The Admiral: Roaring Currents Blu-ray Review
Myeong-ryang
Score: 72
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
'The Admiral: Roaring Currents' is a visually stunning and dramatically charged film with excellent audio-visual quality and compelling performances, especially from Choi Min-sik.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 77
The Admiral: Roaring Currents offers a stunning 1080p Blu-ray transfer, skillfully mastered with an average bitrate of 23.94 Mbps, delivering exceptional clarity, fine detail, and rich color reproduction. Despite minor banding, the image remains clean and sharp, presenting intricate warships and period costumes with remarkable precision.
Audio: 87
The Admiral: Roaring Currents' audio presentation excels with its DTS-HD MA 5.1 track, delivering an enveloping and powerful soundstage. Especially praised are the dynamic low-end during naval battles and the impressive imaging of dialogue, effects, and Kim Tae-seong's score, making it an auditory spectacle.
Extra: 30
The highlights feature repurposes core scenes without offering additional depth (SD), while the 'Making Of' (HD, 4:58) provides compelling behind-the-scenes insights into the film's complex production. The package is rounded off with well-crafted teasers and trailers, emphasizing the film's grand scale.
Movie: 83
The Admiral: Roaring Currents is a visually stunning and historically rich film that meticulously recreates the Battle of Myeongnyang, brilliantly blending epic naval warfare with deep character development. Despite heavy odds and political intrigue, director Kim Han-min captures Admiral Yi Sun-shin's tactical genius and indomitable spirit, making it a must-watch for historical action drama fans.
Video: 77
"The Admiral: Roaring Currents" delivers an exceptional visual experience, thanks to its 1080p transfer sourced from a 5K digital intermediate. Shot on RED cameras, the film exhibits outstanding clarity and fine detail, from every splinter of the warships to the intricate design of the Japanese armor. This Blu-ray presents colors vibrantly, particularly the primaries, which pop alongside the gorgeous replica armor. Flesh tones are depicted authentically, with battle-worn faces accurately reflecting the harsh conditions faced by the characters.
The video compression is skillfully handled, maintaining an average bitrate of 23.94 Mbps. This allocation ensures the action-heavy latter half of the film receives the necessary bandwidth for smooth presentation. Blacks and shadow details are flawlessly rendered, enhancing night vigils and firelit scenes without any noticeable crush. While there are minor instances of banding and video noise during transitions, these imperfections are negligible and do not detract from the overall image quality.
The Blu-ray displays superb contrast and sharpness levels, providing a reference-quality visual experience. The ocean scenes, although digitally enhanced, appear convincingly real, adding depth to the imagery. Practical effects like cannons and period costumes retain impressive fine detail, contributing to a visually immersive historical drama. Despite minor flaws like light banding at scene transitions, "The Admiral: Roaring Currents" offers an astounding and clean visual presentation, making it a demo-worthy Blu-ray release.
Audio: 87
The audio presentation of the Blu-ray for "The Admiral: Roaring Currents" is a standout feature, providing both English and subtitled Korean soundtracks in lossless PCM 2.0 and DTS-HD MA 5.1 formats. The DTS-HD MA 5.1 track, in particular, showcases a meticulously crafted sound mix that excels in creating an immersive experience. Especially distinguished in the second half of the film during the naval battle, the soundtrack envelops the viewer with a symphony of surging oceans, creaking and breaking hulls, cannon and gunfire, clashing swords, and flying arrows. This comprehensive arrangement plunges the audience into the historical setting with striking realism. The bass extension reaches impressive low-frequency registers, enhancing the tension and intensity of the battle scenes while Kim Tae-seong’s musical score, rich with resonant drumbeats, provides a powerful auditory backdrop.
