Project X Blu-ray Review
#XtendedCut
Score: 52
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Faithful AV presentation but marred by a formulaic plot and debased teenage behavior; Blu-ray offers good picture quality, near-reference audio, and minimal supplements.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 58
The Blu-ray presentation of 'Project X' showcases a diverse range of video sources, from handheld iPhones to Sony Digital-HD cameras, resulting in an intentionally stylized found-footage look. While black levels are deep and colors lifelike, the 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer includes compression artifacts and noise, reflecting source limitations but remaining true to the filmmakers' vision.
Audio: 65
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track on 'Project X' is an intense, bass-heavy experience with thumping techno rhythms, robust low-frequency extension, and an enveloping soundfield. While it may lack nuance, it effectively captures the chaotic party atmosphere with powerful LFE and clear dialogue amidst the noise.
Extra: 36
With only three brief featurettes totaling fourteen minutes in HD—covering casting, damage overview, and behind-the-scenes footage—the Blu-ray extras for 'Project X' are minimal but complemented by an extended cut and UltraViolet Digital Copy.
Movie: 20
Project X delivers a morally vacuous, hyper-staged spectacle of teenage anarchy, devoid of likable characters or redeeming value, culminating in formulaic plot devices and excessive debauchery. The Blu-ray release includes an extended cut with additional scenes of indulgent recklessness, catering to those seeking unrelenting chaos.
Video: 58
The video presentation of "Project X" on Blu-ray is characterized by its deliberate stylistic choices, designed to emulate the found footage genre. The film employs an array of video sources, including handheld iPhones and Sony Digital-HD F23 cameras, contributing to an intentionally varied visual texture. Warner's 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer copes admirably with this eclectic mix, effectively managing periods of shaky camera work, vibrant strobe lights, and sections of ADD-like darkness. Blacks are robust with excellent detailing in shadowy areas, although noise spikes can sometimes detract from this. The resolution maintains a good overall standard despite variation in sharpness and fine detail perception, which is inherent to the photography style.
The video quality of "Project X" demonstrates a well-balanced contrast, with credible visibility of finer background details. However, whites occasionally exhibit posterization and blooming, which may obscure subtler nuances. Colors are lifelike yet restrained by the natural lighting employed by cinematographer Ken Seng, with primary hues faring better than secondary ones. Unfortunately, some scenes exhibit a digitized appearance due to mosquito noise, especially segments captured on phones. Despite these occasional dips in quality, the transfer remains faithful to the filmmakers' vision, presenting a solid representation even if it does not rival top-tier high-definition releases.
In conclusion, while "Project X" on Blu-ray might not deliver awe-inspiring visuals, it remains true to its stylistic and technical intentions. The use of diverse video sources results in a presentation that's intermittently brilliant and inconsistent. The Blu-ray transfer excels in handling dynamic contrasts and depth in darker scenes but suffers from intermittent compression issues and noise. Those compromises aside, the overall video quality offers a reasonably faithful adaptation of the film’s intended aesthetic.
Audio: 65
The audio presentation of "Project X" Blu-ray is a robust experience, delivering an immersive and dynamic soundscape that vibrantly captures the chaotic essence of the film. Utilizing a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track, it boasts clear dialogue with a discerning front channel presence. The surrounds, although not always active, extend the film's atmospheric elements, particularly during extended party sequences where thumping techno rhythms drive the soundscape. These party scenes allow the bass to extend deeply into low-frequency ranges, creating an intense and enveloping auditory experience that mirrors the chaos portrayed on-screen.
Warner’s DTS-HD Master Audio mix doesn’t emphasize subtlety but rather overwhelms with its loud and brash execution. This track captures the chaotic party sounds authentically, from the shouts of partygoers to pounding music and crowd surges, ensuring an all-encompassing soundfield. The directional effects are not easily tracked amid the cacophony, yet the overall envelope created by the audio is fittingly aggressive. The low-frequency effects are powerful and relentless, providing potent bass extension that contributes to a visceral experience, occasionally dipping into ultra-low frequencies with impressive authority and persistence.
