Ender's Game Blu-ray Review
Score: 71
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Ender's Game: A visually compelling, thought-provoking film marred by flawed HDR.
Disc Release Date
2K Upscale
HDR10
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 58
Ender's Game on 4K UHD Blu-ray enhances colors and details from the 2K DI source but struggles with consistent black levels, despite using advanced video codecs and HDR.
Audio: 81
Ender's Game's Ultra HD release dazzles with an immersive Dolby Atmos soundtrack, offering detailed soundscapes and dynamic range that enhance viewer experience.
Extra: 73
The US Ultra HD Blu-ray of Ender's Game includes extensive extras like commentary from Hood and producers, making-of featurettes, deleted scenes, and trailers, but the 4K disc lacks these supplements.
Movie: 73
Ender's Game" is a cerebral and visually stunning sci-fi tale exploring leadership and morality, facing mixed reception but leaving audiences wanting more.
Video: 58
"Ender's Game" arrives on 4K UHD Blu-ray from Lionsgate Films with a grand display of visual refinement and digital sophistication, bound within a 2.40:1 aspect ratio. Despite its original capture in 5K using RED Epic cameras and subsequent downsampling to a 2K Digital Intermediate (DI), this Ultra HD rendition skillfully upscales to 2160p, utilizing HEVC (H.265) codec, 10-bit video depth, wider colour gamut (WCG), and high dynamic range (HDR) to enhance its presentation. The discernment between the Blu-ray and the Ultra HD Blu-ray in terms of sheer detail is subtly nuanced due to the upscale; however, the CGI and special effects, initially rendered at 2K, display a commendable degree of clarity and definition, benefiting from the technological advancements in color handling and contrast ratios, even if the full potential of HDR isn’t fully realized due to black level inaccuracies reminiscent of issues seen in "The Expendables 3."
The upgrade in video quality is immediately apparent in the vivacity and boldness of colors, where hues such as the blue of the space sequences and the yellow of the trainees' suits are rendered with a newfound depth, showcasing superior shadow detail and a broader spectrum of tones. The addition of HDR augments this further, except in instances where the black levels present less than true darkness—a shortcoming possibly linked to metadata encoding or PQ EOTF settings. These moments notwithstanding, the visual enhancement lends a greater sense of realism and immersion, particularly in scenes set within the zero-gravity Battle Room or the intricate landscapes of alien planets, where color depth and detail capture attention.
While minor issues such as occasional banding in midrange gradients and the discussed black level fidelity exist, they detract little from the overall experience. The upgrade from Blu-ray to Ultra HD Blu-ray for "Ender's Game" stands out most significantly in its richer, more robust color presentation and marginally improved detail that together elevate the visual storytelling. Scenes heavy with CGI might exhibit slight softness, but this does not mar an otherwise impressive video presentation on this format. Despite challenges with black levels—a concern echoed across similar releases—the advancement in home cinema technology showcases the film's sophisticated production design and effects work with compelling clarity and vibrancy.
Audio: 81
The audio presentation of "Ender's Game" on Ultra HD Blu-ray, with its transition from DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 to a Dolby Atmos track, marks a notable enhancement in the auditory experience of the film, bringing a fresh sense of dimensionality and immersion that was less prominent in previous versions. Utilizing a Denon AVR-X7200WA in a 7.2.4 setup, the superiority of the Dolby Atmos format becomes evident through its adept use of overhead channels, particularly during the zero-gravity Battle School scenes and momentous events such as rocket launches. This upgrade not only amplifies the feeling of being inside the spacecraft but also finely balances the soundscape between intense action sequences and quieter, dialogue-driven moments, ensuring clarity and depth throughout.
From the initial alien incursion flashback to the later stages of Ender's videogame challenges, the Atmos mix introduces an expansive sound field where directional effects and low frequency enhancements (LFE) are remarkably pronounced. These enhancements bring a new level of realism to the viewing experience, with sound elements meticulously moving across and above the audience, enriching every scene with floorboard-shaking bass and precise sound positioning. The auditory dynamism displayed, coupled with the detailed articulation of effects and dialogue, demonstrates a thoughtful sound design that complements the visual spectacle of the film.
Overall, whether through the weighty roar of spaceship engines or the nuanced ambient sounds of space station chatter, this Dolby Atmos track offers a robust and engaging audio experience. It not only underlines the technical prowess of modern sound design but also elevates "Ender's Game" into an immersive auditory journey that excels in both intensity and subtlety. The continuous prioritization of dialogue clarity amidst a heavy FX mix, alongside a wide dynamic range, showcases this Atmos track as a definitive listening experience for both aficionados and casual viewers alike.
