Tokyo Sonata Blu-ray Review
トウキョウソナタ T�ky� sonata Masters of Cinema
Score: 60
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Solid Eureka BD of Kurosawa's film with detailed visuals, pleasant audio, and comprehensive extras.
Disc Release Date
Video: 55
'Tokyo Sonata's Blu-ray transfer, with its well-executed dark tones and strong contrast, showcases vibrant yet muted colors and organic grain, enhancing the mood without losing detail.
Audio: 55
'Tokyo Sonata's audio, with its delicately engineered tracks and emphasis on silence, presents a clear, immersive experience, complemented by a minimalistic score.
Extra: 66
Eureka Masters of Cinema releases 'Tokyo Sonata' with rich extras including a detailed making-of documentary, cast Q&As, premiere footage, a DVD discussion, a UK HD trailer, and a 28-page booklet, all highlighting Kurosawa's insights and the movie's depth.
Movie: 81
Kiyoshi Kurosawa's 'Tokyo Sonata' is a poignant exploration of a family's disintegration amid economic distress, interweaving themes of loss, tradition, and resilience.
Video: 55
Kiyoshi Kurosawa's "Tokyo Sonata" is brought to life on Bluray in a 1.85:1 widescreen presentation, utilizing a 1080p MPEG-4 AVC encoding that reveals the film's nuanced visual texture and color palette. The video quality enhances the atmospheric storytelling, displaying a striking contrast ratio and a rich saturation of primary colors that underscore the film's emotional depth. While initially appearing dark, the visuals are deliberately so, complementing the narrative’s mood perfectly. The dark tones, combined with a well-managed grain presence, contribute to a presentation that feels authentic and grounded. The transfer showcases vibrant greens, reds, and blues, especially noting the standout hues such as the deep red of a character’s shawl and the muted greens of a suburban landscape, all of which are rendered with precision.
The Blu-ray transfer remains stable and tight to the frame, with no significant issues like edge enhancement or macroblocking to detract from the viewing experience. In particular, the outer scenes display exemplary sharpness, bringing to life the director’s intent with clarity that enhances the visual storytelling. Though there are some instances where indoor scenes may seem somewhat soft, this appears aligned with Kurosawa's cinematic vision rather than a flaw in the transfer itself. The film’s grain texture is consistent and unobtrusive, maintaining the film's filmic integrity without veering into excessive noise reduction.
Health of the video transfer is commendable; there are no alarming signs of damage or age in the form of scratches or debris, ensuring that the visual presentation remains pristine. Subtitles receive special mention for their clear translation and ease of reading, an essential feature that facilitates engagement with the narrative. Despite some moments of softness, mainly in interior scenes that carry an intended aesthetic value, details across various settings are well-preserved, contributing to an overall satisfying high-definition experience that respects and uplifts Kurosawa’s storytelling craftsmanship.
Audio: 55
The audio presentation of "Tokyo Sonata" on Blu-ray is offered through three distinct tracks: Japanese DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0, Japanese Dolby TrueHD 2.0, and Japanese Dolby Digital 2.0. After thorough evaluation, including a comparison between the DTS-HD Master Audio and Dolby TrueHD options, it is clear that both provide a similarly high-quality experience, with a slight edge in dialogue clarity observed on the Dolby TrueHD track. The film’s delicate nature is well-reflected in its audio composition, maintaining crisp and clear dialogue throughout, allowing for an immersive viewing experience. The ambient sounds, such as the rustling of leaves and distant trains, add depth to the audio landscape without overwhelming the spoken word, showcasing an impressive front separation and a wide soundstage.
The minimalistic score by Kazumasa Hashimoto plays a subtle yet significant role in enhancing the emotional undertones of the film. It surfaces sparingly but effectively, utilizing gentle flutes and other instruments that blend seamlessly into the mix, accentuating moments of revelation without detracting from the overall serenity. This careful balance underscores the meticulous engineering behind the audio track. Despite its understated presence, the soundtrack, alongside the naturalistic sound effects, contributes to the film's delicate ambience, creating an engaging auditory experience.
