects, yielding a robust soundscape where dialogue, effects, and score coexist in harmonious balance, each element meticulously prioritized to ensure a broad dynamic range without sacrificing clarity.
Improvements over the original Blu-ray's audio are unmissable, with the Dolby Atmos track introducing a depth and dynamism sorely lacking in the former's lossy outputs. The Atmos mix doesn’t merely augment the vertical soundscape but enriches the overall spatial feel, granting every aspect from ambient noises to dialogue an enhanced presence. Moments of intense action, like the Henry Heck gunfight or the clash with The Russian, exhibit a gratifyingly visceral impact thanks to the mix's adept utilization of LFE channels, propelling sounds around the listeners that significantly augment the viewing experience. Comparatively, previous audio tracks appear markedly compressed and lackluster.
Lionsgate's dedication to revamping classic titles with new Atmos tracks pays off spectacularly with The Punisher, establishing an auditory experience that is as vast as it is engaging. The track masterfully exploits the capabilities of the format, offering an appreciable upgrade in how sound travels and is perceived within the listening space. Explosions and combat sequences leverage deep, resonant bass to make each action feel impactful, while subtler sounds have their moment, bringing scenes to life with authentic acoustics. Dialogue remains crystal clear amidst the chaos, emphasizing that this mix’s prowess lies not just in loudness but in its adept handling of nuanced sounds, ensuring an immersive experience throughout.
Extras: 77
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "The Punisher" addresses previous oversights by packing the disc with a commendable assortment of extras that elevate this edition far above its predecessors, especially enhancing the offerings compared to the sparse 1080p Blu-ray release. The inclusion of in-depth special features, notably the director's audio commentary, provides fans and newcomers alike with rich insights into the film's production, character origins, and action choreography. Although all extras are presented in HD and give the appearance of upscaled video on devices like the Oppo, they deliver substantial value. Highlights include behind-the-scenes stunts, deleted scenes with optional commentary, and explorations into the character’s Marvel roots. The content is suited for enthusiasts of the genre or those looking to delve deeper into the making of this particular Punisher adaptation.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary with Director Jonathan Hensleigh: Offers firsthand insights into the film's production challenges and creative decisions.
- Deleted Scenes (HD; 3:12): Features optional commentary that sheds light on the editing process.
- Keepin' It Real: Punisher Stunts (HD; 27:45): A behind-the-scenes look at the creation and execution of action sequences.
- Army of One: Punisher Origins (HD; 12:55): Dives into the character’s beginnings in Marvel comics, including interviews with key figures.
- War Journal: On the Set of The Punisher (HD; 29:59): Provides an extensive peek behind the curtain of movie magic.
- Music Video - Step Up Performed by Drowning Pool (HD; 3:24): Adds a musical highlight connected to the film.
- Drawing Blood Bradstreet Style (HD; 6:22): Focuses on the advertising campaign’s key artwork.
Movie: 63
The Punisher's leap into the 4K UHD realm with Lionsgate Films' latest release teases the potential of a vast and nearly mythical archive, hinting at a nostalgia for the early days of Blu-ray. This combo pack, much like others in Lionsgate’s recent foray into 4K, bundles the movie with a somewhat antiquated 1080p Blu-ray version, adding a quaint touch with its tutorial on navigating the main menu—reflective of its status as an early release in the Blu-ray history. This aspect inadvertently serves to accentuate the stark contrasts in visual and auditory experience that advancements in format can yield. However, it's the 4K UHD disc that stands firmly in the spotlight, promising an enhanced viewing of this early-2000s dark action film that meticulously follows FBI agent Frank Castle's transformation into the brooding vigilante known as the Punisher after a brutal attack by criminals irreversibly alters his life.
Thomas Jane’s embodiment of Frank Castle strikes a near-perfect balance, infusing the character with a palpable intensity that shines even amidst the film’s deviations from traditional Punisher lore. While some fans may find the Miami setting and revenge-driven plot a detour from the character's essence—his war against societal decay itself—Jane’s performance, coupled with John Travolta’s portrayal of Howard Saint, provides enough substance to engage. The film's position during the superhero boom of the early 2000s presents it as a solid, if not groundbreaking, entry into the genre. Its R-rating allows for a grittiness that fans would expect from a Punisher narrative, though it stops short of fully exploiting this freedom.
The inventive yet grounded approach of writer/director Jonathan Hensleigh manages to carve out moments of brilliance through well-staged action sequences and nods to comic book elements fans will appreciate, despite the film feeling slightly bloated at times. The inclusion of memorable yet functionally superfluous characters like the Johnny Cash-esque Harry Heck adds flavor without substantial narrative contribution. As a 4K UHD release, this edition of The Punisher offers both long-time enthusiasts and newcomers a chance to experience the movie with visual and sonic clarity previously unattainable, making it an intriguing revisitation. While it may verge on being a standard action revenge thriller stripped of its comic book identity, there's enough within this rendition to rekindle appreciation for its unique take on Frank Castle’s relentless pursuit of vengeance.
