In a small working-class town, Tony, a young Italian-American, anticipates the annual Christmas Eve tradition known as the Feast of the Seven Fishes, a celebratory meal featuring an array of seafood dishes. As his family prepares for the feast, Tony grapples with his ambitions, romantic desires, and the pressures of living up to family expectations. His traditional grandmother imparts wisdom, while his boisterous family members provide comic relief and emotional support. A chance encounter introduces Tony to Beth, a girl from outside his cultural milieu, sparking an immediate connection and the possibility of romance.

As the festive preparations continue, family tensions rise and old grudges resurface, reflecting deeper issues within the family dynamics. Tony’s relationships with his friends and family are tested as he navigates the complexities of love and loyalty. The dinner draws nearer, bringing with it a blend of humor, heartache, and soul-searching that highlights the significance of tradition and the bonds that hold us together. As Tony faces pivotal decisions about his future and his new relationship with Beth, he must reconcile his dreams with his sense of duty to his family.