Remarkably, while the film features several dialogue-heavy segments, the track maintains intelligibility and clarity excellently. Channel separation is another highlight, with fluid movement and consistent activity across the soundstage. When rear speakers are engaged, they convincingly expand the listening area, immersing viewers fully in the film’s raucous and tumultuous environment. Despite the movie’s simplicity, this lossless soundtrack breathes life into the party atmosphere, making listeners feel as if they are truly part of the pandemonium. The audio mix’s dynamic range and responsiveness ensure that every auditory element is delivered with impactful precision.
Extras: 36
The Blu-ray of "Project X" comes with a concise but engaging suite of extras that complement the high-energy film effectively. The extras comprise three featurettes, each offering insight into different aspects of the movie. "Pasadena Three" delves into the casting process and the chemistry among the lead actors, enhancing the viewer's appreciation of their onscreen camaraderie. "Declassified" provides a behind-the-scenes look at the making of the film, offering valuable context and fun tidbits for fans. "Xpensive: Tallying Up the Damage" humorously catalogs the extent of the destruction featured in the movie, appealing to those curious about the film's production design. Additionally, an extended cut is available that doesn't significantly differ from the theatrical version. The inclusion of a Bonus DVD and UltraViolet Digital Copy ensures multiple viewing options for different preferences.
Extras included in this disc:
- Project X: Declassified: Behind-the-scenes featurette.
- Project X: Pasadena Three: Discussion on the casting of main characters.
- Project Xpensive: Tallying Up the Damage: Overview of the party's damage.
Movie: 20
"Project X" navigates the turbulent waters of teenage parties, reaching depths of debauchery rarely seen on screen. Directed by Nima Nourizadeh and produced by Todd Phillips, the film follows three high school seniors as they attempt to throw an unforgettable party, only to see their harmless intentions spiral into chaos. The plot is straightforward: Thomas (Thomas Mann) uses his birthday as a pretext for an epic bash, egged on by friends Costa (Oliver Cooper) and J.B. (Jonathan Daniel Brown). The ensuing mayhem features everything from rampant underage drinking to police intervention and even a flame thrower—a spectacle of unrestrained teenage excess.
Despite moments of dark humor, "Project X" lacks depth, relying heavily on shock value and moral vacuity. Critics have widely panned the movie for its portrayal of high school anarchy, highlighting the dearth of likable, relatable characters. The teens are depicted as self-destructive and devoid of any redeeming qualities, making it difficult for viewers to engage or empathize with them. What stands out most is not the unruly behavior itself but the glorification and lack of consequence attached to it. Ultimately, Thomas is bizarrely praised by his father and gains social standing, sending a dubious message about accountability and rewards.
While some find entertainment in the reckless abandon showcased, the film's overt misogyny and crude portrayal of women are troubling. "Project X" remains essentially a 90-minute music video celebrating Bacchanalian revelry, shamelessly indulging in worn-out tropes of teenage debauchery. Though it aims to capture the essence of teen comedies like "Animal House" or "Superbad," it fails to offer any meaningful commentary or character development. Instead, it serves up a hyper-staged narrative that appeals to basest instincts without a modicum of originality or substance.
Total: 52
"Project X" is a divisive teen comedy from first-time director Nima Nourizadeh, chronicling the chaos that ensues when three high schoolers throw a house party that spirals out of control. Despite leaning heavily on debauchery and shock value, the film struggles to maintain a compelling plot. While it fails to capture the charm of classic teen-sex comedies, some viewers may find humor in its unrestrained antics.
The Blu-ray release offers a commendable audiovisual presentation. The picture quality is solid, particularly given the film’s stylistic use of handheld camera footage. However, it’s the audio quality that truly stands out, delivering an immersive and near-reference experience. The high-definition format benefits the extended cut, which is exclusive to the Blu-ray and will likely be a draw for fans. Unfortunately, the supplementary materials are sparse and unremarkable, consisting of only three brief featurettes that add little value.
