Amadeus Blu-ray Review
Score: 58
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Classic 'Amadeus' on Blu-ray: stunning visuals & sound, almost perfect upgrade. A must-see.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 51
'Amadeus' Blu-ray enhances visuals significantly from past versions, with richer colors and details, despite issues like softness and over-processing.
Audio: 66
Warner's Dolby TrueHD 5.1 track on Amadeus masterfully renders Mozart's music with dynamic clarity, enveloping listeners in a concert hall experience, though dialogue scenes feel less engaging by comparison.
Extra: 41
The 'Amadeus' Blu-ray reissue swaps its lavish Digibook for a standard case, dropping beloved bonuses like the Mozart CD, yet retains rich director commentary and a detailed making-of documentary, missing only the isolated score.
Movie: 86
Amadeus, a timeless blend of rage, envy, and genius, mesmerizes as it dramatizes Mozart's life and Salieri's obsession, proving its enduring acclaim and Oscar success.
Video: 51
Warner's release of "Amadeus" on Blu-ray, encoded in 1080p/VC-1, represents a noteworthy advancement from its predecessors in visual quality, though it is not without its flaws. Years of subpar video formats have done little justice to the film's meticulous production design and vivid cinematography. This edition addresses many of those issues, offering richer colors, deeper blacks (with some inconsistency), and improved contrast and skintone accuracy. Detail enhancement is evident across textures and backgrounds, leading to a clearer, more refined image presentation that significantly minimizes issues like artifacting and source noise. Fabric, hair, and edge sharpness are particularly improved, making for a visual experience that far surpasses earlier DVD releases.
However, the transfer's over-reliance on post-processing techniques such as digital noise reduction (DNR) and edge enhancement has introduced its own set of challenges. These attempts to clean up the image result in occasional waxy-looking close-ups, softened textures, and some motion smearing—compromises that detract from the authenticity of the source material. While these efforts likely aimed to modernize the film's appearance, they occasionally sacrifice the film's natural cinematic qualities. Despite these missteps, scenes maintain a film-like texture that compliments the period setting, with grain carefully managed to avoid distraction.
The palette's vibrancy shines through in this release. Reds are luscious, and there is an impressive display of delicate pastel tones that enhance the visual depth of scenes. Black levels are satisfying, helping textiles and details stand out more impressively. Fine details are mostly preserved, lending authenticity to the visual narrative. Unfortunately, the pitfalls of digital tampering are visible but kept at bay enough not to ruin the overall appreciation of the upgrade. Though "Amadeus" on Blu-ray doesn't fully exploit the potential of its high-definition medium, it represents a significant improvement over past versions and brings us closer to appreciating the film in a quality reminiscent of its original theatrical glory.
Audio: 66
Warner's Dolby TrueHD 5.1 surround track for the "Amadeus" Blu-ray edition works wonders in bringing Mozart's exquisite compositions to life, transcending the film's vintage to offer an immersive, captivating sonic experience. The audio meticulously crafts a concert hall atmosphere, where violins initiate the auditory journey in the center channel, spreading melodiously across the soundstage, soon complemented by the rich undertones of cellos and the airy presence of bassoons and flutes. As the orchestral force gathers, with horns heralding from various directions and cellos and bassoons making their presence felt, a whirlwind of sound engulfs the listener. The track masterfully handles both the tempestuous crescendos, where each instrument clamors for attention, and the subtler moments, ensuring even the faintest oboe note is discernible amidst the robust ensemble of trumpets and timpani.
Despite the audio track's prowess in delivering Mozart's symphonic masterpieces with exceptional dynamism and clarity, its treatment of the more mundane elements—dialogue and ambient sounds—though competent, feels somewhat lackluster in comparison. Dialogue remains clear and well-balanced, and the soundscape convincingly realistic, yet these aspects pale next to the enveloping richness of the musical sequences. The fidelity and acoustical detail during conversational exchanges and environmental ambiance are commendable for a film of this age, highlighting Warner’s dedication to audio quality, yet they do not encapsulate the listener with the same vigor as the musical portions do.
