A young comic book artist, Holden McNeil, encounters fellow artist Alyssa Jones at a comic convention and is instantly smitten by her intelligence, wit, and charm. Unaware of her sexual orientation, he pursues a friendship with Alyssa. His hopes of a romantic relationship are dashed when he learns she is a lesbian, but he remains infatuated and continues to deepen their platonic bond. Their friendship evolves into a close camaraderie, with Holden struggling with his feelings and Alyssa confiding in him about her past relationships. Despite the challenges, their emotional connection grows as they navigate the treacherous waters of personal identity and social conventions.

Against the backdrop of the comic book industry and the countercultural scene of the '90s, Holden and Alyssa's relationship is further complicated by the reaction of Holden's friend and professional partner, Banky Edwards. Banky's jealousy and disapproval over their growing friendship lead to tension and unresolved issues resurfacing. The story explores themes such as sexuality, love beyond societal labels, and the complexity of human relationships. As Holden becomes increasingly conflicted over his feelings for Alyssa, the plot delves into the dilemmas faced when one's heart is at odds with societal norms and the fear of judgment within peer groups.