Broil Blu-ray Review
Score: 57
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Broil offers stylish moments and a slick screenplay, but suffers from an overcrowded plot and distractingly high audio levels.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 72
Well Go USA delivers a competent 1080p AVC encoded 2.39:1 Blu-ray transfer for 'Broil.' While darker scenes can appear hazy or murky, well-lit sequences showcase good detail with a natural palette. The modest definition reflects recent standards, with occasional murkiness in shadows but impressive for an independent film.
Audio: 72
Broil's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track offers a dynamic and atmospheric soundscape with exceptional channel separation, deep bass, and clear dialogue, though the overpowering score can be distracting. Fidelity is near perfect, making the surround mix effective, especially in heightening the horror elements.
Extra: 2
Despite 'Broil' being one of Well Go USA's standout horror releases, the Blu-ray extras are limited to a few automatic trailers and an HD original trailer, missing potentially enriching content like a director commentary.
Movie: 66
Broil offers an intriguing premise and a rich ensemble cast led by Jonathan Lipnicki, with suspenseful storytelling and unique monster mythology, but is frequently hampered by confounding edits and structural choices, making the narrative dauntless and leaving too many unanswered questions by the end.
Video: 72
"Broil" is presented on Blu-ray by Well Go USA, featuring an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 2.39:1. The video quality, largely presumed to be captured digitally and finished at a 2K DI, offers a competent yet modestly engaging visual experience. Significant portions of the film unfold in near darkness, leading to frequent instances of hazy or murky scenes. The better-lit segments exhibit good fine detail, although a certain gauzy softness can detract from consistent detail levels. The color palette appears natural overall, despite some scenes being distinctly graded towards reds or blues, resulting in a minor reduction in fine detail.
The 2.39:1 presentation at 1080p provides a faithful representation of the film. The cinematography achieves deep black levels, enhancing the demonic narrative with a masterful tone. Encoded at adequate AVC parameters on a BD-25, the film’s 90-minute runtime is effectively handled. The muted palette and darker colors within Wai Sun Cheng's cinematography style highlight pale flesh tones while selective primary colors exhibit saturated pops when necessary. Despite occasional murkiness in shadow delineation, the transfer remains largely unprocessed, delivering a clean and precise visual presentation for an independent film. Even the limited VFX and CGI elements appear impressive under this transfer.
Audio: 72
The audio presentation of "Broil" features a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track that is largely competent with some notable technical achievements and a few issues. The soundtrack's strong presence and deep bass contribute to an immersive atmosphere appropriate for its horror genre. The moody score and unsettling effects benefit from excellent channel separation, creating a dynamic soundstage. However, the mix suffers from occasional overemphasis on the musical score. For example, a series of thumping drums in the opening minutes drowns out other audio elements, a problem that unfortunately recurs intermittently throughout the film.
Despite these imbalances, the track exhibits great fidelity when not overpowered by music. Dialogue is generally clear and intelligible, maintaining pristine quality that ensures viewers do not miss crucial plot points. Directional panning and discrete rear action effectively enhance the soundstage, making it lively and engaging. The subtlety between whisper-quiet dialogue and louder elements is handled smoothly, providing a sense of ebb and flow that retains the audience's attention. Additionally, Broil's surround mix successfully adds layers of tension essential for the horror experience, weaving a frightening spell on the listener. The Blu-ray also includes optional English SDH subtitles in a white font within the scope presentation and a secondary 2.0 Dolby Digital soundtrack, though it can't match the main lossless surround mix.
Extras: 2
The Blu-ray release of "Broil" from Well Go USA, while equipped with high-definition visuals and effective disc navigation, is somewhat sparse in supplementary content. Although the film's engaging narrative could benefit from a director’s commentary, the included extras do provide some depth for enthusiasts. Trailers for both "Broil" and other Well Go USA releases are present, although they auto-play which might be a minor inconvenience for some viewers. The initial pressings feature a slipcover, adding a physical collectible element. The supplementary material could see improvement with additional behind-the-scenes content or interviews, yet what's offered is appreciable for what it is.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer: Original "Broil" trailer presented in 1080p quality for 1 minute 34 seconds.
- Well Go USA Trailers: Additional trailers amounting to 5 minutes and 55 seconds, including "Synchronic," "Cut Throat City," and "Valley of the Gods."
Movie: 66
"Broil," directed by Edward Drake, is a distinctive fusion of supernatural horror and family psychodrama that attempts to breathe new life into well-worn horror tropes. The film chronicles the sinister secrets of the affluent Sinclair family, focusing on the troubled 17-year-old Chance Sinclair (Avery Konrad). Following violent incidents at her Catholic school, Chance is exiled to live with her sinister grandfather August Sinclair (Timothy V. Murphy) at his opulent mansion for a year of homeschooling. What ensues is a nightmarish family dinner where diabolic secrets unravel. Jonathan Lipnicki and Corey Large round out a rich ensemble cast delivering haunting performances.
