Serena Blu-ray Review
Score: 66
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Despite superior Blu-ray video and audio quality, 'Serena' falters with a thin, monotonous story, making it worth a rental at best.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 77
Serena’s Blu-ray presentation, encoded in 1080p AVC/MPEG-4 on a BD-50, excels with its vibrant, finely detailed visuals and solid black levels, accurately capturing the lush landscapes and period details, despite its average bitrate of 22.99 Mbps.
Audio: 77
Serena's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix impresses with immersive soundscapes, effectively layering nature sounds, logging activity, and Johan Söderqvist's orchestral score. Dialogue is clear despite occasional imbalance with sound effects, and dynamic range captures everything from deep bass to sharp cracks.
Extra: 43
The Blu-ray extras for *Serena* include high-definition deleted scenes, insightful making-of featurettes, and detailed production design overviews, effectively capturing various technical aspects like the film's Appalachian recreation in Europe and screenwriting adaptations, though they notably avoid addressing any on-set challenges.
Movie: 37
Despite its lush visuals and high-profile cast, 'Serena' is marred by a meandering plot, tonal flatness, and inconsistent character development, leaving critical elements underexplored and reliant on inference, ultimately failing to deliver on its ambitious premise.
Video: 77
"Serena," shot on the Red Epic and overseen by cinematographer Morten Søborg, offers viewers a visually compelling Blu-ray experience, thanks to its meticulous production design and technical achievements. The 1080p AVC/MPEG-4 encoded transfer presents a sharp, detailed picture with vivid colors that bring both the grandeur of nature and the devastation of Pemberton's lumber operations to life. Details in period costumes, makeup, hairstyles, and decor are readily visible, with deep black levels and solid earth tones dominating the palette. The film’s digitally originated material achieves an average bitrate of 22.99 Mbps on a BD-50 disc, which proves to be adequate as no artifacts are detected.
The unique color grading, characterized by warm hues and accents of brown and green, beautifully matches the film’s setting. Occasional bursts of blue and red against the earthy backdrop provide additional vibrancy without oversaturation. Lighting plays a crucial role, enhancing the lush forests and rolling hills while maintaining high contrast for stunning visuals. This Blu-ray transfer exhibits high clarity and detail, particularly in facial features and clothing textures. The scenery, supposedly representing 1929 North Carolina but subbed by Eastern European landscapes, looks exceptional with naturalistic depth and sharpness.
Magnolia Home Entertainment ensures an exemplary transfer without any detectable postproduction tweaks, resulting in a spotless presentation devoid of noise or artifacts. The color reproduction stays inviting throughout, with deep inky blacks and white levels that do not blow out. Even moments of slight banding cannot diminish the overall splendid image quality. This Blu-ray edition of "Serena" truly showcases Magnolia's commitment to delivering some of the best visual experiences on the market.
Audio: 77
The audio presentation of "Serena" on Blu-Ray features a robust DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix that genuinely enhances the film's immersive quality. The sound design intricately layers natural and industrial noises, effortlessly transporting viewers to Pemberton's logging operation. From the crisp crack of trees being felled to the resonant thud upon their impact, the dynamic range is impressively broad. Gunshots, horses' hooves, and the hiss of steam machinery are lifelike and well-dispersed across the soundstage. Dialogue remains largely clean and clear, despite some regional accents, and Johan Söderqvist's orchestral score provides significant depth and emotion, further enriched by its deep bass extension.
While the score by Söderqvist dominates the soundscape, the mix maintains a commendable balance with dialogue and effects. Actors' voices register clearly from start to finish, though there are sporadic instances where the sound effects slightly overpower dialogue; these moments are relatively minor and usually do not detract from crucial scenes. The mix predominantly utilizes the front channels but also leverages the rear channels effectively to create atmospheric soundscapes, particularly highlighting the laborious efforts of the loggers. The ambient noise at the train station is another standout element, adding to the immersive experience.
In summary, "Serena's" DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix delivers a solid auditory experience, marked by an engaging dynamic range and balanced orchestration. It successfully creates a vivid aural backdrop that complements and enriches the visual narrative.
Extras: 43
"Serena" on Blu-ray offers a compelling set of special features that provide an insightful look into the film's production process and creative challenges. The deleted scenes offer significant context to Rachel's storyline and include notable developments that weren't part of the final cut. The behind-the-scenes featurettes explore the intricate details of production design, costume creation, and screenplay adaptation while capturing the collaborative spirit among the cast and crew. These extras, presented in high definition, deliver a thorough and engaging exploration of how "Serena" was brought to life, despite not addressing any on-set issues directly.
Extras included in this disc:
- Deleted Scenes: Fourteen scenes that provide additional context to various storylines.
- The Making of Serena: The Story, Direction & Characters: Interviews with cast and crew discussing the film’s narrative elements.
- Exploring the Production Design and Time Period: Insights on recreating 1929 America in the Czech Republic.
- Following the Screenwriting: Comparing the Film and the Novel: Comparison of the film adaptation to Ron Rash’s novel.
- Breaking Down the Set: Kingsport Tanners, Train Station & Main Street: Detailed look at key sets used in the film.
- Also from Magnolia Home Entertainment: Trailers and promos included as additional content.
Movie: 37
"Serena," set against the majestic backdrop of 1929 North Carolina's Smoky Mountains, stars Bradley Cooper and Jennifer Lawrence in their third collaboration. Directed by Susanne Bier, who replaced original director Darren Aronofsky, the film adapts Ron Rash's 2008 novel. Despite the star-studded cast and promising source material, the movie disintegrates into a cliché-ridden, sometimes incoherent narrative. Various tones and thematic strands such as Macbeth-like ambition, Medea-esque vengeance, and wilderness-induced savagery are flirted with but never fully embraced. This tonal indecision, coupled with scenes of questionable relevance and a slew of foreshadowing that never surprises, results in an impact that's disjointed rather than cohesive.
