Red Dog Blu-ray Review
Remastered
Score: 65
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
20th Century Fox’s remastered Blu-ray of 'Patton' boasts a sharp, vibrant, and naturally filmic presentation, making it a must-own for fans.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 74
The remastered 1080p/AVC-encoded Blu-ray of 'Patton' corrects previous issues with overly de-noised, detail-lacking visuals, offering a lifelike, richly detailed image with intact grain structure, improved tonal qualities, vibrant colors, and superb fine detail, making it a high-definition transfer worth the upgrade.
Audio: 54
The Blu-ray retains the impressive DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, delivering clear dialogue and dynamic action sequences with directional effects that bely the film's age. Jerry Goldsmith's martial score is beautifully realized, though slight hiss and occasional harshness in Patton's commands are noted.
Extra: 61
The Blu-ray extras of 'Red Dog' lack significant updates, reusing previous DVD supplements, including an insightful commentary by Francis Ford Coppola and impactful documentaries like 'History Through the Lens: Patton: A Rebel Revisited' and 'Patton's Ghost Corps'. Despite redundancy, the features remain compelling and essential for fans.
Movie: 81
Fox's new Blu-ray remaster transforms 'Patton' from a glossy, detail-lacking earlier edition to a stunningly sharp, filmic presentation, faithfully preserving the 65mm clarity and providing an awe-inspiring tribute to this eight-time Academy Award-winning war biopic. This release reaffirms the film’s epic legacy.
Video: 74
The video presentation of the "Red Dog" Blu-ray is delivered in a stunning 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer that ensures a top-notch viewing experience for cinephiles. The image is richly detailed and maintains an impressive level of clarity throughout. Textures appear lifelike, with elements such as the weave of fabric and facial features exceptionally well-rendered. The film grain is preserved perfectly, providing an authentic and immersive viewing experience that respects the movie's original visual intent.
Color reproduction in this transfer stands out significantly. Reds are vivid and accurate, blues and other colors are vibrant and natural, and skin tones are incredibly realistic. The contrast levels have been meticulously managed, providing a greater depth to the image, with inky blacks that enhance the overall picture quality. This rejuvenated transfer not only corrects previous color inaccuracies but elevates the visual aesthetics to a new standard.
In summary, the "Red Dog" Blu-ray video presentation is a marked improvement over previous versions. With its pristine detailing, accurate colors, and flawless encoding devoid of compression issues, this release sets a new benchmark for high-definition catalog titles. This meticulously restored transfer undoubtedly justifies an upgrade from earlier editions, ensuring that fans and new viewers alike can enjoy the film at its visual best.
Audio: 54
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "Red Dog" boasts a robust DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track that mirrors the impressive mix of the previous editions. This is notable, given the film's biographical nature. The dialogue, a core component, consistently comes across clearly and precisely, though a slight hiss can be discerned if one listens meticulously. Instances where this is most noticeable involve Patton's barked commands that sometimes peak harshly. Action-heavy sequences deliver an immersive auditory experience, with strafing planes crisscrossing between speakers, bullets whizzing through the rear channels, and artillery shells detonating with impactful explosions.
The sound design achieves significant sonic spectacle during high-intensity scenes, rivaling modern film standards in terms of immersive experience. Explosions reverberate with commendable LFE presence, and the directional effects demonstrate remarkable accuracy and placement throughout the soundfield. Jerry Goldsmith's martial score is rendered with meticulous detail, utilizing crisp trumpets and snare drums. This score integrates seamlessly across the entire range of speakers, enhancing the viewing experience substantively.
However, it is essential to note that there are moments where the audio balance falters slightly, and the dynamic range—particularly in Patton's vocal projections—can be somewhat inconsistent. Despite these minor flaws, the overall auditory presentation remains highly engaging, maintaining a vitality that complements the film's narrative and visual intensity. Optional subtitles are available in various languages, including English, Mandarin, and Cantonese, further broadening accessibility.
Extras: 61
The Blu-ray extras for "Red Dog" offer immersive and comprehensive insights into the making and historical context of the film. Although the content remains identical to previous releases and is presented on a second DVD disc rather than Blu-ray, these extras are still captivating and informative. Francis Ford Coppola’s introduction and commentary provide a rich dive into the research and development phases, balanced portrayal of General Patton, and Coppola's personal anecdotes about his involvement in the project. The feature-length documentary "Patton: A Rebel Revisited" rigorously distinguishes fact from film fiction, supported by interviews with figures closely associated with Patton’s legacy. Additional features include veteran interviews, substantial making-of content, and in-depth galleries accompanied by insightful commentaries.
Extras included in this disc:
- Introduction by Francis Ford Coppola: Anecdote about his involvement in writing the screenplay.
- Feature Length Commentary by Francis Ford Coppola: Insights into authentic portrayal and script development.
- History Through the Lens: Patton: A Rebel Revisited: Detailed comparison between real-life Patton and his film portrayal.
- Patton's Ghost Corps: Interviews with surviving members of Patton's Ghost Corps.
- The Making of Patton: Interviews with filmmakers and cast, including George C. Scott and Oliver Stone.
- Production Stills Gallery: Gallery accompanied by Jerry Goldsmith’s complete musical score.
- Behind the Scenes Gallery: Gallery with commentary by Charles M. Provence, including an audio essay on the historical Patton.
Movie: 81
"Patton" stands as a monumental classic in cinema history, brought to life through Franklin Schaffner's meticulous direction and George C. Scott's indelible performance. The film explores the complex persona of General George S. Patton, weaving together his egotistical flaws and strategic brilliance in a manner that reverberates with authenticity and nuance. Revisiting "Patton" in its Blu-ray form, especially with the new remaster, brings this legendary war biopic into sharper focus. Key improvements in high-definition mastering and compression have significantly enhanced the visual fidelity previously marred by digital noise reduction (DNR) and edge enhancement issues typical of early Blu-ray releases.