Extras: 73
The US Ultra HD Blu-ray release of "Ender's Game" serves as a comprehensive package for enthusiasts, offering a duo of discs comprising the Ultra HD Blu-ray without regional coding and the Full HD Blu-ray designated for Region A. Although the set includes a digital HD copy, its redemption may face geographical limitations. The bulk of the supplemental materials is housed on the Full HD Blu-ray, presenting a wealth of insights into the film’s creation. Noteworthy are the dual audio commentaries—one by director Gavin Hood, providing an encyclopedic dive into the technicalities and narrative evolution, and another by producers Gigi Pritzker and Bob Orci, which adds a refreshing conversational tone, grounded in their unique perspectives. The extras are further enriched by "Ender’s World: The Making of Ender’s Game," a detailed assembly of featurettes that traverse the entirety of the film's development, supplemented by a selection of deleted and extended scenes offering glimpses into omitted content, alongside "Inside the Mind Game," a brief exploration of the in-film computer game’s creation. This ensemble of features, while absent on the 4K UHD disc, provides a definitive exploration of the filmmaking process, albeit with an opportunity for tighter editing in places to avoid redundancy.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary with Director Gavin Hood: A detailed walkthrough by Hood, covering technical and narrative aspects.
- Audio Commentary with Producers Gigi Pritzker and Robert Orci: Offers insights into the production from a different angle, showcasing good chemistry between the speakers.
- Ender’s World: The Making of Ender’s Game: An eight-part documentary detailing various facets of production.
- Deleted/Extended Scenes: Six scenes with optional director's commentary, shedding light on pacing and story decisions.
- Inside the Mind Game: An examination of the creation of the computer game Ender interacts with in the movie.
- Theatrical Trailers: Two trailers intended for the cinematic promotion of the film.
Movie: 73
"Ender's Game" emerges as a fascinating intersection of tactical science fiction and introspective drama, skilfully adapted from Orson Scott Card's renowned novel by Gavin Hood. This adaptation brings to life a future Earth under threat from an alien race known as the Formics, and the film meticulously explores the moral complexities of warfare, leadership, and the heavy reliance on child prodigies for survival. Asa Butterfield delivers a compelling performance as Ender Wiggin, a young genius enrolled in an advanced military academy to prepare for an impending alien encounter. Surrounded by a stellar cast including Harrison Ford, Viola Davis, and Ben Kingsley, the film benefits from strong acting that adds depth to its intricate narrative.
From a technical standpoint, "Ender's Game" shines on Blu-ray, showcasing the detailed production design and special effects that bring its vast universe to life. The UHD 4K presentation elevates this experience, offering viewers stunning visuals that highlight the film’s dynamic space battles and the intricate architecture of the space station settings. Despite its underwhelming box office performance, the film remains an underappreciated gem that appeals to both sci-fi aficionados and those who appreciate deeper thematic exploration in their cinema. It prompts the audience to contemplate the ethics of war, the responsibilities of leadership, and the costs of victory.
However, "Ender's Game" is not without its challenges, notably in finding its audience niche. While aimed at a younger demographic, its pacing and cerebral tone may not fully grasp the attention it deserves. Regardless, this adaptation stands out for its willingness to engage with complex questions without sacrificing entertainment value. The combination of excellent performances, thought-provoking storytelling, and visually stunning effects make "Ender's Game" a must-watch on Blu-ray, especially in 4K UHD, which amplifies its cinematic quality for home theater enthusiasts seeking depth and detail in their viewing experience.
Total: 71
"Ender's Game," adapted from Orson Scott Card's celebrated novel by Gavin Hood, who also directed, emerges as a thought-provoking sci-fi adventure that delves into the ethics of preemptive strikes and the essence of leadership. Despite its appeal to a younger audience, with Harrison Ford leading a dynamic cast, the film is criticized for its lack of action, though it compensates with intriguing ideas and compelling production design. The Blu-ray release comes with high expectations, featuring an Ultra HD presentation that magnifies the visual effects and an immersive Dolby Atmos soundtrack that enhances the viewing experience with its robust bass and atmospheric depth, providing an excellent audio-visual complement to the film's thematic complexity.
