The film explores the life and career of an actor who starred in a controversial horror sequel during the 1980s. His portrayal was groundbreaking yet criticized for its overt queer subtext at a time when LGBTQ+ representation was scarce in mainstream cinema. The film became infamous for its homoerotic undertones, leading to backlash that affected his career and personal life. The viewer is taken through his journey as he reflects on the impact the role had on his life, both as an unwitting icon for gay horror fans and as a victim of Hollywood's discriminatory practices. Interviews with industry insiders and fans provide context for the film's production and cultural significance, painting a vivid picture of the sectarian world of 1980s horror.

As the documentary progresses, it addresses themes of identity, acceptance, and resilience. Embracing his past, the actor sets out to reclaim his place in horror history and become an advocate for LGBTQ+ representation in media. With candid interviews and archival footage, the film traces his path from a struggling actor to a symbol of change in Hollywood. It also underscores the changing dynamics of the horror genre and its evolving audience. Stories from fans who found solace and empowerment in his misunderstood performance add emotional depth, highlighting how cinema can have profound personal impacts. Through his eyes, the film delivers a poignant message about overcoming adversity and finding power within one's narrative.