In the wake of a scandal that leaves their once-thriving Southern Baptist megachurch nearly deserted, Pastor Lee-Curtis Childs and his devoted wife Trinitie are determined to rebuild their congregation and reputations. To document their comeback journey, they invite a film crew to capture their attempts to resurrect not only their church but also their personal and public images. Despite the heavy toll of the scandal on their bond, both Pastor Childs and Trinitie put on a brave face and portray unwavering faith, hoping to spark the same fervor and devotion that previously filled their pews. However, as they prepare for a grand reopening on Easter Sunday, they face challenges in rekindling the trust of their former followers and reckoning with competitors who see their possible failure as an opportunity to expand their own influence.

As the film crew captures both candid and orchestrated glimpses into the Childs' lives, it becomes apparent that there is a deeper strain in their relationship, mounting pressure from dwindling supporters, and an increasing awareness of underlying hypocrisies. Surrounded by opulence but lacking a real connection with their community, the couple must confront questions about authenticity, leadership, and the true nature of their commitment to faith. This intense scrutiny forces Pastor Childs and Trinitie to grapple with their priorities while maintaining a poised facade for the camera and their remaining faithful followers. As preparations for the anticipated reopening heighten tensions, their personal struggles risk overshadowing the comeback story they are striving to project.