Jack Marcus, a charismatic and witty English teacher at a prestigious prep school, finds himself in a professional and personal slump. Struggling with alcoholism and the dwindling interest of his students in literature, Jack's passion for words is rekindled when he learns that a new art teacher, Dina Delsanto, has joined the faculty. Dina, an accomplished artist who suffers from rheumatoid arthritis, challenges her students to explore the power of images and their ability to convey deeper meaning. The clashing ideologies of the two teachers set the stage for a spirited and intellectually stimulating battle: which is superior, words or pictures?

As Jack and Dina's rivalry intensifies, they coordinate a school-wide competition designed to inspire their students and prove their respective points. Through this contest, both teachers face their personal demons and begin to confront their own vulnerabilities. Their interactions reveal complex layers of their characters, highlighting their struggles and the importance of creative expression. As the competition progresses, the impact of their teachings not only influences their students but also catalyzes significant changes in their own lives.