Nikki Angioli returns to her hometown in Toronto's Little Italy after completing her culinary studies abroad. Growing up, she was best friends with Leo Campo, whose family owns a pizzeria next to her family's own legendary pizza restaurant. Their families, once close, are now bitter rivals due to a business feud that erupted years ago. As Nikki settles back into the community, she and Leo reconnect, sparking up old feelings despite the tension between their families. Both are passionate about cooking and share a love for pizza making, setting the stage for a complicated relationship.

Amidst the backdrop of family rivalry and love for food, Nikki and Leo must navigate their budding romance carefully. The feud between their families escalates, putting pressure on Nikki and Leo to choose between their burgeoning love and family loyalty. As they try to find a balance, the couple faces multiple challenges that threaten not only their relationship but also the harmony within their close-knit community. Through a series of heartwarming and humorous events, Nikki and Leo strive to bring their families together while pursuing their own dreams.