Night Watch Blu-ray Review
Score: 62
from 5 reviewers
Review Date:
Night Watch" Blu-ray impresses with quality, dynamic sound, and rich content, despite notable omissions and mixed reviews.
Disc Release Date
Video: 59
Night Watch's Blu-ray maintains a theatrically correct image with subdued colors and detailed shadows, despite a bright overall presentation and a miss on dynamic subtitles.
Audio: 64
Comprehensive review highlights excellent audio qualities across various tracks, with minor critiques on English dubs and deep bass presence; emphasizes immersive soundscapes.
Extra: 60
Night Watch Blu-ray offers a mix of insightful and lackluster extras, including varied commentary tracks, deleted scenes, and featurettes, yet misses some key features like the original Russian cut.
Movie: 71
Night Watch, a visually unique and complex Russian fantasy-horror film, captivates with its blend of action, intrigue, and supernatural battles between Light and Dark, promising rich rewards upon repeated viewings.
Video: 59
The Blu-ray presentation of "Night Watch" delivers a solid but unremarkable video quality reflective of its small budget origins. Presented in a theatrically correct 1.85:1 ratio with a 1080P transfer, the film achieves a level of detail and sharpness that closely mirrors the cinema experience. Despite its title, "Night Watch" is exhibited in a generally bright and clear manner, albeit with deliberately muted colors as intended by the director. The transfer retains this aesthetic faithfully, showcasing deep and natural black levels, while shadow details are impressively delineated, adding to the depth and realism of the image. However, the omission of the original dynamic subtitles for standard white ones detracts from the overall presentation, missing an opportunity to fully recreate the theatrical spectacle.
Grain is ever-present throughout the film, contributing to a natural and pleasing visual style without overwhelming viewers or distracting from the on-screen action. The source material’s integrity is commendable, free of defects and aiding in a clean and immersive viewing experience. Contrast and color rendition are managed well, with good shadow delineation revealing subtle textures in darker scenes. Though the color palette leans towards darker, muted tones, occasional splashes of vivid colors stand out, enhancing the visual narrative without resorting to oversaturation. Despite some instances of potential overlighting and color blooming noted in specific scenes, these do not significantly detract from the film's intended gritty and slightly foreboding atmosphere.
The Blu-ray's video quality effectively captures the film's unique visual style, characterized by its darker color schemes and grittier textures that align with the storytelling elements. Detail is rendered crisply, with strong black levels and contrast elevating mixed content scenes. While it may not showcase the razor-sharp detail and vibrancy seen in higher-budget productions, "Night Watch" on Blu-ray delivers a competent and true-to-source visual experience. Maintaining the film’s grainy aesthetic enhances its atmosphere, ensuring that its brooding essence is preserved without crossing into overly distracting territory.
Audio: 64
The array of audio options for "Night Watch" on Blu-ray presents an intriguing mix for audiophiles and cinema fans alike, although it notably omits the DTS HD option available on the US disc. Instead, viewers are treated to a robust Dolby TrueHD track in both English and Russian alongside a standard DTS option, with additional English, German, and French dubs in Dolby 5.1. While the TrueHD mix steals the spotlight with its aggressive yet nuanced sound field that leverages every speaker to immerse the viewer without overwhelming, it is complemented by hard rock and classical scores that remain distinct even as they propel the film’s intense atmosphere. The dialogue clarity amidst the complex audio environment is commendably maintained, ensuring that every spoken word is crisp and coherent.
The DTS track, while expansive, slightly misses the mark when it comes to the true depth of bass and high frequency clarity present in the TrueHD version, though it remains a viable option for those without TrueHD capability. Conversely, the English dub version significantly underperforms; its compressed nature not only reduces dynamic range but also clumsily handles surround channel usage, resulting in a flatter, less engaging experience that’s further marred by poorly executed dubbing efforts. For authentic auditory immersion, the dubbed versions are best avoided in favor of the original language tracks that showcase the film's sonic depth more accurately.
Fox's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 original Russian track emphatically underscores the film's atmospheric tension and dynamic action sequences with a masterful use of surrounds and deep, impactful bass that breathes life into the cinematic experience. Despite some critiques on the soundtrack’s loudness perhaps compensating for a lack of finer sonic detail, the overall consensus leans towards an effective horror ambiance achieved through meticulously crafted soundscapes. Scenes filled with eerie effects, hard-hitting music, and strategic silence demonstrate a sophisticated audio mix that complements the visual storytelling superbly, proving "Night Watch" to be a compelling auditory experience on Blu-ray.
Extra: 60
The Blu-ray extras for "Night Watch" offer a comprehensive package that's somewhat a mixed bag but overall enriching for fans and newcomers alike. Director Timur Bekmambetov's audio commentary, although marred by long silences and a meandering delivery, provides unique insights into the film's production and its significance in Russian cinema, albeit with exaggerated claims about its pioneering status. More coherent and engaging is the subtitled commentary by novelist Sergei Lukyanenko, which delves into the thematic depths and deviations from the source material, adding a valuable layer of understanding. The inclusion of extensive deleted scenes with optional directorial commentary, behind-the-scenes featurettes, and a somewhat perplexing comic book still gallery adds depth, although the lack of innovative subtitles and the original Russian theatrical cut is felt. The amalgamation of Region 1 and Region 2 DVD extras onto this Blu-ray disc, together with the exclusive D-Box Motion Code, crafts an almost definitive viewing experience that's slightly diminished by missing elements like impactful subtitles and more substantial behind-the-scenes revelations.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by Director Timur Bekmambetov: Discussion on the film's role in Russian cinema.
