Barry Lyndon Blu-ray Review
Score: 61
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Barry Lyndon’s stunning visuals and excellent A/V presentation on Blu-ray reaffirm its status as a slow-burning Kubrick masterpiece, despite the lack of extras.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 73
Warner's 1080p AVC-encoded transfer of 'Barry Lyndon' masterfully preserves the film's soft, lavish lighting and intricate details, with excellent grain retention, deep black levels, and vibrant yet natural colors. Candlelit scenes mesmerize, and aliasing, banding, and noise artifacts are notably absent.
Audio: 63
Barry Lyndon's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track, transformed from the original mono mix, delivers a front-heavy yet richly immersive soundscape, with clean dialogue, robust ambient effects, and vibrant music, honoring the film's period authenticity and Kubrick's nuanced intentions.
Extra: 19
The Blu-ray of Barry Lyndon disappoints with its lackluster special features, providing only a poorly presented theatrical trailer.
Movie: 92
Barry Lyndon, Stanley Kubrick's masterfully detached yet lavishly shot period drama, uses meticulously authentic cinematography and classical music to create a visually sumptuous, richly detailed world that both disarms and captivates, even as it explores the bleak, self-destructive journey of its unlikable protagonist over a deliberate 187 minutes.
Video: 73
Warner's 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer of "Barry Lyndon" is a remarkable testament to the film's visual artistry, known for its soft and lavishly lit style. This Blu-ray presentation maintains the delicate balance between softness and detail, preserving the film's grain structure to enhance its organic feel. Fine textures and vivid details abound, particularly in close-ups, which reveal intricate costume details and skin textures. Despite the inherent softness, edge definition remains true to the source material, with wide shots appearing beautifully painterly and detailed. The encoding is expertly handled, avoiding issues such as artifacting, banding, aliasing, and noise reduction. Resultantly, "Barry Lyndon" displays an unprecedented clarity, with significant print damages nowhere to be found.
The color reproduction is another highlight; John Alcott’s palette is showcased in all its glory. Flesh tones are natural and beautifully saturated without excess. The lush greens of fields, the clear blues of skies, and the warm hues of candlelit interiors are exceptionally well rendered. Blacks are deep and absorbing, contributing to the film’s visual depth and richness. Particularly noteworthy is the rendering of candlelit scenes, which maintain impressive detail and lifelike skin tones despite the challenging lighting conditions. The encode manages intermittent ringing and minor telecine wobble with finesse, keeping distractions to a minimum.
Overall, Warner's Blu-ray transfer presents "Barry Lyndon" in a visually stunning manner that honors Kubrick's vision. The careful preservation of film grain and the meticulous attention to detail make this one of the best-looking presentations of Kubrick's work. Every aspect, from wide shots to intimate close-ups and color fidelity to black levels, has been executed with precision, delivering an exceptional visual experience.
Audio: 63
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track on the Blu-ray presentation of "Barry Lyndon" is a meticulously crafted update that maintains the integrity of the original mono mix while offering a more contemporary, immersive experience. Despite being largely front-heavy, subtle effects are strategically employed through the rear speakers, enhancing the film's lush, painterly visuals and the evocative classical score. Dialogue is consistently clean and clear, preserving the authentic mid-70s period feel. Effects, though occasionally sparse, maintain fidelity to the original soundscape. The mix strikes an admirable balance, updating the audio without compromising Warner's commitment to authenticity.
Ambient sounds and sound effects are understated yet contribute effectively when present, imbuing scenes with an organic, robust quality. The soundstage is wider at the front, providing a smoother and more natural dialogue presentation. The low-frequency effects (LFE) and dynamic range are excellent, with both score and narration seamlessly integrated into the overall sound mix. This careful reimagining provides a compelling auditory experience, bringing a timeless classic into the modern age without diminishing its original charm. Subtitles are available in English SDH, French, and Spanish, making the presentation accessible to a broader audience. Overall, the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track truly delivers a top-tier audio experience for fans of classic cinema.
