Fire at Sea Blu-ray Review
Fuocoammare
Score: 66
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Fire at Sea is a meticulously crafted, award-winning documentary that balances intimate, observational storytelling with a powerful exploration of migrant crises, featuring strong video and audio presentations.
Disc Release Date
Video: 73
The AVC encoded 1080p HD presentation in 1.85:1 aspect ratio delivers stunning detail and vibrant colors, from the greenery and blue skies to the textured close-ups. Black levels are deep, and skintones are natural, despite minor banding and pixelation.
Audio: 68
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA sound mix, though front-heavy and not fully immersive, excels in clarity and precision, effectively supporting dialogues, ambient island noises, and rescue operations with dynamic and compelling panning effects.
Extra: 46
The "Fire at Sea" Blu-ray extras are comprehensive, featuring in-depth interviews with director Gianfranco Rosi and Dr. Pietro Bartolo, a NYFF Q&A moderated by critic Dennis Lim, a detailed essay by Alberto Zambenedetti in a 10-page booklet, and a theatrical trailer, offering substantial insight into the film's creation and themes.
Movie: 71
'Fire at Sea' by Gianfranco Rosi presents an authentic yet harrowing documentary, contrasting the daily life on Lampedusa with the refugee crisis in the Mediterranean. The Blu-ray, from Kino Lorber, delivers exceptional procedural scenes and an emotional narrative, though without a tidy conclusion. Region A Locked, includes an essay booklet.
Video: 73
The AVC encoded image of "Fire at Sea," presented in an aspect ratio of 1.85:1, delivers a remarkably crisp and detailed HD-shot feature. This 1080p HD transfer accentuates both the vivid and sharp details throughout the film. Close-ups are rendered with exceptional clarity, allowing viewers to observe intricate details such as individual hairs and the distressing physical health conditions of the migrants. Emotional expressions and bodily textures are captured with precision, creating a deeply engaging visual experience.
The color reproduction is particularly noteworthy, with outdoor shots showcasing the natural greenery, blue skies, and island vegetation in vibrant hues. The colors are true to life and exhibit a striking vibrancy, albeit occasionally overlaid with a stylistic muted tone. Black levels are rendered deep and inky, ensuring excellent contrast, while skintones are consistently natural. Some technical imperfections are noted, including mild pixelation and occasional banding, but these do not significantly detract from the overall strong video quality. Delineation is precise, promoting clear differentiation between elements on screen.
Ultimately, "Fire at Sea" offers a visually compelling HD experience, with both its detailed and expressive presentation and its accurate color reproduction contributing significantly to the immersive quality of the film. While minor issues such as banding are present, they are minimal and do not undermine the overall impressive video clarity and depth.
Audio: 68
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA sound mix for "Fire at Sea" offers a robust audio experience, emphasizing clarity in human interaction and dialogue. Communication is consistently crisp and clean, adeptly handling various accents and languages with precision, ensuring ease of following along with English subtitles. The mix predominantly presents sound from the front channels, delivering a more frontal listening event, which is appropriate for the film's documentary nature. However, it also incorporates compelling panning effects and varied atmospheric elements that support the narrative effectively.
Despite its front-heavy disposition, the mix does demonstrate dynamism, particularly during critical moments such as rescue operations and the ambient noises of island life, accentuating the real-life environment depicted. Underwater sequences are particularly noteworthy, as they successfully convey a sensation of pressure, enhancing the viewer's immersion. The absence of any pops, cracks, hisses, or shrills in the dialogue further contributes to a seamless listening experience. While not fully immersive due to the front-centric sound design, this audio presentation excels in providing a high-fidelity soundtrack that complements the film's themes and scenes.
Extras: 46
The Blu Ray of "Fire at Sea" delivers an array of insightful extras that significantly deepen the viewer's understanding of the film and its context. Among the highlights is a rich booklet featuring an essay by Alberto Zambenedetti, which provides an erudite backdrop to the film. Interviews with director Gianfranco Rosi and Dr. Pietro Bartolo offer invaluable perspectives, especially concerning the humanitarian crisis depicted in the film. Additionally, the New York Film Festival Q&A moderated by Dennis Lim is an engaging discussion that sheds light on the filmmaking process. The included theatrical trailer offers a quick yet impactful encapsulation of the film's essence.
Extras included in this disc:
- Booklet: Essay by Alberto Zambenedetti.
- Interview: 2016 discussion with director Gianfranco Rosi.
- Interview: Conversation with Dr. Pietro Bartolo about migrant crises.
- NYFF Q&A: Insightful session moderated by Dennis Lim.
- Theatrical Trailer: Quick encapsulation of the film's essence.
Movie: 71
Gianfranco Rosi's "Fire at Sea" is an intricate and powerful exploration of the Mediterranean refugee crisis, set on the Italian island of Lampedusa. The documentary masterfully contrasts the daily lives of the locals with the harrowing experiences of African and Middle Eastern migrants. Through an almost docudramatic approach, Rosi captures the procedural rescue operations and the subsequent quarantines with unprecedented access, creating a deeply personal yet objective recounting. These sequences reveal the stark reality faced by the migrants, often filled with raw emotion as they undergo medical examinations and come to terms with their traumatic journeys.