Total: 75
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "The Punisher" proves to be a significant improvement over its predecessor, bolstered by a native 4K transfer with Dolby Vision HDR and an exceptional Atmos audio mix that enhances the viewing experience. Through the lens of Lionsgate Films, the release revitalizes the action-packed narrative and Thomas Jane's compelling portrayal of the titular character. Although the film diverges from the comic book storyline in several respects, it retains a solid footing as an action revenge flick that is both engaging and gritty, akin more to traditional action cinema than its comic book movie counterparts.
Technical upgrades are at the forefront of this release, with reviewers highlighting the vastly improved video and audio quality that outpaces the previous 1080p Blu-ray version. The inclusion of supplements, previously absent, adds value and depth to the overall package, inviting fans to explore beyond the film itself. The enhanced audiovisual presentation not only elevates "The Punisher" within the realm of superhero adaptations but also renders it a standout release for enthusiasts of the genre and 4K collectors alike.
In conclusion, "The Punisher" 4K UHD Blu-ray release is recommended for its significant improvements in video and audio quality, coupled with the addition of previously missing supplements, making it a worthwhile upgrade. This edition caters to both long-time fans of the franchise and newcomers seeking high-quality action entertainment. With a keen emphasis on technical enhancements and value addition through supplements, Lionsgate Films delivers an attractive package that reaffirms "The Punisher" as a memorable and robust action film deserving of a spot in any 4K aficionado's collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
The entire 4K UHD presentation looks decidedly less garish and more natural than the 1080p Blu-ray, though with that said, in my opinion Dolby Vision and HDR haven't really significantly altered the palette,...
Audio: 70
The film is rife with set pieces which allow fantastic immersion, with both discrete channelization and some well done panning effects creating a very boisterous sonic environment....
Extras: 100
Keepin' It Real: Punisher Stunts (HD; 27:45) has some great behind the scenes footage of various action sequences being planned and shot....
Movie: 70
I kinda sorta joked about this aspect in our recent Halloween 4K Blu-ray review, where kind of oddly in my estimation the 1080p Blu-ray included with that release was the old 2007 version rather than the...
Total: 60
Lionsgate has really done a rather nice job on this release, providing upgraded video and hugely improved audio as well as some supplements that were missing in action on the long ago 1080p Blu-ray version....
High-Def Digest review by Matthew HartmanRead review here
Video: 80
The first shot of the yellow Corvette has that nice rich banana yellow color and the extra detail allows you to appreciate that thing of mechanical beauty as well as see all of the little beads of rain...
Audio: 90
Rightly and upfront, the verticals don't really experience a whole lot of distinct object-based activity, but as a whole they add a great amount of space to the mix giving voices, ambients, scoring, and...
Extras: 70
Righting another wrong, Lionsgate updated the bonus feature package to include a lot of the material that was available for the old DVD release but remained absent from the Blu-ray....
Movie: 60
Hensleigh has some great writing chops to his credit so the man knows how to stage an action sequence, the hit on Castle's family is brutal and downright scary, but other sequences of exposition or tidbits...
Total: 80
The Punisher is a solid action revenge flick - even if it breaks from the comics in several key areas of the character....
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 90
Its not a transfer that’ll set the world on fire, but compared to before and the overall just well done look of the thing, its quite a nice jump from the standard Blu-ray (Which came early on in the format...
Audio: 100
The mix place around the room, having sound travel, different levels of volume as the camera moves and overall utilizing every speaker....
Extras: 70
On the Set of The Punisher (SD, 29:59)Music Video “Step Up” Performed by Drowning Pool (SD, 3:24)Drawing Blood: Bradstreet Style (SD, 6:22)...
Movie: 70
Disagreements on the direction of the next film had him walking away, but since, he’s always been grateful and would done the skull shirt in a heartbeat if asked, probably....
Total: 80
The film is based on Welcome Back, Frank, but Welcome Back, Bonus Features as the standard Blu-ray did not carry any of them over....
Director: Jonathan Hensleigh
Actors: Thomas Jane, John Travolta, Samantha Mathis
PlotFrank Castle, an undercover FBI agent, successfully completes what he intends to be his final mission before retirement. After a sting operation to arrest arms dealer Otto Krieg, the operation goes sideways, leading to the unintended death of Bobby Saint, the son of powerful businessman and crime lord, Howard Saint. In retaliation for his son's death, Saint orchestrates a brutal massacre at a family reunion, where Castle and his entire family are celebrating. Castle miraculously survives the onslaught, though he's left grief-stricken and near death.
Wounded in body and soul, Castle retreats to a quiet life in a dilapidated tenement building. As he recuperates, he plots his vengeance against those responsible for the slaughter of his loved ones. Resurrecting himself as a vigilante, he takes on the moniker of The Punisher. Armed with a personal arsenal and driven by a fierce resolve, Castle embarks on a relentless crusade to dismantle Saint's empire, using his tactical expertise and intelligence to turn Saint's associates against him and tear the organization apart from the inside, all while evading the grasp of law enforcement who are on his trail.
Writers: Jonathan Hensleigh, Michael France
Release Date: 16 Apr 2004
Runtime: 124 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, Germany
Language: English