Marnie 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 63
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Marnie's 4K overhaul shines, outclassing its Blu-ray with superior visuals and making it a recommended, intriguing Hitchcock piece.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
DTS-HD MA
Video: 73
Universal's UHD upgrades of 'Marnie' & 'Trauma' enhance clarity, color, & texture, offering a cinematic experience superior to Blu-ray, with refined grain, deeper hues, & striking contrast.
Audio: 58
Universal preserves the original charm with unchanged DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0, delivering clear dialogue and solid music, while maintaining accurate low-end and broad imaging, despite minor effects limitations.
Extra: 51
This UHD release, carrying over legacy extras without new supplements, includes a Blu-ray, digital copy, and embossed slipcover. It features The Trouble with Marnie, The Marnie Archives, and Trailer, matching its Blu-ray predecessor's content.
Movie: 66
Universal releases Hitchcock's 'Marnie' in 4K UHD, tackling complex themes with masterful storytelling, available both individually and in a Hitchcock set.
Video: 73
Universal's release of "Marnie" on 4K UHD Blu-ray marks a significant leap in visual fidelity over its previous Blu-ray incarnation, presenting a new 2160p/HDR transfer that is sure to captivate with its considerable enhancements. The upgrade is immediately noticeable in the more naturally managed grain structure, offering a textural finesse that translates into a visually splendid experience. This isn't simply about hitting new peaks in clarity for the format, but about showcasing a dramatic improvement in detail and texture discernment, moving from the Blu-ray's comparatively lackluster presentation to a more stable, sharply defined, and organically cinematic one. The HDR color grading intensifies this improvement, transforming the visual experience not by altering the original color scheme but by refining and deepening it. With this upgrade, colors appear more vibrant and true-to-life, bolstered by strong contrast, authentic temperature settings, and impeccable black levels that together create a visually rich and engaging picture.
Further elevating the presentation, the HDR10 encode reveals finer details and textures across the board - from hair and clothing to furniture - with only minor softness attributable to the original production's rear-projection effects. The balance of contrast and brightness enhances visibility across all planes, especially within darker scenes where shadow detail is markedly improved. The inky black levels contribute significantly to the image's depth, imparting a genuine cinematic quality, while specular highlights add realism to metallic surfaces and create dimension around light sources. The vibrant HDR palette showcases deeply saturated primaries and lively secondary hues, presenting a more dynamic and engaging visual experience. Together with a consistently refined grain structure, these improvements afford "Marnie" a film-like quality on 4K UHD that admirers of Hitchcock and cinephiles will undoubtedly appreciate, marking it as a vital upgrade from its HD SDR predecessor and a notable entry in the second wave of Hitchcock titles on UHD.
Audio: 58
Universal's approach to the audio presentation of "Marnie" in its 4K UHD Blu-ray release showcases a respect for the film's original audio elements by retaining the DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 lossless soundtrack. This decision avoids unnecessary embellishment through a possible remix into Atmos or DTS:X, preserving the film's authentic sound design. The soundtrack is characterized by clear, well-balanced dialogue, which maintains center stage throughout the film. Musical scores are presented with a commendable front-side spread and detail, ensuring that Bernard Hermann's composition is delivered with appreciable clarity and acoustical detailing. The soundtrack supports an immersive experience without distracting from the narrative with over-engineered effects.
The audio mix excels in aligning dialogue neatly above other aspects of the sound design, an improvement noted over past releases. This enhancement ensures that conversations are easily discernible and prioritized, contributing significantly to the overall viewing experience. The low-end frequencies are accurately represented, providing a solid foundation without overpowering the mix. Imaging is described as broad and engaging, a testament to the effort spent in preserving the sonic integrity of this cinematic classic.
However, it's important to mention that not all elements are flawless. The upper ranges, particularly during instances such as the rumble of thunder, lack a bit of distinctness and come across as somewhat uniform. Though this doesn't lead to distortion, it represents a minor deviation from what could be considered an ideal audio experience. Despite this, the effects maintain accuracy and fail to detract noticeably from what is, on the whole, an excellent lossless mix. This careful balance of maintaining fidelity to the original while ensuring a clean, detailed audio presentation underscores Universal's commendable treatment of "Marnie" in its transition to 4K UHD.
Extras: 51
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Marnie" maintains the tradition of Hitchcock classics by porting over its legacy supplements from the Blu-ray predecessor, without adding any new supplements. The package includes the legacy extras on the UHD disc and comes with a legacy Blu-ray disc and a Movies Anywhere digital copy code. Highlighting the package is an embossed slipcover that adds a touch of elegance to the presentation. Essential for collectors, these extras delve into the depths of "Marnie" through detailed documentaries and archival material, albeit presented in their original resolutions and formats, reflecting the preservation of their historical authenticity.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Trouble with Marnie: An in-depth exploration of the film's production, challenges, and legacy.
- The Marnie Archives: A compilation of rare photographs, production notes, and other archival material related to the film.
- Theatrical Trailer: The original promotional trailer for the film.
Movie: 66
Universal Studios Home Entertainment has recently released Alfred Hitchcock's 1964 psychological thriller, "Marnie," on 4K Ultra HD. This release is either an individual purchase or part of The Alfred Hitchcock Classics Collection Vol. 2, which also includes other notable films like "Shadow of a Doubt" and "Family Plot." The movie itself has been upgraded to 2160p/HDR video quality, enhancing the visual experience without altering the original audio track or adding new extras. However, it maintains all legacy supplements. The packaging provides a two-disc combo pack, accommodating a Region Free UHD66 and a BD50 disc, along with a digital copy code for accessing the HDR10 version with Dolby Digital Plus 5.1 audio.