Warner earns praise for its handling of this iconic soundtrack, particularly considering its choice of 16-bit audio. The TrueHD 5.1 track delivers a breathtakingly pure and textured auditory experience whether in symphony or opera form, enveloping listeners in Mozart's powerful expressions of joy, elegance, and despair. Operatic sequences and symphonies alike are rendered with lush, full-bodied tones that showcase intricate texture and shading, allowing audiences to virtually feel as though seated within a grand concert venue. Despite occasional underutilization of the subwoofer, low-end bass during musical lows is rendered beautifully, with high soprano notes maintaining clarity without distortion. This meticulous attention to detail in audio presentation ensures that every note of Mozart’s music is preserved and celebrated, truly enhancing Salieri’s narrative and the overall impact of "Amadeus" on its audience.
Extras: 41
Merging the insights from the various reviews, the extra presentation of the Blu-ray edition of "Amadeus" offers a compact yet insightful collection that both enriches the viewing experience and deepens the appreciation for this cinematic masterpiece. Despite the transition from a Digibook to a standard Blu-ray case, leading to the regrettable omission of the audio CD featuring Mozart compositions and the digital copy, the extras maintain their allure. The standout is undoubtedly the director Milos Forman and writer Peter Shaffer's audio commentary, providing a riveting three-hour journey through the film's creation, peppered with anecdotes, behind-the-scenes revelations, and scholarly insights into Mozart’s life—despite occasionally treading on ground also covered by the Making of 'Amadeus' documentary. This documentary itself, though in standard definition, thoroughly chronicles the film’s production process, casting challenges, and location hurdles, offering a glimpse into the intense collaboration and rich historical tapestry that informed the screenplay. While some fans may lament the exclusion of the Isolated Score track, present in earlier editions, the existing extras deliver substantial content that will satisfy aficionados and newcomers alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Director Milos Forman and writer Peter Shaffer provide engaging insights and behind-the-scenes anecdotes.
- The Making of Amadeus: A comprehensive documentary covering the film’s production, casting, challenges, and reception.
- Original Theatrical Trailer: A brief preview of the film.
- Special CD Compilation: (Not included in the latest release) Offered an engaging selection of eight Mozart pieces relevant to the film's context in previous editions.
Movie: 86
Amadeus," originally premiering over three decades ago, offers an undeniably captivating cinema experience that remains unblemished by time's often cruel passage. This film, revered not only for its masterful storytelling but also for its rich, atmospheric portrayal of 18th and 19th-century life, secures its place as a timeless classic, driven home by an exceptional Blu-ray presentation. The movie, a dramatic retelling of the life of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart through the envious eyes of his contemporary, Antonio Salieri, blends historical fiction with emotional depth, focusing not on the accuracy of events but on the profound narrative of genius, rivalry, and human frailty. The performances by Tom Hulce, as the prodigious yet immature Mozart, and F. Murray Abraham, portraying the villainous yet pitiful Salieri, are monumental, capturing the complexity of their characters with nuance and intensity.
Much more than a biopic, "Amadeus" thrives on the antagonistic relationship between Mozart and Salieri. It explores themes of envy, obsession, and the divine gift of musical talent with a compelling narrative that transitions seamlessly from stage to screen. The screenplay by Peter Shaffer, which won him an Oscar alongside the film’s numerous other accolades including Best Picture, crafts a world where Salieri’s vendetta against Mozart becomes a war against God himself - a battle of a man tormented by his own mediocrity against a backdrop of Mozart's brilliant compositions. This thematic depth is matched by authentic settings, lavish costumes, and an immersive atmosphere that brings the period to vivid life, further enhanced by the director's cut that delves deeper into character relationships and motivations.
The cinematic portrayal does more than narrate; it elevates Mozart's music to an almost tangible presence, integral to understanding both protagonists' arcs. The scenic design and costume work contribute significantly to the film’s immersive quality, making the viewer feel part of the era. These elements combined with stellar performances not only solidify "Amadeus" as an engaging study of envy and jealousy but as a sumptuous period piece that commands attention to this day. Its reception upon release and its enduring appeal underscore its status as a masterpiece, proving that certain stories have the power to transcend time. With such detailed craftsmanship from Milos Forman and an unforgettable score that serves almost as a character in its own right, "Amadeus" on Blu-Ray remains an essential experience for film fans and music lovers alike.