However, the Blu-ray's presentation is not without its flaws. The HDR image quality, while boasting a 10-bit video depth and a wide color gamut for realistic imagery free of banding and artifacts, suffers from underwhelming black levels that appear dark grey rather than true black. This issue detracts significantly from the impact of the visuals, undermining the overall enhancement intended by the Ultra HD upgrade. Despite these technical shortcomings, the Blu-ray edition still offers a worthwhile package for fans, including a substantial array of extras that add value to the release.
In conclusion, while "Ender's Game" on Ultra HD Blu-ray demonstrates notable improvements in audio and color detailing, it falls short of delivering a consistently high-quality picture due to problematic black levels. The film itself remains engaging and thoughtfully adapted, supported by excellent performances and sound design. However, potential buyers should be aware of the varying experiences reported with this particular Blu-ray release. For enthusiasts equipped for 4K UHD and seeking to explore the enhanced features, it represents an interesting acquisition, albeit with reservations due to the inconsistent video quality.
avforums review by Steve WithersRead review here
Video: 50
As result of the 2K DI there isn't any real difference in terms of detail between the Blu-ray and the Ultra HD Blu-ray, with the latter being upscaled to 4K for this release....
Audio: 100
The zero-g sequences in the Battle School offer plenty of opportunity for the sound designers to take advantage of the overhead channels, resulting in a sound mix that completely envelopes the viewer....
Extras: 80
The title of each featurette reveals the areas they cover and they are best watched as one feature which explains the genesis of the project the struggles involved in getting it made....
Movie: 70
The production design and special effects are very good and, in amongst the action set pieces, the film's narrative addresses some interesting subjects such as what actually makes a good leader....
Total: 60
A good film, a great soundtrack and a decent set of extras are spoilt by a flawed HDR picture Sadly, despite being a good film, having a great Dolby Atmos soundtrack and a decent of extras, the Ultra HD...
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 70
The other interesting element with this version is the gradation of colors, something probably most attributable to HDR....
Audio: 90
Despite a somewhat FX heavy mix, dialogue is always prioritized well and the overall sound design is extremely well articulated with precision and a surprising amount of nuance (at least given the somewhat...
Extras: 100
The 1080p Blu-ray included in this package includes the supplements I detailed in our original Ender's Game Blu-ray review....
Movie: 70
This rollout has been a bit more haphazard than even jaded HT enthusiasts may have been expecting, but a number of high profile films are seeing the light of day in new "ultra high definition"....
Total: 0
The fact that several members on our Forum have had even more egregious video quality issues than I did keeps me from giving this disc an outright recommendation, but I will say for those who haven't yet...
High-Def Digest review by Bryan KlugerRead review here
Video: 90
The rustier colors on the alien surface planet look richer as well here with a bigger dose of color saturation to give a more lifelike presence....
Audio: 90
Ender's Game' sound design is powerful and packs a punch at every turn, no matter if the kids are throwing punches themselves or there is a battle in space, all of it sounds incredible and fully immerses...
Extras: 50
Audio Commentary with Director Gavin Hood – Despite only listing an 'Audio Commentary' on the back of the box, there are actually two commentary tracks on 'Ender's Game', the first of which is a solo one...
Movie: 90
This visually stunning film, along with its great performances and story have created one hell of a fine film, that I sure hope will make enough money to warrant a sequel....
Total: 80
Although, quite a bit is left out of the film from the book, it transfers well on screen and leaves room for more films....
Director: Gavin Hood
Actors: Harrison Ford, Asa Butterfield, Hailee Steinfeld
PlotIn the near future, Earth has narrowly survived an attack from a technologically superior alien race known as the Formics. In preparation for a feared second invasion, the world's military forces have banded together to form the International Fleet, a global organization tasked with finding and training future fleet commanders. The most promising children are identified and recruited from a young age, sent to Battle School in orbit around Earth to undergo a rigorous military training program. One such recruit is Ender Wiggin, a shy but strategically brilliant boy whose unique talents place him under the tutelage of Colonel Hyrum Graff, the commander of the training facility, and Major Gwen Anderson, a psychologist who monitors the children's emotional well-being.
Within the Battle School, Ender struggles to fit in among other gifted trainees and faces intense pressure to succeed. His ingenuity and tactical genius quickly earn him respect and lead to rapid advancement through the ranks, though they also cause friction with his peers. Throughout his training, Ender is put through a series of increasingly complex war games in the Battle Room, a zero-gravity environment where students learn the fundamentals of space combat. These simulations are designed to test the recruits' abilities to think strategically and work as a unified force, all in preparation for the looming threat of another invasion by the alien enemy.
Writers: Gavin Hood, Orson Scott Card
Release Date: 01 Nov 2013
Runtime: 114 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English