The movie follows the beleaguered American Samoa soccer team, infamous for a 31-0 loss, the worst defeat in international soccer history. Desperate to change their fortunes, the Football Federation recruits Thomas Rongen, a jaded yet passionate Dutch-American coach. Initially met with skepticism by the players and community, Rongen faces the daunting challenge of transforming the ill-equipped and largely inexperienced team within a limited timeframe. As he begins to understand the culture and spirit of the islanders, Rongen works to instill discipline and teamwork. His unconventional training methods and quirky motivational tactics clash with local customs but gradually gain the team's respect and enthusiasm.

Rongen's journey is marked by significant hurdles; he confronts his own personal demons while striving to inspire the team. Key players like Jaiyah, whose story as a transgender athlete resonates deeply within the sports community, become central figures in this transformative process. The plot intricately weaves humor and heart, highlighting the coach's evolving relationship with his players. Their shared love of the game gradually turns the underdog team into a cohesive unit. The team learns to balance their cultural identity with the demands of competitive sports, culminating in their quest for qualification in the upcoming World Cup. This story captures not only the revival of a failing team but also the rediscovery of belief in oneself and the power of unity through sheer determination and hope.