Lisa, a professional softball player, faces an uncertain future when she's unexpectedly cut from the national team. Reeling from this blow, she begins a relationship with Matty, a charismatic and self-absorbed Major League Baseball pitcher. Their relationship is full of ups and downs, characterized by Matty's charm but lack of emotional depth, leaving Lisa unsure of her feelings and what she truly wants in life.

Simultaneously, corporate executive George is dealing with a crisis of his own—he's the target of a serious federal investigation for corporate malfeasance. His life is in turmoil, both professionally and personally, as he struggles with his relationship with his overbearing father, Charles. By chance, George meets Lisa, and they form a connection based on shared vulnerabilities and mutual understanding. As they navigate their respective challenges, their bond forces them to reassess what is truly important in their lives.