Switching to the Korean 5.1 track is highly recommended for an authentic experience. This track distinguishes itself through its sheer dynamic range and power, with superb bass impact that makes it feel like the subwoofer could almost take flight, contributing to an adrenaline-pumping viewing experience. During quieter moments, the audio levels remain stable and consistent without any unwarranted fluctuations. The sound mixing is balanced to maintain clarity and prevent distortion, allowing for a captivating auditory experience without necessitating constant adjustments to the volume controls. Imaging is precise and deftly handled, giving ample space for dialogue, sound effects, and Tae-seong Kim's evocative score to harmonize splendidly. This exceptional auditory composition significantly enhances the film’s impact, transforming "The Admiral: Roaring Currents" into an enthralling sensory experience.
Extras: 30
The Blu-ray disc of "The Admiral: Roaring Currents" offers a solid range of extras that complement the main feature effectively. The "Making Of" featurette provides insightful, though brief, behind-the-scenes glimpses into the film’s production, including the use of green screens and elaborate machinery. The "Highlights" compilation is an odd addition, primarily consisting of key scenes assembled without new context. Trailers for both "The Admiral" and other films give an engaging preview. These features are all presented in high quality with English subtitles, ensuring accessibility. While the content is varied, it would have benefitted from more depth and duration.
Extras included in this disc:
- Making Of: Brief insights into production challenges and techniques.
- Highlights: Key scene selections from the movie.
- The Admiral (Teaser): Quick and loud preview.
- The Admiral (Trailer): Better paced, cleaner depiction of the movie.
- Trailers: Additional film trailers with English subtitles.
Movie: 83
"The Admiral: Roaring Currents" is a remarkable feat of historical drama, deftly capturing the grit and grandeur of the Battle of Myeongnyang. Directed by Kim Han-min, the film portrays the near-miraculous victory of Admiral Yi Sun-Shin (played by Choi Min-sik) in 1597, where a tiny fleet of 12 Korean ships vanquished a formidable Japanese armada of 330 vessels. Despite the dense historical context that may initially challenge Western viewers, the film excels in establishing the dire stakes and complex motivations on both sides, making the eventual confrontation all the more gripping.
The film is segmented into two distinct halves: the buildup and the battle. The first half invests heavily in character development and setting up the tactical landscape. The screenplay by Kim Han-min and Jeon Cheol-hong introduces us to Admiral Yi's complex state of mind and the political maneuvering on both Korean and Japanese fronts. This narrative richness is supported by meticulous production design, featuring historically accurate models of the ships and authentic period costumes. The filmmakers utilize CGI judiciously to enhance rather than overwhelm the visual authenticity, creating a visceral viewing experience.
When the action erupts in the second half, it's both intense and masterfully orchestrated. Naval warfare scenes are captured with stunning realism—cannon fire, flaming arrows, and brutal hand-to-hand combat unfold in a meticulously choreographed symphony of chaos. Kim's direction ensures each moment is both grand in scale and intimately emotional, making Admiral Yi’s strategic genius and indomitable spirit palpable. The cast delivers uniformly strong performances, especially Choi Min-sik, whose portrayal of Yi embodies stoic resilience. Ultimately, "The Admiral: Roaring Currents" goes beyond mere spectacle to deliver a compelling study of leadership and courage under insurmountable odds.
Total: 72
"The Admiral: Roaring Currents" delivers an enthralling cinematic experience that combines historical drama with intense action, portraying one of Korea's most celebrated military victories. The film, led by Choi Min-sik's compelling performance as Admiral Yi, effectively captures the transformation of Korean forces under his tenacious leadership. Early scenes depict the initial fears and hesitation of the troops, underscoring the extraordinary nature of their eventual bravery— a crucial element that endears the narrative to viewers. The Blu-ray edition amplifies this story with exceptional audio and picture quality, creating an immersive experience that enhances every meticulously crafted scene.
Production values are high throughout, with remarkable attention to detail in costume and visual effects design. Despite a somewhat slow first hour of intricate plotting, the film rewards patience with a spectacular visual feast. Each battle sequence is rendered with impressive clarity, showcasing both strategic brilliance and raw emotion, truly bringing history to life. The Blu-ray’s thin extras might leave some yearning for more behind-the-scenes content, but they do not detract from the overall high-quality presentation of the core film.
