The Legend of Zorro

Sony's 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of "The Legend of Zorro" unfortunately falls short of expectations, especially when compared to its predecessor, "The Mask of Zorro." Despite being upscaled to 2160p from a 2K digital intermediate originally shot on Super 35, the video transfer here is marred by a murky, yellowed, sometimes nearly monochromatic color palette. This issue is further exacerbated by dim and dirty visuals that starkly contrast the vibrant and detailed 4K release of "The Mask of Zorro." Skies in this edition take on a grimy hue reminiscent of a neglected gas station restroom, and the overall contrast is muddied with oppressively shadowed scenes that obscure details and dampen the viewing experience.

Upon closer examination, fine detail within "The Legend of Zorro" does manage to come through in scenes well-lit enough to allow for it, showcasing some redeeming qualities of the 4K transfer. However, these instances are too few and far between, plagued by soft textures, less-than-sharp edges, and noticeable edge halos and artificial sharpening in certain shots. The film's visual quality deteriorates further in low-light conditions - a frequent setting in the second act - resulting in weakened delineation, a fluctuating grain quality, and compromised dark regions. Despite the skilled director and cinematographer duo of Martin Campbell and Phil Meheux who worked on both Zorro films, "The Legend of Zorro" fails to replicate the dynamic visual appeal seen in "The Mask of Zorro," highlighted by its crisp skies, lifelike flesh tones, and rich coloration.

In comparison with its current streaming version on platforms like Amazon, the 4K Blu-ray edition of "The Legend of Zorro" does offer more refined details and a more filmic appearance. However, the comparison also highlights the missed opportunity for a visual experience that could have benefited from HDR's enhanced vibrancy and contrast. This comparison suggests that the 4K release may suffer from reliance on an outdated master, possibly dating back to its initial 2007 Blu-ray release. The considerable discrepancy in visual quality between the two formats underscores a pressing need for a remaster. Unfortunately, this makes Sony's 4K rendition of "The Legend of Zorro" a rare disappointment in their catalog of 4K releases.

The audio presentation of "The Legend of Zorro" on 4K UHD Blu-ray showcases an exquisite Dolby Atmos mix, paralleled closely by its impressive Dolby TrueHD 7.1 track, ensuring a riveting auditory experience that notably exceeds expectations set by the film's visual counterpart. In the calmer scenes, the mix demonstrates an adept finesse in handling dialogues, ensuring they remain crisp, clear, and appropriately prioritized amidst the ambient sound. The fluidity in channel transitions and the precision in directional cues are commendable, laying a solid foundation for the audio's performance, which becomes truly exemplary during the film's action sequences.

As the cinematic action escalates with clashing swords, splitting wood, and charging horses, the audio mix remarkably elevates the viewer's immersion. The subwoofer asserts its dominance with resonant, booming effects that underscore nitroglycerin explosions and other dynamic events, creating a palpable tension and excitement. The rear speakers are not merely bystanders in this auditory feast; they actively contribute to crafting an enveloping sound field that draws the listener into the heart of the adventure, perfectly capturing the essence and dynamism of Zorro's escapades. This impeccable balance of sound design elements across the spectrum enriches every scene, making even the quietest moments significantly impactful.

Highlighting the audio mix's brilliance is the climactic final battle, where Zorro and his family's daring antics around a speeding train are brought to life with an astounding depth and clarity of sound. The sequence is a tour de force of audio excellence, where each speaker channel works in harmony to deliver an exhilarating experience. The explosive crescendos and smoky aftermath are so vividly rendered, they momentarily distract from any visual flaws, positioning Sony's Dolby Atmos mix as an unequivocal standout feature of this 4K UHD Blu-ray release. This audio track does not just accompany the film; it elevates it to a sensory spectacle that fully embodies the thrilling spirit and legacy of Zorro.