- Subtitled Commentary by Novelist Sergei Lukyanenko: Insightful themes and adaptations.
- 7 Deleted Scenes: With optional Russian audio and Director commentary.
- Making of Night Watch: A detailed behind-the-scenes glimpse with cast and crew interviews.
- Characters, Story, and Subtitles: Exploration of film's impact on Russian culture.
- Night Watch Trilogy: Origins and styles of the series.
- Comic Book Still Gallery: Selection from the comic adaptation.
- Poster Gallery: Collection of film posters.
- Theatrical Trailer (HD): Original movie trailer.
- Fox on Blu-ray (HD): Additional 6 BD trailers.
- D-Box Motion Code: Enhanced viewing experience for D-Box equipped seats.
Movie: 71
"Night Watch" emerges as a cinematic experience that intricately marries the mystical with the kinetic, transporting its audience into a deeply textured world that oscillates between the binaries of light and dark. This Russian-language fantasy/horror epic masterfully intertwines a folkloric battle of moral complexities with visually arresting sequences, courtesy of director Timur Bekmambetov's unique vision. Set against the backdrop of contemporary Moscow, the narrative unfurls an age-old conflict waged by 'Others', supernaturally endowed beings. These individuals navigate between the factions of light and darkness, each side governed by a centuries-old truce. Destined to destabilize this precarious balance is Anton Gorodetsky, portrayed by Konstantin Khabensky, whose discovery of his own powers as an Other thrusts him into the epicenter of potential apocalypse.
Despite its occasionally labyrinthine plot that may challenge first-time viewers, "Night Watch" rewards perseverance and repeated viewings with its layered storytelling and complex character arcs. Bekmambetov's direction ensures a frenetic pace, underpinned by a visual style that melds the grunge of urban decay with the slick polish of high-octane action sequences. However, it is not without its narrative pitfalls; at times, the film skirts clarity for stylistic excess, leading to moments where the frenzied visual tapestry supersedes coherent storytelling. Nonetheless, this does little to detract from the film's overall impact as a groundbreaking addition to Russian cinema, catapulting it from domestic blockbuster status to international cult acclaim.
The high definition Blu-ray presentation accentuates the film's visual and auditory elements, though it notably lacks the innovative, comic book-style subtitles that added a unique layer to its theatrical release. Despite this omission, the Blu-ray serves as a vital conduit for audiences to immerse themselves in "Night Watch’s" richly constructed universe. The film straddles genres — from medieval fantasy to urban action thriller — crafting an oeuvre that is as much a love letter to Russian folklore as it is an homage to Western cinematic influences. Through the lens of Bekmambetov's dynamic direction, "Night Watch" achieves a distinctive status; it's a tale of moral ambiguity, a visually stunning spectacle, and perhaps most importantly, a signal of Russian cinema's vibrant resurgence on the global stage.
Total: 62
"Night Watch" on Blu-ray delivers an intriguing blend of horror, drama, and fantasy that stands out due to its distinctive visual style and kinetically charged action sequences. The film itself, a unique take on the genre from a Russian perspective, enriches its narrative with cultural insights and maintains a balance between its complex storyline and visually compelling scenes. The Blu-ray edition offers a commendable 1080p video quality, especially notable given the original production's budget constraints. The inclusion of a lossless TrueHD original Russian language soundtrack enhances the viewing experience, making it evident that audio plays a vital role in immersing the audience. It's advisable to bypass the English dub version due to its subpar quality. The packaging comes replete with an array of extras, although some may find these lacking in depth. A notable disappointment is the omission of the creative subtitles from the theatrical release, an aspect that previously added to the film's charm.
The evaluation of this Blu-ray was conducted using top-tier home cinema equipment, including JVC's DLA-RS1x 1080p HD Front Projector and an array of high-quality playback devices such as Oppo's 970HD universal DVD player and Sony's Playstation 3, among others. This high-level setup ensured that the film's audiovisual presentation was assessed with the utmost precision, highlighting the Blu-ray's ability to deliver superior sound and picture quality that can satisfy even the most discerning enthusiasts.
In conclusion, "Night Watch" on Blu-ray stands as a compelling release that successfully marries a uniquely Russian storytelling perspective with high-quality technical presentation. Despite some flaws, such as weaker English dubbing and missing cinematic subtitles, the disc is a worthy investment for fans and newcomers alike. The film's slow-building narrative, culminating in an action-packed climax, coupled with its excellent audiovisual quality, makes this Blu-ray a commendable addition to any collection. Whether for its stylistic flair or its engaging story, "Night Watch" remains a fascinating cinematic journey well worth experiencing in its best form on Blu-ray.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 80
One thing that I will mention is that in the cinema, the subtitles were almost like a work of art, moving around the screen in sympathy with the action, morphing and changing colour during the film....