Notably, the attention to silence as a compositional element stands out, with its powerful impact on the viewing experience. Such silences punctuate the narrative, underscoring the film's thematic elements with profound quietness that is as evocative as any sound effect used throughout. While this Blu-ray's audio presentation may not be classified as demo material due to its understated approach, it is undeniably well-engineered and perfectly suits the source material's nuanced storytelling approach. This technical proficiency ensures that whether one selects the DTS-HD Master Audio or Dolby TrueHD track, the auditory aspect of "Tokyo Sonata" is faithfully preserved, enhancing the film's delicate narrative and emotional depth.
Extras: 66
The Blu-ray release of "Tokyo Sonata" within the Eureka Masters of Cinema series is praised for its rich collection of extras, all thoughtfully presented with English subtitles. Unique insights into the film's creation are revealed through a comprehensive Making of Documentary, where behind-the-scenes footage and cast interviews delve deep into their experiences and director Kurosawa's methodologies. The inclusion of a Q&A session, the film's premiere footage, and a focused DVD Discussion, enhance understanding of the film's production and thematic depth. A high-definition UK trailer and a deluxe 28-page booklet, featuring directorial notes and an insightful essay by B. Kite on Kurosawa's oeuvre, round out this well-curated package. Especially notable is the documentary's exposition on the film-making process, alongside candid interactions during the Q&A and premiere segments, offering fans and cinephiles alike a rather comprehensive glimpse behind the curtain of this acclaimed film.
Extras included in this disc:
- Making of Documentary: An extensive look at the film's production, featuring B-roll footage and cast interviews.
- Questions and Answers Session, Tokyo, Sep 2008: Candid discussions with Kurosawa and the cast post-Cannes Film Festival.
- Premiere, Tokyo, Sep 2008: Features introduction of the film and cast before its Tokyo premiere.
- DVD Discussion: Insights on DVD recording benefits, with talk from Kurosawa, Kagawa, and Koizumi.
- Trailer: High-definition trailer for the UK audience.
- Booklet: A 28-page booklet with a director's note and an essay by B. Kite.
Movie: 81
Kiyoshi Kurosawa's "Tokyo Sonata," a poignant narrative diverging significantly from his usual foray into horror, delves into the life of a typical Japanese family ensnared in the throes of an economic downturn. The movie, crowned with the Un Certain Regard Jury Prize at the Cannes Film Festival in 2008, meticulously portrays the unraveling of familial bonds following the patriarch Ryuhei's (Teruyuki Kagawa) secretive unemployment. Much like Ryuhei's silent struggle, his wife Megumi (Kyôko Koizumi) and their sons Kenji (Inowaki Kai) and Takashi (Yû Koyanagi) each navigate their personal turmoil, unknowingly echoing the broader societal malaise of loss, pride, and disenchantment with traditional roles. "Tokyo Sonata" channels a narrative harmony that is both simplistic in its focus on family dynamics yet complex and layered in its exploration of societal pressures and individual aspirations.
In a departure from his horror roots, Kurosawa crafts a film that is strikingly transparent and resonant with global audiences, tackling universal themes such as dignity, loyalty, and the quest for personal identity amidst societal expectations. The film’s execution is technically flawless, boasting stellar performances that infuse the narrative with authenticity and depth. Detailed attention to emotional subtlety is captured through Kurosawa’s lens, complemented by Kazumasa Hashimoto’s minimalistic score, enhancing the film's poignant atmosphere. This nuanced portrayal is encapsulated in sequences where character expressions convey volumes, underscoring the director's ability to evoke empathy without reliance on dialogue.
"Tokyo Sonata" stands as a testament to Kurosawa's versatility and insight into human relationships, presenting a narrative that transcends cultural boundaries with its deeply humanistic approach. The film not only showcases the fragile yet resilient nature of familial ties but also serves as a mirror to the economic challenges facing contemporary society. Through its melding of personal and collective narratives, "Tokyo Sonata" emerges as a critical and emotive examination of the modern human condition, marking it as one of the most significant Japanese cinematic contributions of its time.