Total: 58
Amadeus," a period masterpiece that captures the essence and rivalry of classical music's most intriguing figures, Mozart and Salieri, remains a cinematic treasure long after its initial release. This Blu-ray edition, while not boasting a flawless video transfer, still presents a significant improvement over its predecessors, enriching the visual experience with more vivid colors and sharper details. The audio is where this release truly excels, offering a lossless track that envelops the viewer in Mozart's profound musical compositions, ensuring that every note resonates with the clarity and depth it deserves. However, it's worth noting that this edition lacks some of the extra frills like the Digibook casing, bonus audio CD, and digital copy that were included in its original release.
Furthermore, the array of special features provided adds substantial value, allowing both newcomers and dedicated fans an in-depth look into the making of this cinematic icon. Despite the slight shortcoming in video fidelity, which may not satisfy those seeking reference quality, the overall enhancement in picture and sound does justice to the film’s artistic achievements. The lack of certain collectible items previously offered does little to diminish the worth of this edition, making it a must-have for enthusiasts of historical dramas and classical music alike.
In conclusion, this Blu-ray edition of "Amadeus" represents a valuable addition to any collection, effectively balancing minor limitations in visual transfer with superior audio quality and enriching bonuses. Its presentation underscores the enduring appeal of the film's storytelling, performances, and, most importantly, its musical genius. Whether you are revisiting Salieri's tale of envy and genius or discovering it for the first time, this release proves to be an essential homage to one of cinema's finest explorations of artistry and rivalry.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 70
Early VHS copies didn't do the film's lavish production design or stunning cinematography justice, laserdisc failed to capture the details of Mozart's drunken exploits, and more recent DVD editions were...
Audio: 80
Of course, it's deflating anytime the music subsides since the rest of the film offers little more than conversational chit-chat and subtle environmental ambience....
Extras: 50
The Making of Amadeus (SD, 61 minutes): This full-length documentary delves into the complete production, from the genesis of the project, to casting relative unknowns, to shooting on lavish sets that...
Movie: 90
Shaffer's screenplay presents a story of rage, revenge, and madness; a cautionary tale that follows a well-regarded master composer as he falls prey to his own insecurities and self-doubt....
Total: 70
While its video transfer could have been more faithful to its source, it still offers a substantial upgrade over previous releases....
High-Def Digest review by David KraussRead review here
Video: 70
Many scenes err on the soft side, but there's a healthy complement of sharp, well-defined images that burst forth with excellent contrast and vibrant color....
Audio: 90
Without proper dynamic range, tonal depth, and a broad sound field, the impact of Mozart's melodies on Salieri personally and the audience at large would not be nearly as great, and the story would suffer....
Extras: 40
A Mozart scholar, Shaffer imparts a wealth of fascinating tidbits about both composers that adds a great deal to the film; most notably, his belief that Mozart died of kidney failure brought on by ingesting...
Movie: 90
Mozart also doesn't hide his disdain for mediocrity, and that includes Salieri's compositions, which he attacks with a barrage of stinging barbs that rapidly turn the court composer's jealousy into hatred....
Total: 70
Though the 1080p transfer may not be reference quality, it's still a worthy upgrade, and the crystalline quality of the high-def audio allows us to truly feel Mozart's music as well as hear it....
Director: Milos Forman
Actors: F. Murray Abraham, Tom Hulce, Elizabeth Berridge
PlotIn 18th-century Vienna, Antonio Salieri, the celebrated court composer to Emperor Joseph II, finds himself consumed by obsessive jealousy upon encountering Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, a young musical prodigy whose genius is unparalleled. Despite Mozart's crass and childish behavior, his music captivates Salieri, who views Mozart's divine talent as a cruel joke by God, given to someone so unworthy in Salieri's eyes. Salieri's reverence for music and his ambition to create heavenly compositions clash with his growing envy, setting him on a dark path of rivalry and desperation.
As Salieri becomes increasingly entangled in Mozart's world, he positions himself as the young composer's confidant to sabotage his career while publicly maintaining the facade of a supportive colleague. The dynamic between the mediocre court composer and the brilliant Mozart plays out against the backdrop of the opulent Austro-Hungarian Empire, filled with palace intrigues, sumptuous feasts, and grand performances. Salieri witnesses Mozart's struggles for recognition and financial security even as the latter creates sublime and transformational works, further fueling Salieri's bitter resentment.
Writers: Peter Shaffer, Zdenek Mahler
Release Date: 19 Sep 1984
Runtime: 160 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States, France
Language: English, Italian, Latin, German, French