War Blu-ray Review
Rogue Assassin
Score: 62
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
War: a mediocre action flick elevated by its twist and stellar audio, but marred by technical issues.
Disc Release Date
Video: 53
Blu-ray offers mixed picture quality; struggles with black crush and inconsistency, yet shines in color and detail. Hollywood tint and minimal grain present.
Audio: 76
Lionsgate's PCM 7.1 audio track excels, offering an immersive, high-definition audio experience with perfect steering, powerful LFE, and crystal-clear dialogue, making it near-perfect and demo-quality.
Extra: 53
The 'War' Blu-ray features a mix of engaging and mediocre extras, with highlights like The War Chest offering insight, while other elements like monotonous commentary tracks and lackluster games disappoint.
Movie: 60
'War' is a mediocre action movie with nice choreography and a surprising twist, yet plagued by cliches and forgettable despite strong leads.
Video: 53
The 2.40:1, 1080p high-definition presentation of "War" on Blu-ray showcases an ambitious effort from Lionsgate, albeit with mixed results that oscillate between excellence and mediocrity. The AVC MPEG-4 encoding on a BD-50 disc demonstrates a commendable attempt at delivering crisp visuals, evidenced by sharpness, solid color reproduction, and particularly vibrant fire effects that lend depth to the imagery. The cinematic experience is elevated by excellent black levels and shadow detail, offering a mostly three-dimensional image that rivals the studio's top releases. Despite these highs, the transfer is not without its flaws; black crush and blooming occasionally mar the picture, hinting at intentional post-processing choices that might not appeal to all viewers.
Technical inconsistencies further detract from an otherwise robust visual presentation. Scenes vary dramatically in quality, with some suffering from artificial sharpness and others appearing unusually soft, undermining the overall depth and detail expected from high-definition content. Such disparities are particularly noticeable in the transition between foreground and background elements, which can disrupt the visual continuity. Moreover, a slight but discernible presence of compression artifacts alongside occasional blockiness suggests a compromise on encoding efficiency. The decision to minimize grain and eschew edge enhancement, while generally positive for maintaining a filmic texture, does not fully compensate for these variable outcomes.
In summary, the Blu-ray video quality of "War" delivers strong points such as impressive color fidelity, notable fire effect depiction, and commendable black levels, marred by a host of inconsistencies that hinder its potential for visual excellence. While the outdoor scenes and skin tones sometimes exhibit an unnatural yellow tint — a deliberate stylistic choice rather than a transfer fault — and despite clear efforts to present a pristine print free from physical blemishes, the fluctuating sharpness, detail, and depth across scenes somewhat dampen the overall viewing experience.
Audio: 76
The audio presentation of "War" on Blu-ray, featuring an uncompressed PCM 7.1 audio track, is a quintessential example of auditory excellence. Delivered by Lionsgate, it pushes the boundaries of the high-definition audio experience, ensuring that enthusiasts with a properly equipped home theater setup are in for a treat. Through an Onkyo 875 amplifier, connected via HDMI, the precision of the sound design is immediately apparent. The use of the two additional surround back channels enriches the action sequences with pinpoint accuracy, where gunshots and environmental sounds convincingly ping from behind, immersing the viewer directly into the chaos. The low-frequency effects (LFE) channel meticulously underscores fight scenes with pronounced kicks and punches, while dialogues remain crisp and centered, never bleeding into other channels. Furthermore, the score, especially rap songs integrated within the film, make full use of the LFE channel to enhance the on-screen energy, embodying a "rock da house" vibe.
While the uncompressed track is a marvel in its right, offering controlled low frequencies and superior steerage of sound across channels, it's worth noting that the disc also includes a 640kbps Dolby Digital Surround EX track. This alternative track manages to fill the room with a genuinely enveloping sound experience, despite not matching the uncompressed track's finesse by a narrow margin. However, for those without a 7.1 setup, this inclusion ensures no listener is left wanting. The fidelity and dynamism of the PCM track make it not only an auditory feast but a showcase piece for what home theater systems can achieve. It leverages powerful LFE pulses and a multidimensional soundfield to create an atmosphere where music, from deep nightclub bass to gunfire, resonates with palpable intensity. Despite minor dialogue clarity issues, which are infrequent and hardly detract from the overall experience, this audio track stands as reference quality material.
