Two wealthy and intelligent university students, Artie Strauss and Judd Steiner, believe they can commit the perfect crime as a demonstration of their intellectual superiority and Nietzschean philosophy. Influenced by their craving for existential validation, they plan and execute a gruesome murder of a young boy, carelessly leaving behind clues that lead the authorities directly to them. The discovery of Judd's distinctive glasses at the crime scene triggers an intensive investigation.

Despite their meticulous planning, Artie and Judd are apprehended, and their trial becomes a sensational courtroom drama that captures public attention. The defense attorney presents arguments centered on the psychological state and upbringing of the defendants, challenging conventional notions of morality and criminal responsibility. The narrative unfolds through compelling legal battles and ethical dilemmas.