A year after outwitting the FBI and winning the public's adulation with their Robin Hood-style magic spectacles, The Four Horsemen – a group of elite illusionists – resurface for a comeback performance. This time, their goal is to expose the unethical practices of a tech mogul. However, their performance is hijacked by a mysterious figure who exposes the true identity of their leader, Dylan Rhodes, and the Horsemen are forced to flee. The group, now fugitives, must find out who is behind the curtain, manipulating them. Their quest leads them to discover that they are playing a part in a much larger, more dangerous scheme orchestrated by powerful forces.

While the Horsemen are coerced into taking on their most impossible heist yet, Rhodes tries to bring justice to his father's death by going after the man responsible. The illusionists find their hands forced and must pull off a complex series of heists during their performances, with the eyes of the FBI continually on them and new threats emerging. With the stakes higher than ever and with their enemy always one step ahead, the team must rely on their wit, skills, and illusions while unravelling a grand conspiracy. The Horsemen, along with a new female member, must use their unique abilities to clear their names and reveal the mastermind behind it all before it's too late.