The film embarks on an exploration of an alternate history with the premise that America never existed. It presents a compelling "what-if" scenario where key events in American history transpire differently or not at all. The narrative scrutinizes pivotal moments and influential figures, proposing that their absence or differing actions would have resonated globally. This speculative approach examines the impact on democracy, economic systems, and global leadership. The documentary enlists real-life historical commentary and dramatized reenactments to engage viewers in a thought-provoking analysis.

Shifting from hypotheticals to reality, the narrative then addresses criticisms against America’s past, dissecting common negative perceptions about the country. It counters these narratives by highlighting achievements and contributions to freedom and prosperity worldwide. Throughout, the film interweaves personal anecdotes and interviews to build a case for America's unique role in shaping modern civilization. The storyline gradually delves into larger themes of patriotism, national identity, and historical interpretation, inviting viewers to reflect on the core values and principles defining the United States.