"Marnie" stands as a testament to the late career of Alfred Hitchcock, encapsulating his masterful grasp on suspense and psychological depth. The film explores the complicated narrative of Marnie Edgar (Tippi Hedren), a pathological thief and liar, who is blackmailed into marriage by one of her victims, Mark Rutland (Sean Connery). What unfolds is an intricate story of trauma, identity, and the possibility of redemption, couched within Hitchcock's characteristic blend of mystery and drama. Although initially received with mixed reviews, "Marnie" has come to be appreciated for its forward-thinking approach to complex psychological themes and its critical place in Hitchcock's filmography, making it a classic worth revisiting, especially in its enhanced 4K presentation.
In this new format, "Marnie" dazzles with richer visuals that accentuate Hitchcock’s deliberate use of color and shadows to convey mood and character psychology. While no new content has been added to this release, the preservation of its original attributes—paired with the improvement in image quality—offers both longtime fans and newcomers an immersive viewing experience. The film’s intricate plot, combined with its revival in 4K, bolsters its position as a significant piece in the realm of cinematic history, encapsulating Hitchcock’s genius in storytelling and visual composition.
Total: 63
The 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of Alfred Hitchcock's "Marnie" marks a significant improvement over its Blu-ray predecessor, elevating the visual experience to new heights despite some lingering imperfections. This upgrade is not merely a superficial enhancement but a comprehensive overhaul that brings out the richness and depth of the film’s cinematography, making it a more stable and delightful viewing experience. While the audio and supplementary content have not received updates, remaining consistent with the original Blu-ray release, the enhanced visuals alone justify the purchase for fans and collectors alike. The film itself, although not considered among Hitchcock's finest works, presents a compelling psychological thriller that engrosses viewers with its mystery and exploration of trauma.
The 4K HDR10 presentation significantly outshines the HD SDR version, offering a testament to what the format can achieve when applied thoughtfully to classic cinema. This edition keeps the DTS-HD MA 2.0 mono soundtrack and a modest array of bonus materials, mirroring the original Blu-ray release. Yet, it's the visual fidelity where this release shines, providing a noteworthy upgrade that enriches the viewing experience. The effort invested in this release demonstrates a keen understanding of the film's value to both cinephiles and collectors, ensuring that "Marnie" is appreciated in the best possible light despite its varying reception among Hitchcock's oeuvre.
In conclusion, the 4K UHD Blu-ray of "Marnie" stands as a recommended investment for both longstanding Hitchcock fans and newcomers intrigued by the filmmaker's exploration of complex psychological themes. Although remaining imperfections and unchanged audio and supplements may deter purists seeking a complete revamp, the visual overhaul alone makes this version superior to its predecessors. This release underscores the importance of preserving cinematic legacies through technology that respects both artistic intent and modern viewing standards, making "Marnie" a worthy addition to any 4K collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
Gone is the uneven grain and less than flattering details, replaced with a sure, confident presentation that boasts a far more naturally inclined grain structure which is properly managed here and very...
Audio: 50
A remix to Atmos or DTS:X would have simply robbed the original elements of their simple graces and diverted attention to where it is not needed....
Extras: 80
While no new supplements have been added for this release, the UHD disc itself does carry over the legacy extras, which are outlined below (please click here for full review coverage)....
Movie: 70
The disc is currently available individually (this release) and as part of a larger five-film UHD boxed set along with Shadow of a Doubt, Saboteur, The Trouble with Harry, and Family Plot....
Total: 40
While still imperfect here and there the picture is vastly superior to the uneven and disappointing Blu-ray, offering here a more stable, delightful picture that accentuates the best qualities of the film...
High-Def Digest review by M. Enois DuarteRead review here
Video: 80
The HDR10 presentation also comes with a more dynamic color palette overall than its HD SDR counterpart, boasting richly saturated primaries, particularly the reds, and spirited, vibrant secondary hues,...
Audio: 80
However, dialogue reproduction appears to be better balanced and prioritized above the rest of the sound design, which was an issue mentioned in our previous review....
Extras: 30
The Trouble with Marnie (1080i/60, 58 min) The Marnie Archives (1080i/60, 9 min) Trailer (HD)...
Movie: 70
But much of that, as always, is really to the genius of Hitchcock's masterful camerawork and skilled storytelling, knowing precisely how to leave little breadcrumbs for further enticing his audience until...
Total: 80
Featuring the same DTS-HD MA 2.0 mono soundtrack and the same small assortment of bonuses as the Blu-ray, the overall UHD package still makes for a recommended addition to the 4K collection....
Director: Alfred Hitchcock
Actors: Tippi Hedren, Sean Connery, Martin Gabel
PlotA young woman named Marnie Edgar, who has a habitual pattern of embezzlement and theft, lands secretarial jobs under fake identities. She steals from her employers and then disappears, changing her appearance and identity to remain untraceable. Marnie's latest victim is Mark Rutland, a widower and wealthy owner of a publishing company. Mark becomes intrigued by Marnie's behavior, particularly her extreme reactions to the color red and thunderstorms, which suggest a deeper psychological trauma.
Mark confronts Marnie with evidence of her theft, but rather than turning her over to the police, he coerces her into marrying him. He is motivated both by his attraction to her and by a desire to understand her compulsions. The marriage, however, is fraught with tension and complexity, as Marnie remains cold and distant towards Mark. Despite her resistance, Mark works to uncover the mysteries of her past, believing that this will help her overcome her psychological issues and the events that trigger her criminal impulses.
Writers: Winston Graham, Jay Presson Allen
Release Date: 17 Jul 1964
Runtime: 130 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English