In conclusion, while "Project X" might not appeal to everyone, especially those seeking depth or a well-constructed narrative, its Blu-ray edition provides a reliable AV experience. The content remains polarizing, but for enthusiasts of no-holds-barred comedies, this release might be worth considering. The extended cut and superior audio make it a modest recommendation for genre fans.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 80
Some shots excel, others wallow in excess with Costa and J.B. Crush and poor delineation are an issue as well but, once again, a source-based issue that shouldn't be held against the encode itself....
Audio: 80
The shouts of partygoers, the surge of the crowd, the chaos of drunken debauchery, the noise bleeding through the walls, and the thumping, at-times unintelligible party music make for an overwhelming soundscape...
Extras: 30
Only three brief featurettes are included -- "Pasadena Three," a character overview; "Declassified," a behind-the-scenes rundown; and "Xpensive: Tallying Up the Damages," an overview of the damage left...
Movie: 20
I'm tempted to go as far as to call producer Todd Phillips and director Nima Nourizadeh's Project X a wasteland; an ugly, empty, barren desert prowled by vicious, self-destructive teenagers consuming anything...
Total: 50
Obviously, I had a strong reaction to Phillips and Nourizadeh's no-holds-barred teen comedy, and that's really the best thing I can say about it....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Contrast is well-balanced for the most part with great visibility of background information in the distance, but whites tend to run very hot with some posterization and blooming, which ruins the finer...
Audio: 80
Although several segments are dialogue-heavy, which sound great and intelligible throughout, the front soundstage is quite wide and engaging for much of the movie's runtime....
Extras: 0
Project X: Pasadena Three (HD, 6 min) — A quick but fairly detailed discussion on the casting of three main characters and how their camaraderie relates to the story's effectiveness....
Movie: 20
His so-called best friend, Costa (Oliver Cooper), wants to change that, but the kid is one of the most annoying and grading things about the entire movie, like the nickel's worth version of Jonah Hill...
Total: 40
With no redeeming value whatsoever but an endless barrage of debased teenage behavior, it tries to recapture the teen-sex comedies of the past but fails miserably due to a terribly dull formulaic plot...
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 82
Resolution is good overall however due to the nature of the photography definitive sharpness and fine detail perception ebbs and flows....
Audio: 84
Extras: 50
Theatrical & Extended Cut of Project X (HD) Project X: Declassified – 5 minute featurette (HD) Project X: Pasadena three – 5 minute featurette (HD) Project Xpensive:...
Movie: 30
“Project X” follows three seemingly anonymous high school seniors as they attempt to finally make a name for themselves....
Total: 62
Screen Onkyo PR-SC5508 THX Ultra 2 Audio/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-93 Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: Nima Nourizadeh
Actors: Thomas Mann, Oliver Cooper, Jonathan Daniel Brown
PlotThomas Kub, Costa, and JB are three high school boys who feel unnoticed and unpopular. As Thomas's parents leave town for his birthday weekend, his best friend Costa seizes the opportunity to host a massive house party to elevate their social status. Despite their initial reservations, the boys distribute flyers and utilize social media to extend invites, hoping to make a memorable impression. As night falls, guests begin to arrive in droves, and the event quickly spirals into an uncontrollable rager that far exceeds their expectations.
The scene at the party becomes increasingly chaotic, with neighbors growing agitated and property damage escalating. The boys' ambitious venture into popularity begins attracting unwanted attention, triggering unforeseen consequences. As the chaos intensifies, so do the stakes, pulling Thomas, Costa, and JB into an escalating series of events that will test their friendships and decision-making skills in surprising ways. The explosive party eventually attracts authorities and creates complications that far outreach their initial intentions.
Writers: Matt Drake, Michael Bacall
Release Date: 02 Mar 2012
Runtime: 88 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English