Lily and her mother move to a new town, starting a new chapter in their lives. At her new school, Lily encounters three girls, Frankie, Tabby, and Lourdes, who are rumored to dabble in witchcraft. After an uncomfortable incident at school demonstrates Lily's unique telekinetic ability, the trio quickly takes interest in her, believing she could be the fourth member needed to complete their coven. As Lily bonds with her new friends, they introduce her to the world of magic, initiating her into their group with a ritual that confirms their suspicions of Lily being a natural witch. Their newfound power and sisterhood bring them closer, as they begin to explore the limits of their abilities together.

The coven starts using their magic to enact seemingly harmless wishes and personal gains, believing their intentions to be for the greater good. However, as their spells begin to have unforeseen consequences, the group is forced to confront the moral implications of their actions. The deeper they venture into the magical realm, the more they realize that every spell comes with a price, leading to tensions within the group. Their friendship and loyalty are tested as they grapple with the balance between their desires and the dark side of the power they wield. Halfway through, their journey takes a dramatic turn as they face challenges that threaten the very fabric of their coven and the bond they share.