Dawn of the Dead

The Blu-ray release of "Dawn of the Dead" presents an infestation of the visual senses with its 1080p, 2.35:1-framed transfer, which brings George A. Romero's vision to life in a manner that’s both impressively detailed and faithful to the film’s original presentation. The transfer showcases excellent detail in a majority of scenes, creating a sharp, crisp image that often pops off the screen. This is complemented by a distinct color palette that sees use across various scenes - from the sterile, cold greens of the mall interiors to the rich, natural exteriors and the dimly lit basements and garages, embodying a broad spectrum of visual styles that play a crucial role in storytelling. Despite the challenges associated with translating the film’s diverse locations and textures to high definition, including occasional noise and grain particularly in bright whites and darker scenes, the Blu-ray edition represents a significant improvement over standard definition DVDs, especially in terms of detail resolution.

Shadow delineation has been handled with care, allowing for deep, natural visibility that maintains the suspense and horror without compromising on the effects and makeup work’s integrity. The horror ambiance is further enhanced by the three-dimensional look certain shots possess, alongside a color scheme where blues, grays, and especially vibrant reds stand out. Despite inherent grain and occasional digital noise—most noticeable in early morning scenes and dark mall basements—the transfer maintains a balanced clarity that seldom distracts from the overall experience. Skintones, although intentionally pale to match the film’s atmosphere, are rendered with sharp textures, highlighting hair, pores, and clothing fibers with remarkable clarity.

Fans will find the Blu-ray edition’s faithful 1080p/VC-1 transfer and detailed presentation a welcome upgrade, particularly when it comes to small background elements and the overall clarity of the image. It mirrors its HD DVD counterpart closely and excels in showing fine details like clothing fibers and interior textures within the mall, making for an enhanced viewing experience. Although some shots may drift out of focus as part of Zack Snyder's intended disorienting effect reflecting the survivors' panic, these moments are few and purposefully styled. The inclusion of heavy grain fields and sporadic noise, remnants from the original print, might diminish clarity in less lit scenes but do not detract significantly from an otherwise excellent visual presentation that dramatically surpasses earlier DVD releases plagued by compression issues and lack of sharpness.

The audio presentation of "Dawn of the Dead" on Blu-ray serves as a compelling testament to Universal's prowess in delivering high-caliber DTS-HD MA 5.1 lossless soundtracks, setting a benchmark for horror action sonic experiences. The film begins with slightly subdued dialogue volumes, a minor hiccup that swiftly corrects itself as the narrative escalates. The sound effects, in contrast, burst through with clarity and loudness, enveloping the listener in an intense auditory ordeal. Noteworthy is the bass that reverberates with thunderous vigor, complementing both the sound effects and the film’s ominous score. Moreover, guns fire with a realism that's both full-bodied and remarkably directional, enhancing the immersive aspect of the soundscape. The audio track meticulously crafts a 360-degree sonic environment, pulling the audience deeper into the cinematic experience with outstanding atmospheric sounds and music that flows seamlessly across channels.

The Blu-ray edition not only matches but in some aspects supersedes the previous HD DVD’s TrueHD 5.1 mix, especially in its portrayal of the film’s auditory elements - from the menacing moans of the undead to the cacophony of gunfire and roaring engines. Zombie vocalizations are gruesomely lifelike, emanating from all surround channels, creating a pervasive sense of dread and urgency. The high treble tones remain stable without wavering, backed by an aggressive LFE that ensures each moment of terror feels close and intense. The dialogue cuts through the chaos with remarkable clarity, ensuring that the narrative thread remains coherent amid the explosive violence. The sound field’s mastery in utilizing rear channels fosters an engrossing soundscape, further amplified by swift pans and subtle movements across channels, resulting in an audio experience that is not just heard but felt.

In essence, "Dawn of the Dead’s" Blu-ray audio presentation is a finely tuned symphony of horror, balancing explosive action sequences with nuanced sound design that elevates the entire viewing experience. The transition from quieter, dialogue-heavy scenes to the full-throttle horror ensures a dynamic range that keeps listeners on edge. Universal has crafted an audio track that is as relentless and formidable as the film's undead adversaries, making it an exemplary example of how sound can transform good horror into an unforgettable sensory ordeal.