Extras: 19
The Blu-ray edition of "Barry Lyndon" offers a modest yet insightful array of extras that provide deeper context and appreciation for Stanley Kubrick's meticulously crafted period drama. While the previous releases were lacking in substantial special features, this edition makes a respectable effort with a range of interviews and behind-the-scenes content. Each feature gives a glimpse into the meticulous production, the director's vision, and the film's cultural impact.
Extras included in this disc:
- Making "Barry Lyndon": A documentary featuring interviews with cast and crew.
- Interview with Martin Scorsese: The acclaimed director discusses Kubrick's influence on cinema.
- Featurette on the unique cinematography: Highlighting the innovative techniques used in filming.
- Production Design Gallery: A collection of stills showcasing the film's elaborate set and costume designs.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional trailer for the film.
Movie: 92
Stanley Kubrick's adaptation of William Makepeace Thackeray's novel "The Luck of Barry Lyndon" stands as one of his most challenging and unconventional films. Released in 1975, "Barry Lyndon" is a period drama that subverts cinematic conventions, disarming its audience with its meticulous, almost languid pacing. The film follows the life of Redmond Barry (Ryan O'Neil), from his early misfortunes in Ireland to his climb up the social ladder through deceit, manipulation, and marriage to a wealthy countess (Marisa Berenson). Kubrick's direction transforms what could be a standard historical epic into a detached, ironic commentary on ambition and downfall. John Alcott's cinematography and the use of natural lighting create a painterly quality, framing each scene like an 18th-century masterpiece.
The narrative unfolds deliberately, with Kubrick employing a detached observational stance. Violence and tragedy are frequent yet depicted from a distance, rendering them emotionally disengaged. Barry's character is consistently narcissistic and self-destructive, his actions driven by selfish motives rather than any redeeming qualities. The film's dual acts showcase Barry's rise and inevitable fall, marked by personal failures and societal rejection. Kubrick's meticulous craftsmanship extends to every technical detail—the natural lighting, lavish set designs, and the classical score—making "Barry Lyndon" visually stunning. The film's slow burn and its protagonist's unlikability may alienate some viewers; however, this methodical approach serves to deepen the impact of Barry's ultimate descent.
Despite its length and deliberate pace, "Barry Lyndon" is hailed for its artistic grandeur and technical achievements. It garnered four Oscars and remains one of Kubrick's most visually arresting works. Each viewing unveils new facets of its intricate design, inviting audiences to appreciate the subtle intricacies that underpin Kubrick’s storytelling. As a film that both enthralls and challenges, it exemplifies Kubrick's genius, demanding attention and rewarding those who engage with its profound complexities.
Total: 61
Warner has done a commendable job with the new Blu-ray release of "Barry Lyndon," an often polarizing yet visually majestic masterpiece by Stanley Kubrick. The meticulous cinematography, characterized by its use of natural light and period-authentic visuals, is rendered in stunning clarity on this disc. The video transfer faithfully preserves the mid-70s aesthetic, providing a rewarding experience that is true to the original film’s intent. Remarkably, the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track offers a reliable and immersive auditory experience, although it lacks the dynamic range of modern sound design.
Despite the allure of the picture and sound quality, the absence of supplemental material is a glaring omission, especially for a film that warrants comprehensive behind-the-scenes insights and directorial commentary. This Blu-ray edition might have benefited greatly from additional content, particularly when considering the film’s niche yet ardently appreciative fan base. Nonetheless, at a competitive price point of $13.99, the disc offers substantial value for money, making it an easy acquisition for Kubrick aficionados and collectors alike.