Navigating both heart-wrenching and heartwarming elements, Rosi crafts a narrative that doesn't shy away from the unvarnished truth. While news outlets might briefly mention the crisis, "Fire at Sea" delves deeper, highlighting both the tragedies and rare moments of joy among the refugees. The film oscillates between intense rescue missions and domestic vignettes involving island inhabitants, such as a twelve-year-old boy from a fishing family and an empathetic doctor tending to the migrants. This juxtaposition enriches the storytelling by displaying both mundane and life-altering moments. Through subtle yet impactful direction, Rosi compels viewers to reflect profoundly on humanity's capacity for both kindness and cruelty, thus illuminating complex dimensions of this ongoing crisis.
Total: 66
Fire At Sea is both a poignant and observational documentary meticulously crafted by Gianfranco Rosi. With an expertly balanced narrative, the film delves deeply into the lives of migrants seeking solace on the Italian island of Lampedusa while simultaneously painting a vivid picture of the islanders' existence amidst the ongoing crisis. Rosi's use of long, meditative takes and careful composition allows viewers to absorb and reflect on the intimate spaces and intricate details of each moment. The juxtaposition of naturalistic and political elements enriches the storytelling, effectively immersing the audience in the palpable atmosphere.
The combined video and audio presentations are commendable, undoubtedly contributing to the immersive experience of Rosi's storytelling. The sound design supports the visual elegance, enhancing the emotional impact without overwhelming the core narrative. Supplementary materials, including extras that delve into the filmmaking process and provide additional context to the migrant crisis, are well-curated and insightful. These elements establish the film as not only an artistic achievement but also an educational resource.
In conclusion, Fire at Sea masterfully tackles complex themes related to migration and human perseverance, engaging viewers with both its aesthetic quality and profound subject matter. The careful composition and thoughtful approach ensure that it resonates deeply, making it deserving of its accolades. Engaging and enlightening, this Blu-Ray release is highly recommended for anyone seeking a deeper understanding of contemporary global issues through compelling cinema.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 90
Emphasis on detail is valuable, permitting viewers to examine locations and participants, and close-ups are extremely textured, capturing emotional ruin and bodily health....
Audio: 80
Panning effects are compelling, and underwater adventures deliver the sensation of pressure....
Extras: 60
NYFF Q&A (23:42, HD) offers additional insight by Rosi, moderated by film critic Dennis Lim....
Movie: 70
It's the latest work from director Gianfranco Rosi and an often powerful presentation of extremes, contrasting the daily activities of locals and the waking nightmare occurring out on the waters, where...
Total: 80
It's political but also naturalistic, with Rosi walking softly enough to create the largest impact he can muster, trying to lure viewers in with atmosphere before highlighting an aching and confusing reality....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
There was some mild banding here and there, but nothing to write home about, leaving this video presentation with solid marks....
Audio: 80
This release comes with a lossless DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix in Italian and sounds great with the English subtitles, however, it's not a fully immersive experience....
Extras: 40
Booklet - A 10 page booklet with an essay by the assistant professor of Italian and Cinema Studies at the University of Toronto - Alberto Zambenedetti....
Movie: 80
The newspapers and news reporters might devote a minute or two to this crisis, but Gianfranco Rosi goes several extra steps further in giving us a spotlight view of the horrors and sometimes endearing...
Total: 60
Rosi's camera gives you an inside look at what life is like for the migrants who are looking for a new and better life, while also giving a glimpse at the islander's life during this crisis....
Director: Gianfranco Rosi
Actors: Samuele Pucillo, Mattias Cucina, Samuele Caruana
PlotOn the Italian island of Lampedusa, young Samuele navigates his daily life with curiosity and simplicity. The boy explores the rugged landscapes, attends school, and undergoes a routine eye examination, all while practicing his slingshot skills and coping with mild health issues. His days consist of interactions with family and friends, capturing the essence of a quiet yet vibrant existence in a historically rich and traditionally rooted community.
Meanwhile, Lampedusa serves as a focal point in the European migrant crisis, witnessing a constant influx of refugees arriving by boat from Africa and the Middle East. The contrast between Samuele’s childhood innocence and the harsh realities faced by the migrants is starkly portrayed. The islanders, including medical personnel like Doctor Bartolo, deal with both routine local ailments and the critical emergencies presented by newly arrived refugees. The film intertwines these two worlds, showcasing the divergence between tranquil island life and the dire circumstances surrounding the migrant crisis, as Lampedusa becomes a microcosm of broader humanitarian and social issues.
Writers: Gianfranco Rosi, Carla Cattani
Release Date: 18 Feb 2016
Runtime: 114 min
Rating: N/A
Country: Italy, France
Language: Italian, English