In a small Minnesota town, two elderly neighbors, John and Max, reignite their decades-long feud when a charming and vivacious woman, Ariel, moves into the house across the street. Having been at odds since childhood over various disputes, their rivalry reaches new heights as they vie for Ariel's attention. Both are widowers, set in their ways, and using their deeply ingrained habits and quirks as weapons in their ongoing battle. Their antics escalate from mere verbal jabs to elaborate pranks, drawing the amusement and sometimes concern of the community around them.

As both men employ increasingly elaborate schemes to outdo each other and win Ariel's favor, the dynamic within the trio begins to shift. The competition brings to light old wounds and forces John and Max to confront the reasons behind their long-standing animosity. In the process, the presence of Ariel not only reignites their youthful vigor but also brings into focus the importance of companionship, forgiveness, and the value of moving beyond the past. Through their rivalry, they inadvertently teach each other and those around them lessons about life, love, and the importance of reconciling with one's history and relationships.