Notably, the immersive qualities of this PCM 7.1 surround track are exemplified through its seamless pans and ambient support, creating an invisible soundfield that engrosses the listener completely. Dynamics are in overdrive, with each scene transition and action set piece meticulously crafted to maintain high-end fidelity throughout. The level of auditory detail is so high that it occasionally tricks the listener into believing sounds are emanating from behind or around, beyond the specific speakers' locations. This level of immersion is rarely achieved and speaks volumes of Lionsgate's commitment to premium audio experiences for home theater fans. With its unparalleled clarity, depth, and surround capabilities, "War" exemplifies how a film's audio track can significantly elevate the viewing experience, making it a must-listen for audiophiles and movie buffs alike.
Extras: 53
The "War" Blu-ray extras present a mixed bag ranging from the engaging to the mundane. Highlighted by the "The War Chest" and "Scoring War" featurettes, which both offer a deep dive into the film’s production, these extras are complemented by a selection of HD exclusive content and standard offerings. While the audio commentaries tend to drag, with repetitive and sometimes tedious insights, they contrast sharply with the more dynamic visual commentary and making-of materials that showcase the film's action sequences and musical score. The trivia track and Blu-Line feature feel underdeveloped and gimmicky, respectively. However, the inclusion of deleted scenes, a gag reel, and trailers does add some value. Notably, technical enhancements like PiP (Picture-in-Picture) commentary demonstrate Lionsgate's attempt to leverage Blu-ray capabilities, though not all extras fully realize the potential of this format.
Extras included in this disc:
- The War Chest: A comprehensive behind-the-scenes look at nine key scenes.
- Audio Commentary: A commentary track with writers that offers limited insights.
- Scoring War: A featurette on the film’s music composition.
- Audio Trivia Track: An audio track featuring dull narrations of film facts and cast interviews.
- Deleted/Extended Scenes: A few short clips that contribute little to the overall package.
- Gag Reel: Light-hearted outtakes mainly featuring Jet Li.
- B Roll PiP: A short, but technically interesting look at special effects for a specific scene.
- Yakuza Fighter Game: An underwhelming interactive feature.
- Bookmark Feature: Allows viewers to mark and return to favorite scenes.
- Blu-line Feature: Offers fast navigation within the film but is rather redundant.
- Trailers: Previews for other Blu-ray releases.
Movie: 60
"War," at its core, is a game of cat-and-mouse between FBI agent John Crawford, played with fervor by Jason Statham, and the enigmatic assassin Rogue, brought to life by Jet Li's quiet intensity. Initially, "War" presents itself as a standard action film littered with the kind of high-octane sequences that fans of the genre have come to expect: gun battles, martial arts showdowns, and car chases that seemingly promise to keep one's adrenaline pumping. However, beneath this veneer of predictability lies a narrative that plods along, burdened by a script that struggles to break new ground and characters that often feel as dimensional as cardboard cutouts.
The film's redemption, however, arguably comes in the form of a twist that recalibrates one's understanding of the narrative, giving the interactions between Li and Statham a depth previously unappreciated. This surprise element forces a reevaluation of what might have been dismissed as just another entry in the action movie pantheon, suggesting a layer of complexity in its character development that was easy to oversee. Despite this narrative ambition, "War" is hampered by dialogue and supporting characters that veer into cliché, undermining its attempts at delivering a richer emotional payoff. The action sequences, while competently executed, occasionally fall victim to the film's overall disjointedness, failing to fully capitalize on the dynamic interplay between its leads.
Ultimately, "War" finds itself caught between the allure of its genre trappings and the aspiration to something more nuanced, an ambition only partially realized. While the film will likely satisfy those seeking straightforward action fare—thanks in no small part to the capabilities of its leads—the lack of originality in its execution and a script that shies away from truly exploring its potential leave it feeling like a missed opportunity. For some, the thrill of the chase and the revelation of deeper motives may be enough to warrant attention, yet one cannot help but feel that "War" could have been a battleground for much more than it ends up delivering.
Total: 62
"War," as presented on Blu-ray, is a film that teeters between mediocrity and stylistic flair, thanks in large part to a late-game plot twist that elevates the entire viewing experience from "Not bad" to "Very Good." While initially the movie suffers from a sluggish pace and underwhelming acting that does little to advance the action genre, it ultimately rewards viewers' patience with a clever narrative turn. The technical presentation of the Blu-ray brings a mixed bag of quality. The picture quality is occasionally marred by black crush and digital noise, with the bitrate dropping to under 1Mbps at times, a disappointing flaw for Blu-ray enthusiasts who expect the maximum from the disc's capacity. Despite these video transfer issues, the release shines in its audio presentation, boasting an exceptional PCM 7.1 soundtrack that provides an auditory experience so engrossing it nearly justifies the purchase on its own.