The Blu-ray edition of "Dawn of the Dead" intriguingly balances between presenting an enriching behind-the-scenes look for enthusiasts and retaining substantial elements from previous releases, albeit with notable omissions in supplemental materials. The highlight is an audio commentary featuring director Zack Snyder and producer Eric Newman, providing insightful if not always professional, musings on their filmmaking process, decisions, and challenges. This track stands out as both candid and reflective, with Snyder particularly offering a mix of fan-like enthusiasm and critical self-awareness that adds depth to the viewing experience. However, the disc's structure leans heavily on the U-Control picture-in-picture feature, bundling various interviews, making-of segments, and special effects discussions into this format. While innovative, this approach somewhat limits direct access to specific extras, prompting mixed reactions for those preferring a more straightforward navigation to dive into the film's production nuances.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary with Zack Snyder and Eric Newman: An engaging track where Snyder and Newman discuss their experiences and decisions while making the film.
• U-Control Picture-in-Picture: Offers interviews, behind-the-scenes footage, and detailed discussions on various aspects like zombie characteristics and special effects.

Zack Snyder's 2004 rendition of "Dawn of the Dead" marks a noteworthy contribution to the reinvention of the horror genre that was taking shape in the early 2000s. Departing from the formulaic slasher trend of the 90s, Snyder’s film plunges into the domain of hyper-realistic horror, utilizing the zombie narrative to deliver a concoction of relentless gore, rapid pacing, and sleek cinematography. While it borrows the premise of Romero’s 1978 classic, it diverges significantly in execution and tone. The essence of social commentary emblematic of Romero’s work is substantially diluted in Snyder's interpretation, prioritizing high-octane action and graphic violence over satirical depth. This approach undoubtedly caters to a contemporary audience with an appetite for visceral thrills but somewhat alienates purists who revere the subtextual richness of the original.

At the heart of this revamped "Dawn of the Dead" is an ensemble cast that brings to life the chaos unfolding in a Milwaukee overrun by the undead. Sarah Polley and Ving Rhames deliver commendable performances that contribute gravitas amidst the carnage. However, the film struggles to establish meaningful emotional connections between its characters and the audience, often sidelining character development in favor of spectacle. Notwithstanding these criticisms, Snyder's film renders a visually compelling narrative brimming with tension and occasional nods to its progenitor through clever easter eggs and cameos, serving both as a homage and a standalone horror spectacle.

Snyder’s venture into this hallowed cinematic territory was met with considerable skepticism, owing to his then-nascent status as a director. Despite its thematic departure from Romero's original vision, Snyder's fast-paced, action-oriented approach to the zombie apocalypse does manage to capture the essence of sheer survivalist horror. The film's amalgamation of speedier zombies and a no-holds-barred attitude towards gore complements its stylistically modern aesthetic. Yet, its inability to resonate on a deeper, more cerebral level—a hallmark of Romero's oeuvre—underscores a missed opportunity to blend high-octane horror with poignant social commentary. In sum, Snyder's "Dawn of the Dead" excels as an adrenaline-fueled remake that respects its source material while charting its own course, albeit with certain narrative and emotional shortcomings.

Zack Snyder's "Dawn of the Dead" remake navigates a precarious path between paying homage to George A. Romero's original masterpiece and charting its own course through the zombie apocalypse genre. While the film succeeds as an adrenaline-fueled, gory romp, purists may find its disconnect from Romero's thematic depth unsettling. Despite Snyder's capable direction and a paced storyline embellished with visually striking special effects and action sequences, the film's attempt to straddle homage and reinvention leaves it dangling in a limbo of cinematic identity. The Blu-ray presentation of "Dawn of the Dead" delivers a quality experience albeit with some reservations. The video transfer earns praise for its clarity and fidelity, matching the vibrant intensity of the film's visuals. Complemented by a powerful DTS HD Master Audio track, the auditory experience immerses viewers in the chaotic soundscape of a zombie-infested world. However, the release's supplementary material—sparse and lacking in comparison to previous editions—may leave enthusiasts longing for more.

The Blu-ray edition's shortfall in bonus content and its appeal primarily to newcomers rather than collectors or existing owners of previous formats are noteworthy. This release is poised as an enticing option for those yet to own "Dawn of the Dead" in any high-definition format, offering an upgrade in visual and audio quality from standard DVD. However, those with the HD-DVD version or desiring comprehensive extras might find this edition less compelling.

In conclusion, while Zack Snyder's "Dawn of the Dead" remake and its Blu-ray presentation possess undeniable strengths in action, effects, and technical quality, they simultaneously evoke a sense of missed opportunities—a sentiment reflective of the film's broader reception. Admirers seeking to dive into the high-definition spectacle without prior investment will find value here, but the offering feels incomplete for aficionados craving a definitive collectible version. This Blu-ray stands as a testament to the film's polarizing legacy, straddling the line between a fresh visual feast and a homage that struggles to fully resonate with its predecessor's shadow.