Fox's new remaster corrects these flaws by removing unnecessary DNR and edge enhancement, restoring the film’s original texture. This not only retains the inherent grain synonymous with the 65mm large-format negatives but also preserves intricate details. Audiences can now appreciate the depth of field and clarity intended by the filmmakers, without the distraction of unnatural, smoothed-out faces or halo artifacts around hard outlines. The difference is especially evident in the sharpness of George C. Scott's rugged features, which now appear both natural and strikingly detailed.
"Patton," with its complex narrative and grand historical scope, deserved nothing less than a pristine visual presentation. The seamless blend of historical authenticity and dramatic license makes this a must-watch for both old fans and new viewers alike. The latest Blu-ray release finally does justice to this cinematic masterpiece, maintaining its status as an epic character study while providing an unadulterated viewing experience that highlights its legendary status in film history."
Total: 65
"Red Dog: Deluxe Edition" on Blu-Ray delivers a heartfelt and memorable viewing experience, enriched by a stunning high-definition transfer that fully captures the film's striking Australian outback. This release presents an excellent visual upgrade, with vibrant colors and sharp details that heighten the emotional impact and scenic beauty depicted throughout the movie. The remastering work is particularly commendable, eliminating any signs of digital artifacts and presenting a naturally filmic look that enhances the overall cinematic experience.
Audio quality on this Blu-Ray edition maintains a professional standard, delivering clear dialogue, immersive soundscapes, and a well-balanced score. These elements collectively enrich the viewer’s connection to the narrative and its characters. Special features are thoughtfully curated to provide additional insight into the making of "Red Dog," although they could have benefited from further depth and polish. Nevertheless, the included bonus content is still valuable for fans and newcomers alike, offering context and behind-the-scenes glimpses that complement the feature presentation.
In conclusion, "Red Dog: Deluxe Edition" on Blu-Ray is a significant improvement over previous releases, both visually and emotionally. The high-definition remastering ensures that viewers receive the most filmic and immersive experience possible, reaffirming the film’s enduring appeal. Despite wishing for a more extensive set of supplementary materials, this edition is still highly recommended for both long-time admirers and new audiences.
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 100
The weft of cloth, the intricacies of the sets, the dirt on helmets, the detail in the actors' facial features�with the grain structure intact, everything is tighter, more palpable, better resolved....
Audio: 80
The emphasis is largely on dialogue�this is more of a biopic than an out-and-out war movie�and it almost always comes through cleanly and clearly, although there are two or three instances where Patton's...
Extras: 70
As with the original release, the Blu-ray disc itself includes only an introduction (SD, 4:54) and a patchy but informative audio commentary, both by writer Francis Ford Coppola, who describes his early...
Movie: 90
Some viewers inexplicably approved�just look at the user reviews here on the site�but I have a feeling they'll reconsider after seeing the night-and-day difference in 20th Century Fox's all-new remaster...
Total: 90
While the audio and supplementary features remain the same, this is one of those rare instances where a double-dip based on picture quality alone is definitely worth it....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
When the 2008 version initially came out, there were few complaints – even High-Def Digest's review praised the image, while noticing the shortcomings – but over time, the overly ambitious removal of noise...
Audio: 60
Since 'Patton' isn't a war movie, per se, it's important that the film's audio mix deal primarily with the rather stellar dialogue given to the actors, and in this department, the sound does not miss....
Extras: 60
Disc 1: Introduction by Francis Ford Coppola – Coppola shares a wonderful anecdote about being hired to write the first draft of the screenplay for 'Patton,' which resulted in his being removed from the...
Movie: 80
"God, how I hate the twentieth century," he laments in the film early on, and things only get worse from there; try as he might, the world continues to evolve, but Patton stays the same: A fixture of history,...
Total: 80
George C. Scott's performance defined his career through more than a mere display of his acting prowess, but, like those stories, the performance lives on and should be considered one of the most significant...
Director: Kriv Stenders
Actors: Josh Lucas, Rachael Taylor, Rohan Nichol
PlotIn a remote mining town in the Australian outback, a wanderer named Thomas arrives and discovers an iconic statue of a dog. Entering the bar to wash up, Thomas encounters a group of locals who begin to recount the remarkable tale of a stray dog they named Red. Found by a publican named Jack and his wife Maureen, Red bonds with the entire town, touching the lives of all who meet him. Loved by everyone, the dog displays an uncanny knack for bringing people together and mending broken relationships in the close-knit community. However, it is the poignant bond formed with a bus driver named John that truly captivates the townspeople and Thomas, shedding light on a period when John and an American woman named Nancy arrive in town and their lives intertwine with the dog's.
As Red becomes an integral part of the town, his adventurous spirit leads him to form unbreakable ties with various miners, including Vanno, Peeto, and Jocko, helping them through some of their most challenging times. Each person has a unique story of how Red has impacted their lives, from saving them from danger to offering companionship in their loneliest moments. Red's loyalty to John and the search he embarks upon eventually cements his legendary status, encapsulating the themes of loyalty, friendship, and the search for belonging. Through these narratives, the film paints a vivid picture of community life, highlighting how one extraordinary dog left an everlasting legacy on an isolated town.
Writers: Daniel Taplitz, Louis de Bernières
Release Date: 18 Sep 2012
Runtime: 92 min
Rating: PG
Country: Australia, United States
Language: English, Polish