Although the movie has an intriguing premise, its execution suffers from disjointed storytelling and peculiar editing choices. The narrative is partitioned into supposed chapters that only serve to fragment the plot further, oscillating between different viewpoints and timelines in a manner that can be disorienting. These structural quirks divert focus from key characters like Chance, who is often sidelined, leaving numerous critical questions unanswered.
Despite these flaws, "Broil" succeeds in creating an effectively creepy atmosphere with its unnerving set design and artful direction, particularly for a B-movie with limited pedigree. Timothy V. Murphy’s chilling portrayal of August Sinclair is particularly noteworthy, evoking a palpable sense of dread. The unique blend of supernatural elements and family intrigue, coupled with the menacing undertones and cryptic clues, crafts a white-knuckle terror experience. While "Broil" may not find a massive audience due to its generic title, it stands out as an unsettling thriller with sharply drawn characters and surprising twists, marking Edward Drake as a director to watch in the horror genre.
Total: 57
"Broil" presents a mixed bag of experiences ranging from innovative concepts to a rather disjointed execution. The narrative struggles to maintain a coherent focus, often introducing and discarding characters at a whim, making it difficult to discern main characters from supporting ones. The family dynamics intertwined with the supernatural elements are ambitious yet convoluted, leading to an overstuffed plot that doesn’t fully resonate. The standout moments are stylish, with Jonathan Lipnicki delivering a commendable performance that adds a modicum of intrigue.
In terms of its technical prowess, the Blu-ray release of "Broil" is competent, offering generally solid technical merits. However, the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track exhibits an imbalance with the score, being mixed at excessively high levels that might detract from the viewing experience. The visuals are well-crafted, providing some atmospheric tension that aligns with the film’s intent, but these moments are sporadic, leaving the overall impact underwhelming for dedicated horror enthusiasts.
In conclusion, while "Broil" features an interesting blend of supernatural thrills and a strong screenplay with sinister undertones, it suffers from an overabundance of characters and an overstuffed plot that hinders its overall coherence. The technical aspects are largely proficient, though the audio mix may require adjustments for optimal enjoyment. Despite its shortcomings, "Broil" offers enough flair and stylistic elements to warrant a watch, particularly for those interested in supernatural narratives, albeit with tempered expectations.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
The better lit material has good amounts of fine detail, but even in some of these scenes there's a gauzy softness that can tend to work against consistent detail levels....
Audio: 80
The first time you'll notice this is in the first couple of minutes, where a hugely rumbling series of thumping drums simply drowns everything else out, and this is a tendency that recurs throughout the...
Extras: 10
Note: As tends to be the case with Well Go USA Blu-ray releases, the supplements have been authored to follow one another automatically After Trailer for this film plays, the disc has been authored to...
Movie: 40
The fact that Broil is evidently being released on Blu-ray in Germany as Vampire Dinner (this despite the fact that the IMDb does not list any alternate titles for the film, that I could find, anyway)...
Total: 40
Aside from the glut of characters, there's also arguably too much trying to be stuffed into the plot, with all sorts of family dynamics playing out within the context of whatever it is the Sinclairs are...
DoBlu review by Christopher ZabelRead review here
Video: 80
Boasting excellent production values, the 2020 film’s video quality has pleasing clarity with hints of deeper texture and detail....
Audio: 80
Directional panning and discrete rear action make for a lively soundstage, offering huge dynamics and whisper quiet dialogue....
Extras: 2
For an additional 28 Broil screenshots, early access to all screens (plus the 120,000+ already in our library), 120 exclusive 4K UHD reviews, and more goodies, subscribe on Patreon....
Movie: 100
Innocently caught up between the warring factions of her deadly family, Chance’s only hope for survival comes from a culinary killer-for-hire (Jonathan Lipnicki) brought in as a chef at the family gathering....
Total: 66
Slick supernatural thriller boasts a strong screenplay with wonderfully sinister characters....
Director: Edward Drake
Actors: Jonathan Lipnicki, Avery Konrad, Timothy V. Murphy
PlotA troubled teenager named Chance Sinclair is sent to live with her reclusive grandfather, August Sinclair, in his mansion after a violent incident at school. Her arrival at the Sinclair estate sets off a series of peculiar and unsettling events, capturing Chance's curiosity. August, a seemingly cold and enigmatic figure, maintains strict rules and an air of secrecy around the estate. As Chance delves deeper into her family history, she uncovers a hidden world of dark secrets and supernatural elements linked to a mysterious family fortune. August's overprotective demeanor and strange rituals lead Chance to suspect that there's more to her family's legacy than she initially thought.
Simultaneously, a professional chef named Sydney, hired by the Sinclair family for an upcoming feast, grapples with her own dark past. Her culinary expertise becomes entangled with the family's eerie traditions and intentions. As the date of the grand feast approaches, Chance and Sydney's paths collide, revealing twisted truths about the Sinclair family's omnipotent power and the sinister forces they possess. Tensions rise as both women realize they must confront these horrifying revelations while navigating their own personal demons. The tension mounts as the story builds towards a climactic confrontation that changes their lives forever.
Writers: Piper Mars, Edward Drake
Release Date: 05 Jul 2020
Runtime: 90 min
Rating: TV-14
Country: United States
Language: English