Superman finds himself at odds with a new group of super-powered beings known as The Elite, who emerge as a morally ambiguous team determined to use lethal force to combat evil. The world starts to cheer for these new anti-heroes, viewing their brutal methods as a more effective solution to crime and villainy compared to Superman's traditional, non-lethal approach. As The Elite gain popularity, they provoke Superman, challenging his principles and testing his patience.

With the public increasingly divided on the best way to handle threats, Superman faces intense scrutiny and pressure. The tension between him and The Elite escalates, leading to a confrontation that questions not only the effectiveness of violence but also the very nature of justice and heroism. As Superman grapples with this ideological battle, he must prove why his methods and moral code are still relevant in an era clamoring for more drastic measures against evil.