Larry Burrows is an ordinary man leading a life of quiet disappointment, constantly haunted by a pivotal moment from his youth: missing a crucial hit in a high school baseball game. On his 35th birthday, after a particularly frustrating day at work and home, he encounters a mysterious bartender named Mike. Larry confides his regrets to Mike, who offers him a drink that changes everything. Miraculously, Larry wakes up in an alternate reality where he made the game-winning hit, fundamentally altering the course of his life. In this new reality, Larry finds himself as a corporate success with immense wealth, a luxurious home, and married to the company's owner's daughter.

Initially exhilarated by his newfound success, Larry soon realizes that his perfect life is not without its own complications. Despite the perks and comforts, he begins to miss key aspects of his former life and relationships he once took for granted. As he navigates through the challenges of his new reality, Larry starts to understand the true meaning of happiness and fulfillment. The altered perspective forces him to re-evaluate his values and priorities, leading to critical decisions about what he truly wants in life. The journey becomes a potent exploration of choices, consequences, and the essence of personal contentment.