Close Encounters of the Third Kind Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "1941," shot by the esteemed William A. Fraker and released by Universal, showcases a significant improvement in video quality compared to its predecessors, striking a balance between retaining filmic authenticity and modern viewing expectations. The cinematographic blend of live-action footage with miniatures, a hallmark of this Spielberg-directed film, posed a notable challenge for the transfer to high-definition video. This challenge is exacerbated by the film's pervasive use of smoke and fog, especially in nighttime scenes, which historically led to grainy and artifact-ridden transfers. However, this release benefits from what seems to be advanced de-graining techniques that reduce grain without sacrificing detail, avoiding the pitfalls of excessive Digital Noise Reduction (DNR) that can detract from the film's intended texture and sharpness.

The disc’s visual fidelity is further enhanced by its vivid color palette, capturing the wide range of hues from the dreary submarine interiors to the vibrant USO dance hall scenes with exceptional clarity. The commitment to maintaining solid blacks proves essential in appreciating the intricate miniatures by effects specialist A.D. Flowers, lending a depth and realism to these elements that elevate the overall visual experience. With an average bitrate of 27.18 Mbps, particularly for the extended cut, Universal ensures that each frame delivers the intended visual impact without compromise.

Moreover, the extended version incorporates a previously noted disclaimer about potential frame jumps due to scene reinstatements from the Signature Laserdisc edition. Fortunately, these concerns seem addressed, with no noticeable jumps, suggesting a meticulous digital restoration process that has allowed for a seamless viewing experience. Whether these improvements rectify past criticisms entirely may depend on individual purist inclinations towards grain presence, yet this Blu-ray edition presents a compelling case for "1941" being viewed in its best light yet, marrying technical advancement with Spielberg’s visionary execution.

The audio presentation of "1941" on Blu-ray impressively captures the essence and energy of the original cinema release, now being presented in a lossless DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix. This mix, presumably a remaster rather than a straightforward transfer from the original 70mm six-track or stereo recordings, handles the film's extensive soundscape with aplomb. While it's advised that some lines of dialogue suffer from distortion - a legacy issue from the original recording - and that sound effects have been given a boost to exploit the enhanced dynamic range of modern home theater systems, these aspects hardly detract from the overall experience. The marriage of historical sound elements with today's technological capabilities results in a sonic experience that is both nostalgic and impressively contemporary.

Despite not undergoing an aggressive sonic overhaul to fit the modern penchant for immersive, all-encompassing soundscapes like those found in today's blockbuster hits, the Blu-ray's audio track does justice to the film's original ambitious audio design. The restraints shown in not overextending the placement of sound effects ensures that moments of auditory prominence, such as the aerial dogfights, cannon blasts, and gunfire, deliver their intended impact without feeling artificially inflated. This conservative approach pays dividends in maintaining a balance that respects the film's era while providing a fulfilling experience on modern equipment.

The handling of John Williams' iconic score is another area where the Blu-ray audio excels. The score, with its nearly serious martial themes, is given room to breathe and establishes an auditory coherence that helps tether the film’s visual extravagance. Even with moments where dialogue takes on a slightly tinny quality, it remains intelligible throughout, ensuring that viewers are never pulled out of the 1941 world. The overall effect is an audio presentation that enhances the viewing experience by delivering depth and clarity to both the explosive and subtle moments of the film.

The Blu-ray release of "1941" transports much of the comprehensive extra content originally presented in Universal's 1996 Signature Laserdisc edition, although with notable differences that may affect enthusiasts and collectors alike. Most extras transition smoothly to Blu-ray, including the treasured feature-length documentary on the making of "1941," though the isolated music track and significant portions of The 1941 Archives from the Laserdisc edition are regrettably omitted. As a form of compensation, this edition includes both the theatrical and the extended cuts of the film—an option not offered in previous editions. The deleted scenes, dubbed as Additional Outtakes, provide intriguing extensions to the existing narrative. Moreover, the Production Photographs feature is a nod to nostalgia, presenting a detailed visual history in a modern slideshow format enriched by textual explanations. Trailers, including two teasers, offer a glimpse into the film’s original marketing efforts, with the second trailer notably parodying "Close Encounters of the Third Kind."

