The film opens by exploring the early life and career of a charming, all-American actor who quickly rises to fame in Hollywood during the 1950s. Despite his on-screen success and public persona as a heartthrob, he struggles with a personal secret: his homosexuality, which he must keep hidden in an era rife with homophobia. Through candid interviews and archival footage, the documentary delves into the pressures and challenges he faces both professionally and personally, including the constant surveillance by studio executives and the press. His stories are intertwined with reflections from friends and colleagues, revealing how the industry's golden boy managed to navigate a double life under the microscope of fame.

As his career continues to ascend, he faces increasing conflicts between his public image and private life. Romantic relationships and personal anecdotes paint a vivid picture of his internal struggle for authenticity in a world demanding conformity. Historical context is provided, highlighting society's growing but limited acceptance of LGBTQ+ individuals at the time. The film intricately balances tales of his career highs with moments of deep personal introspection, offering an intimate look into the actor's journey towards self-acceptance. By focusing on this dual narrative, it provides a poignant glimpse into the sacrifices and resilience required to maintain both stardom and secrecy in mid-20th-century Hollywood.