Audio: 80
Whilst all six speakers are still used extensively, and the sound field is suitably expansive, this track lacks the true high frequency sounds and deep bass that the main track exhibits....
Extras: 70
Characters and Themes which is not on the US disc is a brief five minute featurette about the mythology of the Others, and Characters, Story and Subtitles explains the wonderfully inventive cinematic subtitles...
Movie: 90
It displays a visual style which was unique at the time, and is a fascinating fusion of Russian culture and sensibilities with an almost Hollywood cinematic style....
Total: 80
All the extras apart from two have been gathered together from the various regional DVD releases, and this makes a comprehensive package, even if insight is lacking....
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
It's actually brighter and more alive than I would have expected from a film entitled Night Watch, but the transfer remains strong between the darkest scenes and those most awash in light, and everything...
Audio: 90
Night Watch features a soundtrack worthy of the nature of the film and is the prefect compliment to the experience....
Extras: 60
Characters, Story and Subtitles (480p, 5:06) is a brief feature that looks at the impact of the film on Russian culture and the themes of the film....
Movie: 70
As the story picks up steam, as the intrigue builds, as we become accustomed to the characters, and as we enjoy some bloody and well-done action sequences, Night Watch pulls in its viewers and establishes...
Total: 80
Night Watch is an amalgamation of horror, drama, and fantasy, a film that revels in kinetically-filmed action and plenty of blood and guts, but also remembers there is a story to be told, and a good one...
The Digital Bits review by Bill HuntRead review here
Video: 80
Audio: 90
Night Watch was shot 35 spherical at 1.66:1 and was presented in the 1.85:1 Flat format theatrically, so that’s how it’s presented here on Blu-ray....
Extras: 75
Movie: 80
I will say that Night Watch is the first part of a trilogy about a thousand-year old cold war between Good and Evil, that’s being waged just beneath the surface of our own present-day reality....
Total: 81
So much of what’s going on in these films is informed by Russian history and cultural sensibilities, that I’m actually interested in reading the original novels to try to and appreciate it all better....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
The grain looks reasonably natural, perhaps a little noisy here or there, but digitized well overall....
Audio: 60
While Master Audio may be a lossless compression format, the film's general sound quality is no better than a typical Dolby Digital or DTS track....
Extras: 40
The Blu-ray is lacking the original Russian theatrical cut of the film or the comic book subtitles from the American theatrical release....
Movie: 60
Disappointingly, it does not have the theatrical subtitles that were designed in a comic book style and interacted with the imagery on screen....
Total: 60
'Night Watch' showcases a unique visual sensibility and I can understand why the film has developed a cult following....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 84
Images tend to lean toward darker color schemes, and grittier textures that provide the look that the filmmakers strive for to drive the story's elements....
Audio: 90
The dynamic range is forceful and delivers solid impact and clearly articulated audio that allows all of the sonic detail inherent with the soundtrack to be audible....
Extras: 60
Audio commentary by Director Timur Bekmambetov Subtitled commentary by Novelist Sergei Lukyanenko 7 Deleted scenes - With optional Russian audio and Director commentary Making of Night Watch - Featurette...
Movie: 60
In modern day, the dark Others actually roam the night as vampires while a "Night Watch" of light forces, among them Anton, try to control them and limit their outrage....
Total: 74
Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Outlaw Audio Model 7700 seven channel amplifier B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 seven Channel amplifier Canton "Ergo"...
Director: Timur Bekmambetov
Actors: Konstantin Khabenskiy, Vladimir Menshov, Mariya Poroshina
PlotSet in contemporary Moscow, the story revolves around the eternal battle between the forces of light and darkness, a conflict concealed from the human eye. The Night Watch, a group of individuals endowed with supernatural abilities and aligned with the Light, patrols the night, safeguarding humans from creatures of the Dark. The Day Watch, conversely, comprises those who serve the Dark, maintaining a delicate balance between the two factions under a centuries-old truce. An ordinary man, Anton, finds himself thrust into this hidden world after discovering his own supernatural abilities. Seeking to find and protect his estranged son, Anton joins the Night Watch, embarking on a journey that reveals the complexities and shades of grey between good and evil.
As Anton delves deeper into the shadowy realm of the Night Watch, he encounters a prophecy that threatens to shatter the precarious balance between Light and Dark, potentially plunging the world into chaos. His path crosses with a cursed young woman whose fate is intricately linked with that of the prophecy. As Anton navigates through a series of trials and moral dilemmas, he must confront his own past and make critical choices that could affect the future of the Night Watch and the world at large. Along the way, Anton learns that in the struggle between Light and Dark, the lines between friend and foe can be surprisingly blurred, pushing him to question where true allegiance lies.
Writers: Timur Bekmambetov, Laeta Kalogridis, Sergey Lukyanenko
Release Date: 03 Mar 2006
Runtime: 114 min
Rating: R
Country: Russia
Language: Russian, German