However, the extras included with this release leave much to be desired. While abundant in quantity, they lack in engaging content, suggesting that their inclusion comes at the expense of potential improvements to video quality. Such quality concerns, coupled with the film's limited appeal beyond its core action genre audience, make "War" a Blu-ray that might be more worthy of a rental rather than a purchase. Jet Li enthusiasts and audiophiles may find enough merit to add this to their collection, but for most, the replay value will be limited.
In conclusion, "War" on Blu-ray is an exemplar of how stellar audio can elevate a film's home viewing experience, even when the video quality falls short of expectations. While the action and story have their moments—especially for genre aficionados—the overall package is hindered by inconsistent video quality and uninspiring supplements. As such, potential buyers should consider their dedication to audio excellence and their tolerance for cinematic and technical flaws before committing to this as more than just a rental.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 70
This makes skin tones look a little unnatural but it's supposed to be there and isn't a fault with the disc....
Audio: 100
I've been waiting for it for years...those of you that can't make use of the extra two channels will not miss out though - because this track isn't all about surround effects....
Extras: 60
It's actually a rather impressive feat technically, but it's been completely overlooked because true 1.1 stuff made its way to the market at the same time (including on this same disc)."Thanks for clearing...
Movie: 80
When I watched it for the first time, I thought it was a mediocre action film that had a half-decent script....
Total: 70
The extras are padded out by a lot of rubbish and the space on the disc could have been given over to the picture to get rid of that digital noise...at times, the bitrate on the picture goesBELOW1Mbps...
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Black levels are excellent, faltering only here and there, but shadow detail remains high nevertheless....
Audio: 90
It's impressive, immersive, and powerful, creating a true high definition audio experience that is certainly the featured attraction on this disc....
Extras: 70
Displayed on screen is the name of the chapter, the current runtime, and time remaining showing both a clock and a progress bar....
Movie: 50
Unfortunately, this movie falls short of distinguishing itself in any way, shape, or form, and the end result is a forgettable shoot and slice 'em up flick that might entertain the first time around but...
Total: 70
The film suffers from a somewhat slow pace and bland acting, and it offers nothing new or exciting to the action genre....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Colors are vibrant, fleshtones are spot-on, and blacks are inky -- there's a bit of blooming and black crush, but it appears to be the result of intentional post-processing work....
Audio: 100
Pans aren't transparent, they're invisible -- I could never lock on a specific speaker as the source, and could hear small echoes from every point in the soundfield....
Extras: 40
The only thing that makes this track mildly interesting is the inclusion of audio clips from interviews with the director, the writers, and other members of the cast and crew....
Movie: 60
I appreciated the action scenes, the fights, and the third act twist, but while these elements elevate the film above the usual dreck, it could still have been a lot better....
Total: 60
This Blu-ray edition doesn't help matters, with an inconsistent video transfer and a host of boring, poorly conceived supplements....
Director: Philip G. Atwell
Actors: Jet Li, Jason Statham, Nadine Velazquez
PlotAn FBI agent seeks revenge against a mysterious assassin known as Rogue, who killed his partner. The relentless pursuit unfolds as the agent becomes entangled in a bitter feud between two powerful crime syndicates: the Triads and the Yakuza. Determined to bring his partner's killer to justice, the agent's investigation leads him deep into the underbelly of organized crime, where loyalty is fleeting and betrayal is deadly. As he navigates through this dangerous world, the lines between good and evil begin to blur, pushing him to the edge of morality.
The assassin, equally enigmatic and lethal, moves through the criminal landscape with a singular purpose, leaving a trail of chaos in his wake. As the war between the syndicates escalates, he manipulates the conflict to serve his own mysterious agenda. The agent, driven by vengeance, finds himself caught in a complex web of deceit and lies, where his every move is watched, and trust is a commodity no one can afford. The deeper he delves into the hunt for Rogue, the more he realizes that his adversary is not just a skilled killer but a shadowy figure with ties to his own past.
Writers: Lee Anthony Smith, Gregory J. Bradley
Release Date: 24 Aug 2007
Runtime: 103 min
Rating: R
Country: Canada, United States
Language: English, Mandarin, Japanese, Cantonese