Extras included in this disc:

• The Making of 1941: A comprehensive documentary offering an in-depth look at the film's production.
• Deleted Scenes: A collection of scenes that didn't make the final cut.
• Production Photographs: A slideshow of photographs from the making of "1941" with text explanations.
• Trailers: Original trailers for the film, including two teaser trailers.

Steven Spielberg's "1941" stands as a flamboyant testament to creative chaos and anarchy, blended into an experience that defies simple categorization. At its helm, Spielberg sought to craft a screwball comedy emerging from a script that could have taken a darker, satirical route under co-writer Robert Zemeckis. This divergence in creative vision led to a film that Spielberg humorously noted found better reception in Europe than in the U.S., as revealed in "The Making of 1941". The movie, despite its turbulent reception and eclectic creation process involving figures such as John Milius and input that could have steered the project differently, remains a fascinating spectacle of what happens when conflicting creative minds converge on a singular project.

"1941" operates on a narrative set around the aftermath of Pearl Harbor, encapsulating the American West Coast's paranoia through a series of comedic escapades that range from a Japanese submarine crew led by a formidable Toshiro Mifune, aiming to strike Hollywood, to the domestic squabbles of the Douglas family preparing for Christmas amidst the chaos. Notably, Spielberg parodies his own work (a nod to "Jaws" in the opening) and orchestrates an elaborate dance of characters and scenarios that at times feels like a raucous party only he was invited to. This layered comedy, utilizing both versions available on Blu-ray (the 119-minute theatrical cut and the extended 146-minute version), showcases Spielberg’s intent to bridge serious themes with an unapologetically juvenile humor.

Technically, "1941" is an exhibition of pre-CGI special effects mastery, particularly in the aerial combat sequences and the climactic destruction involving a ferris wheel – executed with a mix of practical effects and audacity that is rarely seen in today's cinema. This commitment to spectacle over coherence, underscored by performances from an ensemble cast including Dan Ackroyd, John Belushi, and others, illustrates Spielberg's willingness to explore the extents of cinematic creativity. Despite or perhaps because of its disjointed narrative and explosive humor, "1941" demonstrates a peculiar charm that has grown on audiences over decades, thanks to an undercurrent of genuine enthusiasm and technical craft that Spielberg and his team imbued in this unique cinematic concoction.

The Blu-ray presentation of "1941" stands as a unique testament to the film's enduring peculiar charm. Despite not being celebrated as one of Spielberg's finest, the film distinctly marks its presence with an unconventional rhythm that splits audiences. The technical execution in this release is commendable, as it presents the movie in a light that has not been seen before. Enhanced visuals and sound quality contribute to an enriched viewing experience, possibly explaining why some viewers find this version more amusing than previous ones. This dichotomy between viewers - those who walk away puzzled and those who stay, intrigued and laughing, underscores the film's polarizing essence.

On the matter of financial performance, it's interesting to note that while "1941" was not the blockbuster hit Spielberg's other works were anticipated to be during its time, it did not result in a financial loss for Universal and Columbia. The cult following the film has garnered over the years speaks volumes about its unique appeal. Even if the narrative or artistic execution doesn't universally resonate, the presentation quality of this Blu-ray edition has seemingly brought more appreciation to its comedic and technical efforts. Some viewers have found a new appreciation for the movie's humor and craftsmanship upon revisiting it through this release.

In conclusion, the Blu-ray edition of "1941" serves as a pivotal point for both old fans and new viewers, offering a fresh perspective on Spielberg's eccentric project. Its enhanced visual and audio quality not only pays homage to the original vision but also invites a broader audience to explore the film's unconventional journey. Whether it emerges as a newfound favorite or remains a peculiar oddity in Spielberg's filmography, this release assures that "1941" continues to march to the beat of its own drum, garnering curiosity and laughter in equal measure.