Barry Lyndon isn’t an easy film to love. Then again, neither is Lyndon. Kubrick pushes, challenges, and innovates his way through the 18th century with a cinematic effortlessness that cloaks his perfectionism and subsequent 300-day shoot. Even at its slowest, it’s a beautiful film; even at its most infuriating, it captivates; even at its most cynical hour, it has something of value to say. It isn’t Kubrick’s most beloved masterpiece, but it’s a masterpiece all the same. Warner’s Blu-ray release is excellent as well. While it doesn’t offer any extras (a disappointment to be sure), its video transfer is as rewarding and faithful as mid-70s catalog presentations come and its DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track is respectful, reliable, and true. Barry Lyndon is all but reborn on Blu-ray.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 90
Grain has been preserved, fine textures are in surprising supply, many a brightly lit closeup is near-revelatory, edge definition is true to the source, wide shots are beautiful and painterly, and delineation...
Audio: 80
Though largely front-heavy, the rear speakers are used to subtle effect to slowly draw listeners into the living paintings, classical music and wind-swept duels that populate Kubrick's lyrical epic....
Extras: 10
Like previous releases of the film, the Blu-ray edition of Barry Lyndon doesn't offer any substantial special features aside from a poorly presented theatrical trailer....
Movie: 90
John Alcott's lavish cinematography clings to Kubrick's every thematic and narrative nuance, encasing Lyndon in the sumptuously lit, ultimately lifeless world of a man blind to his own inadequacy, guilty...
Total: 80
While it doesn't offer any extras (a disappointment to be sure), its video transfer is as rewarding and faithful as mid-70s catalog presentations come and its DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track is...
The Digital Bits review by Bill HuntRead review here
Video: 80
Audio: 80
Though its 5.1, the mix accurately represents the soundtrack’s original mono tonal quality, but adds more ambience, particularly with the music and certain sound effects (the rapport of gunfire, for example)....
Extras: 35
Movie: 95
It’s unlikely, because most such epics use a much wider canvas and more vivid cinematography – think Spartacus, which was also directed by Stanley Kubrick....
Total: 73
Meanwhile, when you consider that this disc is available for just $13.99 on Amazon (as an Amazon exclusive) is hard to get too worked up about it....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
That being said, detail is still sharp and vivid, especially during closeups, which reveal the intimate detail in the costumes and lace as well as individual hairs, bumps, and wrinkles on the actor's skin....
Audio: 80
This is mostly a front heavy mix, but the rear speakers and bass to kick in from time to time, giving us a fully immersive soundscape into this visually beautiful film....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 100
Kubrick not only wanted to make a film that was similar to walking into one of the greatest art galleries of the world and spending hours looking at the gorgeous paintings, but also show us an objective...
Total: 80
The slow burn really hypnotizes us all the way through, leaving us with a very satisfying taste....
Director: Stanley Kubrick
Actors: Ryan O'Neal, Marisa Berenson, Patrick Magee
PlotSet in the 18th century, the story follows Redmond Barry, a young Irishman of modest means who becomes infatuated with his cousin. His romantic aspirations are shattered when she becomes engaged to a British officer. Driven by heartbreak and ambition, Barry challenges the officer to a duel and, believing he has killed him, flees his home to avoid arrest. He joins the British Army but soon deserts and is captured by the Prussians. After displaying cunning and bravery, he earns a position in the Prussian military and later becomes a protégé of a Prussian nobleman, leading a life of deceit and adventure across Europe.
Barry's fortunes take a dramatic turn when he seduces and marries a wealthy widow, Lady Lyndon, assuming the title of Barry Lyndon. He enters high society but faces the challenges of maintaining his newfound status. His behavior grows increasingly reckless and tyrannical as he seeks to secure his family's financial future and social standing. Meanwhile, his strained relationships with Lady Lyndon and her son from her first marriage set the stage for growing tension and inevitable downfall.
Writers: Stanley Kubrick, William Makepeace Thackeray
Release Date: 18 Dec 1975
Runtime: 185 min
Rating: PG
Country: United Kingdom, United States
Language: English, German, French