Total: 60
The Blu-ray presentation of "Tokyo Sonata" by Eureka Masters of Cinema is a testament to the careful, diligent work that goes into preserving and presenting films in their best light, despite some inherent limitations. The visual quality, while somewhat soft, aligns well with the filmmaker's intentions, showcasing vibrant colors, a strong contrast ratio, and an appreciable amount of detail that together enhance the viewing experience. The audio, delivered in 2.0 DTS Master Audio/Dolby TrueHD, though not the pinnacle of sound technology, is expertly mixed to create an enveloping soundstage that complements the on-screen drama effectively.
The supplementary materials included with this release are nothing short of comprehensive. They offer an insightful look into the movie's creation, its thematic underpinnings, and the logistical aspects of its distribution, thereby adding significant value for enthusiasts and scholars alike. The inclusion of English subtitles across all content underscores Eureka's commitment to accessibility, ensuring that "Tokyo Sonata" can be appreciated by a global audience. This attention to detail and dedication to quality echoes throughout the entirety of the package, cementing its status as a polished and worthy addition to any film aficionado's collection.
In conclusion, while the Blu-ray presentation of "Tokyo Sonata" may not push the boundaries of technical excellence in audio and video quality, it stands as a must-have for fans of Kurosawa and dramatic cinema. Eureka Entertainment's handling of this release exemplifies their role as custodians of cinema, offering a product that is very highly recommended and transcends geographical limitations. The overall package is a compelling purchase, skillfully balancing film preservation with the nuanced demands of contemporary audiences.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 70
There is grain present in the majority of the scenes but it's always organic and unobtrusive....
Audio: 70
Other effects such as the trains which pass over the line close to the Sasaki's home bring forth a powerful rumble, which disrupts the almost serene and peaceful silences which are present throughout....
Extras: 70
There was a very strange segment where Kyoko Koizumi fed the rest of cast some donuts!DVD Discussion (9mins) - Kurosawa, Kagawa and Koizumi discuss the advantages which DVD based recording has allowed...
Movie: 80
With source material which could not be further from his usual offerings, 'Sonata' is the tale of a traditional Japanese family feeling the pressure of the credit crunch....
Total: 80
The video presentation, while appearing somewhat soft at times, suits the source material and does boast good colouring, a strong contrast ratio and plenty of detail....
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 80
Finally, the actual transfer is notably healthy � there are no disturbing scratches, debris, dirt, or stains to report in this review....
Audio: 80
I opted for the Japanese DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track and later on did a few random comparisons with the other two tracks for the purpose of this review....
Extras: 70
DVD Discussion - Teruyuki Kagawa, Ky�ko Koizumi and director Kurosawa talk about some of the advantages DVD viewing offers, such as comparing the final version of the film with the script, taking a closer...
Movie: 90
Takashi announces in front of his mother that he has passed the necessary tests and is ready to become a soldier....
Total: 80
Eureka Entertainment have put together a solid package that should appeal to just about everyone, regardless of one's geographical location....
Director: Kiyoshi Kurosawa
Actors: Teruyuki Kagawa, Kyôko Koizumi, Yû Koyanagi
PlotSet in contemporary Tokyo, the film explores the lives of the Sasaki family, which appears to embody the typical middle-class household. Ryuhei Sasaki, the father, loses his administrative job due to outsourcing but hides his unemployment from his family, pretending to go to work every day. This dishonesty stems from a mix of pride and fear of losing respect within his family. Meanwhile, his wife, Megumi, occupies herself with domestic duties, unaware of the financial instability creeping into their lives. Their two sons, Takashi and Kenji, quietly deal with their own personal challenges and ambitions that diverge significantly from the paths their parents envision for them.
As the narrative unfolds, each family member's secret and individual struggle begin to surface, challenging the fragile veneer of their family unity. Kenji, the younger son, seeks solace and meaning in learning piano lessons against his father's wishes, viewing it as an unnecessary expense. On the other hand, Takashi, the older son, deals with his existential dread and lack of direction by making a drastic and unexpected decision about his future. Within this framework, the film delicately portrays the unraveling of family dynamics and societal pressures, reflecting broader themes of identity, purpose, and the quest for personal fulfillment against the backdrop of modern societal expectations and economic hardship.
Writers: Kiyoshi Kurosawa, Max Mannix, Sachiko Tanaka
Release Date: 27 Sep 2008
Runtime: 120 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: Japan, Netherlands, Hong Kong
Language: Japanese