In conclusion, "The Admiral: Roaring Currents" stands as a superb representation of historical courage and leadership, honored through powerful performances and stunning visuals. While its patriotic fervor may seem heightened to some, it serves to underscore the significance of the depicted victory. This Blu-ray edition comes highly recommended, promising an engaging journey into a pivotal moment in Korean history that will appeal to both casual viewers and discerning cinephiles alike.
Blu-ray.com review by Michael ReubenRead review here
Video: 90
Contemporary audiences are too sophisticated to be completely fooled by computer-generated shots of giant fleets of antique ships, but that's no fault of the Blu-ray image, which is clean, sharp, detailed,...
Audio: 100
With an almost constant assault of surging ocean, creaking (and breaking) hulls, cannon and gunfire, clashing swords, exploding shells, bullets hitting hulls, arrows flying through the air, men barking...
Extras: 30
Highlights (480i; 2.40:1; 30:09): As the title suggests, this is nothing more than a selection of clips from The Admiral (windowboxed in standard definition)....
Movie: 80
Consistent with the historical accounts, Admiral Yi takes his flagship out ahead to face Kurushima's massive fleet alone, so that he can lure the over-confident Pirate King into the whirlpool of currents...
Total: 80
It's hard to envision such a victory without imagining that every single person who contributed to it found hidden reserves of courage in him- or herself, which is precisely what Admiral Yi (in Choi Min-sik's...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Primaries get plenty of pop to them and the Japanese commanders' replica armor is simply gorgeous....
Audio: 100
It feels so hollow and lifeless most of the time so I strongly encourage you to visit the settings menu and switch things over to the Korean 5.1 track....
Extras: 40
This tragically brief making of is fascinating and leaves you wanting much more as tehy detail the making of the armor and the ships....
Movie: 100
Prior to this review I hadn't ever heard of Korean Admiral YI Sun-shin or his numerous naval victories against a massive Japanese in the late 1590s so going into 'The Admiral: Roaring Currents I didn't...
Total: 80
Being someone who doesn't discriminate in their viewing allowed me the opportunity to watch this movie - one that I probably would have never seen otherwise....
Why So Blu? review by Gerard IribeRead review here
Video: 100
This is a native 5k-film shoot – I did not detect any instances of noise, artifacts, noise, etc....
Audio: 100
Extras: 30
The short featurette on the making of the film is very cool in that it goes into some depth on what went into the making of the film....
Movie: 80
Admiral Yi has to spend the first hour of the film holding his ground against those from within his ranks that want him out, to the Japanese forces out there in the ocean that want to blow him out of the...
Total: 80
If you can make it past the first hour of plotting then you will be in for a visual feast that will blow you away....
Director: Han-min Kim
Actors: Choi Min-sik, Ryu Seung-ryong, Cho Jin-woong
PlotIn the late 16th century, Admiral Yi Sun-sin of the Joseon Dynasty faces overwhelming odds as he prepares to defend his nation against a massive invading Japanese fleet. Recently stripped of his rank and reinstated only out of desperation, Yi must contend with a demoralized and vastly outnumbered force of just thirteen ships. With unyielding determination, he leverages his expert knowledge of the local waters, particularly the perilous currents of the Myeongnyang Strait, to level the playing field against the invasion force.
Through masterful strategic planning and inspiring leadership, Yi Sun-sin and his crew face formidable challenges and internal strife. The odds favor the enemy whose superior numbers seem insurmountable. Yet, with unwavering resolve, ingenious tactics, and an unbreakable spirit, Yi seeks to turn the tide of war and protect his homeland from conquest. The narrative showcases his tactical brilliance and the intense naval battles that test the limits of human endurance and courage.
Writers: Cheol-Hong Jeon, Han-min Kim
Release Date: 30 Jul 2014
Runtime: 128 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: South Korea
Language: Korean, Japanese