Nicky, a seasoned con artist, becomes romantically involved with Jess, a novice grifter, after she unsuccessfully attempts to scam him. Intrigued by her potential, Nicky takes Jess under his wing, teaching her the tricks of the trade. They travel to New Orleans, where Nicky and his team execute a series of high-stakes cons, culminating in a $1.2 million bet loss to a compulsive gambler during a major football event. Nicky methodically orchestrates the gambler's manipulation, only to reveal he had planned the outcome from the start, showcasing his prowess and cementing Jess's admiration.

After their successful heist, Nicky abruptly ends the relationship, stating that attachment is detrimental to their line of work. Three years later, Nicky encounters Jess in Buenos Aires while working on another elaborate con involving motorsport mogul Garriga. Jess is now Garriga's girlfriend, complicating the job as Nicky grapples with resurfacing feelings and professional obligations. As events unfold and stakes escalate, Nicky must navigate the complex intersection of love and deception, balancing trust and betrayal in a world where appearances are deceiving and loyalty is scarce.