The 4K UHD Blu-ray of "The Legend of Zorro" primarily repurposes content from previous releases, offering no new exclusive extras but maintaining a set that complements the film. The included audio commentary by Director Martin Campbell and cinematographer Phil Meheux, though insightful, skirts around the specifics of the 4K transfer, leaving tech aficionados wanting. A compilation of featurettes, albeit in standard 480i resolution, delves into various production elements like stunts and visual effects, providing a rounded view of the movie’s behind-the-scenes efforts. The selection of deleted scenes, with optional commentary, alongside high-definition theatrical promos, rounds out the package, echoing a sense of déjà vu for collectors while ensuring newcomers have a comprehensive cinematic exploration.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary: Director Martin Campbell and cinematographer Phil Meheux discuss the film.
• Featurettes: A collection of behind-the-scenes looks at stunts, party scenes, and visual effects.
• Deleted Scenes w/Optional Director's Commentary: Offers a glimpse at what might have been with alternative scenarios.
• Teaser & Theatrical Trailer: The promotional teasers for the movie in high definition.

The Legend of Zorro," while unable to soar to the dizzying heights of its precursor, "The Mask of Zorro," does not languish in the shadow of mere sequel mediocrity. It displays an unfinished tapestry of ambition and reverence towards the swashbuckling genre, with Antonio Banderas and Catherine Zeta-Jones reprising their roles with palpable chemistry that remains the vibrant core of the narrative. Despite its flaws, the film echoes the qualities that endeared its predecessor to audiences: it's a visual feast, set against the backdrop of the Mexican wilderness, coupled with action sequences that pulsate with energy. The directorial baton remains firmly in Martin Campbell’s grip, ensuring consistency in vision, if not entirely in execution. The absence of Anthony Hopkins is felt, yet the film manages to sail mostly unscathed into fans' hearts.

However, the sequel succumbs to certain pitfalls typical of follow-up films. The introduction of Joaquin (Adrián Alonso), the couple's wise-beyond-his-years son, although performed admirably by Alonso, feels like an unnecessary concession to family-friendly dynamics, occasionally detracting from the peril and intensity of the adventure. Likewise, the narrative’s pacing stumbles, especially in its initial acts, bogged down by a desire to set a grand stage for Alejandro's return to vigilantism. Additionally, the villains and purportedly epoch-shattering threat fail to captivate, leaving a somewhat anticlimactic taste as the grandiosity of the plot promise deflates under its own weight.

Despite these criticisms, "The Legend of Zorro" retains a commendable charm and showcases an industry rarity: a reliance on practical effects and stunt work that harks back to a bygone era of filmmaking. The film is an entertaining endeavor that attempts to bridge nostalgia with contemporary cinema storytelling, securing its place as more than a forgettable sequel. It doesn’t replicate the magic of its predecessor but stands firm on its own merits, offering a spirited ride through love, adventure, and heroism.

The Legend of Zorro" on 4K UHD Blu-ray brings a visually ambitious sequel into the homes of enthusiasts, yet it falls short of replicating the magic of its predecessor, both in narrative scope and technical delivery. This Sony catalog release appears compromised by its original 2K digital intermediate source, which evidently limits the potential for a visual remaster that could align with today’s 4K expectations. The decision against a full remastering leaves fans wanting, highlighting an opportunity missed to elevate this sequel's historical and dynamic action sequences to the vividness and clarity that 4K UHD can offer.

Despite these visual shortcomings, Sony's dedication to audio excellence is evident with a Dolby Atmos mix that aligns with the high standard set by "The Mask of Zorro" 4K Blu-ray. This audial prowess salvages part of the immersive experience, enveloping viewers in the midst of sword fights, horseback chases, and explosions, with every sound meticulously layered for an enveloping home theater experience. However, this sonic success underscores the visual disparity even further, creating a mixed bag of technical execution for fans and collectors alike.

In conclusion, "The Legend of Zorro" 4K UHD Blu-ray presents a paradoxical offering from Sony. While the Dolby Atmos track may satisfy audiophiles and supplement the film's adventurous spirit, the visual presentation serves as a stark reminder of the limitations imposed by its source material. For enthusiasts looking to complete their collection, or die-hard fans of the franchise, there may be value in this release. Yet, for others seeking a showcase piece for their 4K UHD setups or a cinematic experience on par with the first film, the advice would be to temper expectations or heed the suggestion to prioritize "The Mask of Zorro" 4K release over its sequel.