Rusty James is a troubled teenager living in a small, rundown town. He idolizes his older brother, known as The Motorcycle Boy, who has a reputation as a former gang leader but now lives a solitary and enigmatic life. Rusty James desperately tries to fill his brother's shoes, getting involved in petty fights and ultimately seeking respect and validation through violence. His friends, including the loyal Steve and girlfriend Patty, try to keep him grounded, but Rusty's impulsive nature often lands him in trouble.

The Motorcycle Boy returns home after a lengthy absence, causing a stir in the local community. His return reignites Rusty James's desire to prove himself, prompting reckless behavior. As Rusty James seeks to emulate his brother's past glory, he confronts the harsh realities of their world, the impermanence of respect earned through violence, and the personal demons that plague his brother. Tension mounts as Rusty James grapples with his aspirations and the disillusionment of his hero’s fall from grace, setting the stage for an inevitable confrontation that will define their futures.