Max and Annie are a competitive couple who host regular game nights with their friends. Their typical game night takes an unexpected turn when Max's charismatic but shady brother, Brooks, arranges a murder mystery party complete with fake criminals and federal agents. Everyone is excited for a staged kidnapping as part of the evening's entertainment. However, the lines begin to blur between what's game and what's reality when Brooks is actually kidnapped by real criminals, leaving Max, Annie, and their friends clueless about the gravity of the situation.

As the night progresses, the group realizes they are embroiled in a dangerous predicament involving hidden secrets, high-stakes crime organizations, and rogue operatives. Trying to navigate through the twists and turns, Max and Annie's relationship is tested, and their wits are put to the ultimate challenge. With each clue they uncover, the game night spirals further out of control, pushing friendships to their limits and uncovering unexpected truths.