In a small Southwestern town, a charming and seemingly sweet older woman, known for her delicious meat pies, runs a successful business out of her home. The secret to her culinary success lies in her kitchen, aided by her four beautiful but mysterious nieces. As travelers venture through the remote desert, they often find themselves lured to this welcoming household by the promise of Auntie's renowned pies. The nieces, with their beguiling looks and flirtatious manners, draw in unsuspecting men, who never realize they are meeting their demise. Uncle Mo, a quirky and eccentric handyman with a taste for the sinister, assists in the operations, ensuring the family’s strange enterprise runs smoothly.

However, local law enforcement begins to take notice of the increasing number of disappearances. An amiable yet determined sheriff is tasked with piecing together the mysterious clues that seem to all lead back to Auntie's doorstep. As he delves deeper, he encounters the unsettling charm of the nieces and the unnerving facade of Auntie's hospitality. With rising suspicion and the stakes growing higher, the family's secret begins to teeter on the brink of exposure. They must juggle maintaining their facade while dealing with the potential threat posed by the sheriff's relentless investigation. As tension mounts and secrets threaten to unravel, the dark underbelly of their operations casts a shadow over their sunny facade.