The Great Train Robbery Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "The Great Train Robbery" maintains its original aspect ratio of 1.85:1 and utilizes an MPEG-4 AVC encoded 1080p transfer. This release, provided by Kino Lorber, is sourced from the same master used for the 2014 edition, but introduces important technical refinements, notably in gamma level adjustments and a BD50 dual-layer disc format which, while offering a higher bit rate, does not result in major quality leaps. The visual rendition showcases pleasing organic traits, with color balance and depth that range from good to very good. Image stability is respectable, though the inherent flaws in the master, such as noisier grain when displayed on larger screens, remain evident.

The release displays enhanced clarity and detail fidelity from the 2014 version while still showcasing minor surface imperfections such as nicks and stains consistent with older film stock. Stylized segments, including sepia-tinted portions, reveal fluctuations but are part of the source material's inherent characteristics. Grain structure is generally maintained without problematic degraining adjustments. Proposed future restorations could significantly elevate color scheme richness and the overall dynamic range, potentially addressing the current limitations linked to contrast and primary color saturation. This iteration effectively advances over its predecessor's visual output yet indicates room for further restoration to achieve a closer alignment with contemporary 4K standards, promising superior color accuracy and textural intricacies.

The Blu-ray release of "The Great Train Robbery" offers two English audio tracks: DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 and DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1, as well as optional English SDH subtitles. Both tracks deliver strong clarity and sharpness in dialogue, sound effects, and Jerry Goldsmith’s dynamic score. The 2.0 track, while clear, presents occasional abrupt dynamic spikes, especially during musical passages, suggesting potential room for future remastering improvements. However, no transfer-specific anomalies were noted.

The 5.1 track elevates the auditory experience by offering a broader soundstage that encapsulates the viewer more profoundly, suitable for scenes requiring immersive audio depth. The inclusion of both tracks reflects commendable consistency with previous releases, maintaining high-quality audio fidelity. Issues like crackling, popping, hissing, and distortion are minimal and do not detract significantly from the overall sonic experience. Consequently, this re-release stands as an impressive audio presentation that matches its predecessors while offering the potential for immersive engagement with the film's dynamic soundscapes.

The Blu-ray release of "The Great Train Robbery" offers an engaging array of extras that deliver both nostalgia and insightful commentary, ideal for fans of the classic heist film. A highlight is the archival commentary by writer/director Michael Crichton, which, despite some silent patches, provides fascinating insights into the film's production in England. Additionally, fans will appreciate the vintage trailer and TV spots that capture the promotional spirit of the era. The reversible cover art featuring vintage poster designs adds a collectibles appeal. These extras collectively enhance the viewing experience by offering a glimpse into the creative and historical background of this cinematic piece.

Extras included in this disc:

• Commentary: Archival audio by Michael Crichton with insights into the film's production.
• Trailer: Vintage theatrical trailer in English.
• TV Spots: A collection of vintage promotional spots in English.
• Cover: Reversible cover featuring vintage poster art.

Michael Crichton's "The Great Train Robbery" (1978) is a period caper film rich in Victorian visuals, based on the true events of the 1855 Great Gold Robbery. The storytelling opens with a meticulously narrated setup by Sean Connery, detailing the secure transport of gold from London to Folkestone. Connery's portrayal as Edward Pierce, a high society gentleman turned master thief, is complemented by his co-conspirators: Donald Sutherland as the skillful pickpocket John Agar and Lesley-Anne Down in a fictional role as Miriam. Despite some noted pacing issues, particularly the dialogue-heavy first half, the film capitalizes on vibrant action scenes and strategic heists to sustain engagement.

Crichton's direction brings an intoxicatingly fun approach to the crime caper genre, showcasing both historical fidelity and artistic license. Geoffrey Unsworth’s cinematography is lauded for its atmospheric rendition of Victorian London, shot in the Irish countryside, effectively transporting viewers to that era. While Crichton's screenplay at times falters with uneven rhythm and clumsy character development, Connery's enigmatic presence maintains audience interest. Unfortunately, humor mismanagement undermines the film’s potential charm, with few successful comedic instances outside of Connery's moments.

Despite its flaws, the film is recognized as one of Crichton's commendable directorial efforts. Connery delivers a memorable performance, channeling comedic elements reminiscent of his James Bond tenure into Pierce's character. Sutherland adds depth to his portfolio with his role as Agar. Although the film doesn’t fully capitalize on its promising premise, it achieves enough intrigue and character-driven caper elements to be regarded as an engaging piece of period filmmaking. Each element from cast performances to technical execution collectively constructs a visual and narrative tapestry that partially redeems the film’s structural defects.

The Blu-ray release of "The Great Train Robbery" presents the film with a competent HD transfer, carried over from the previous edition by MGM. This reissue is a commendable effort by Kino to keep the film accessible, enhancing it slightly while retaining the legacy special features of its predecessor. Additional television spots have been included in this edition, offering a deeper dive for enthusiasts of this heist caper. However, the improvements are marginal, and those who already own the prior release may find limited value in pursuing an upgrade.

Michael Crichton's direction underscores his versatility, transitioning from a successful novelist to a director who manages to weave an engaging narrative. Despite this, "The Great Train Robbery" might not be considered Crichton’s most dynamic work. The choice of Donald Sutherland for one of the lead roles has been met with mixed reactions, suggesting a potential miscast that some believe hindered the film's potential impact. Nonetheless, the film remains an enjoyable experience, capturing the 19th-century escapade with its charm intact.

In conclusion, "The Great Train Robbery" on Blu-ray can be described as average yet valuable to collectors and those experiencing it for the first time without the older edition. Its simple yet robust presentation makes it a good choice for those unfamiliar with the film or seeking to explore Crichton’s broader creative scope. If you already possess a previous edition, consider this purchase only if you are keen on the added content.