Technically, the film suffers from a disparate adaptation with a screenplay by Christopher Kyle that veers too far from its literary source. The disconnect is exacerbated by heavy-handed edits and a lack of coherent storytelling. The characters remain poorly defined; George Pemberton's (Cooper) backstory emerges through clumsy exposition, while Serena (Lawrence), despite her compelling potential, becomes an enigmatic figure whose motivations and actions remain frustratingly opaque. The film's production design and lush visuals indeed stand out—scenes evoke oil paintings with their period-authentic aesthetics. Nonetheless, Bier's direction creates a suffocating atmosphere where the narrative feels rigidly on rails, much like the film's own symbolic locomotive, hurtling from one foregone conclusion to another without the nuance required to engage its audience.
Ultimately, "Serena" is visually compelling yet narratively barren. Every layer of potential thematic richness—be it the couple’s dynamics, moral corruption, or societal conflict—is left underdeveloped. Viewers are battered with relentless bleakness without room for emotional investment, resulting in a viewing experience that feels more rote than revelatory. While it visually captivates, "Serena" remains an exercise in frustration, where considerable talent is squandered by an unfocused script and an unyielding directorial grip.
Total: 66
"Serena" features first-rate production values and an interesting cast led by Jennifer Lawrence and Bradley Cooper. However, it ultimately fails to deliver a compelling narrative. Despite what may have been the potential for an engaging, sweeping epic, the final product feels monotonous and thin. The film relies too heavily on the star power of its leads, but this isn't enough to compensate for its lack of a coherent and captivating story.
On a technical level, the Blu-ray release excels. The video and audio quality are pristine, making the visuals akin to a painting come to life. The extras included are serviceable, providing some behind-the-scenes insight despite the troubled production history. These supplemental features might appeal to those deeply interested in the film's design and cinematography, but they do little to elevate the overall experience of watching a largely disappointing film.
In conclusion, "Serena" has first-rate production values and an interesting cast, and the Blu-ray is technically superior. If that is enough for you, then by all means acquire it. If you care about a coherent story that's well told, skip it.
Blu-ray.com review by Michael ReubenRead review here
Video: 90
Clear, sharp, detailed and colorful, the image brings both the beauty of the natural surroundings, and the contrasting devastation wrought by Pemberton's lumber operations, to the home video screen in...
Audio: 90
Sounds of nature and of the activity in Pemberton's logging operation are layered into the mix all around, and wide dynamic range reproduces the sense of a huge tree falling from the sharp crack of the...
Extras: 60
The Making of Serena: The Story, Direction & Characters (1080p; 1.78:1; 18:23): Lawrence, Cooper, Ifans, Ularu, Dencik, Bier, Kyle and others discuss the characters and the place of each one in the story....
Movie: 40
It's almost as if everyone involved became so familiar with the story that they began to speak in code, forgetting that most of the audience would not share their familiarity and would need to be led by...
Total: 50
Serena�has first-rate production values and an interesting cast, and the Blu-ray is technically superior....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Adding to that is the unique color scheme of the film that washes everything in golden hues with hints of brown and green, matching the environment nicely....
Audio: 80
Although the mix favors the front channels, it makes good use of the rear channels to create an atmosphere that approximates the sounds of men laboring to cut down massive trees with what would be considered...
Extras: 40
This featurette is your typical behind-the-scenes adventure that includes interviews with the cast and crew – mostly the crew – as they talk about the minute details that went into creating the film....
Movie: 40
For whatever reason, despite the talent behind the film, and the richness of source material, the project failed to gel, and the result is a cliché-ridden, sometimes incoherent mess....
Total: 60
The thing is, there may have once been a wonderful, sweeping epic to tell, but the way this film was composed, the end product simply feels monotonous and thin....
Why So Blu? review by Gerard IribeRead review here
Video: 100
Depth: Magnolia always creates some of the best Blu-rays on the market and Serena is no different....
Audio: 100
Extras: 40
Serena on Blu-ray has a few interesting special features that include deleted scenes, making-of featurettes, director and screenwriter interviews, production design overviews, etc....
Movie: 40
The film does not suffer from any negative side effects of those scheduling conflicts but the script is very thin when it comes to characterizing our two leads....
Total: 50
The video and audio quality is like a painting come to life and the extras are just fine considering what a troubled production it was to get the film made and released but it’s too bad the final film...
Director: Susanne Bier
Actors: Bradley Cooper, Jennifer Lawrence, Rhys Ifans
PlotIn the rugged landscape of Depression-era North Carolina, a burgeoning timber empire is led by George Pemberton. His life takes an electrifying turn when he meets and marries the enigmatic Serena. Together, they ambitiously strive to build a successful business amidst the perils and challenges of the wild. Serena proves to be an equal partner, displaying unparalleled skill and determination. Her presence strengthens George’s operations as they face obstacles from both nature and rivals who seek to undermine their efforts.
As their power grows, so do complications within their relationship. Serena’s intense drive and George’s hidden past begin to create a rift, intensified by secrets and betrayals. Tensions escalate when Serena's unyielding ambition reveals a darker, more ruthless side. Her discoveries about George's earlier indiscretions lead to dangerous consequences, forever altering their lives and the fate of their empire.
Writers: Christopher Kyle, Ron Rash
Release Date: 26 Feb 2015
Runtime: 109 min
Rating: R
Country: France, United States, Czech Republic
Language: English