3:10 to Yuma
Blu-ray
Score: 75
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
3:10 to Yuma" enthralls with its old-school charm, superb AV quality, and a wealth of extras; a must-have for Blu-ray enthusiasts.
Disc Release Date
Video: 74
The 3:10 to Yuma Blu-ray offers a visually stunning, authentic western experience with vivid colors, deep blacks, and excellent detail, despite minor edge enhancement and grain issues.
Audio: 75
Lionsgate's 7.1 PCM audio for 3:10 to Yuma impresses with its all-encompassing, realistic soundstage and dialogue clarity, making it a top-notch aural experience.
Extra: 69
The 3:10 to Yuma Blu-ray surprises with its depth of engaging and informative features, highlighting the making, music, and historical context of the Western genre, despite initial confusion over its technical specifications.
Movie: 70
3:10 to Yuma impresses with dynamic performances, meticulously staged action, and a compelling character-driven story, celebrated as a high point in Western cinema and Blu-ray achievement.
Video: 74
"3:10 to Yuma" is delivered on Blu-ray with a presentation that does justice to the film's rich, detailed cinematic world. This release features a 1080p/VC-1 transfer in the movie's original 2.40:1 aspect ratio, achieving a level of crispness and clarity that stands out even among the best Blu-ray presentations. The film’s palette is rendered with striking vibrancy: from the deep reds of blood and the warm hues of desert sunsets to the cooler tones of night scenes and snowy plains. Shadow details are finely rendered, allowing for a discernible texture in the darkest scenes, while black levels are robust, lending depth and dimension to the image without obscuring detail.
However, while the transfer is generally excellent, showcasing Phedon Papamichael's cinematography with an almost tactile realism and maintaining natural skin tones alongside the stunning landscapes, there are minor drawbacks. Some edge enhancement is noticeable, causing occasional haloing that, along with instances of grain appearing noisy due to processing, slightly detracts from the immersive experience. Additionally, there have been scattered reports of aliasing artifacts and the appearance of jaggies in end credits text—likely results of digital compression missteps. Despite these issues, qualities such as the transfer's handling of motion—from high-speed chases to more subtle movements—remain impressive, with no loss of detail or clarity.
In conclusion, the Blu-ray video presentation of "3:10 to Yuma" impresses with its detailed rendering of both characters and sweeping landscapes, its deep and nuanced color palette, and its effective balance of contrasts. While there are minor technical imperfections, they do little to mar what is overall a visually stunning home viewing experience. This Blu-ray not only respects but elevates the original material offering an engaging and vivid way to appreciate this modern Western classic.
Audio: 75
Lionsgate has consistently impressed with their audio transfers, and the 7.1 PCM uncompressed sound for "3:10 to Yuma" is no exception, setting a new standard for immersive and dynamic audio in home entertainment. This mix captures the essence of the Wild West with astonishing clarity and precision, from the thunderous gallop of horses to the crack of gunfire echoing across the desert. Every element, be it the subtle ambient sounds that transport listeners straight into the scene or the explosive intensity of action sequences, is rendered with an exceptional degree of realism and attention to detail. The soundstage is broad and engaging, enveloping viewers in a meticulously crafted aural landscape that rivals, if not surpasses, the best Blu-ray presentations to date.
Dialogue, often a casualty of lesser mixes, remains crisp and distinct against the backdrop of the film's robust sound effects and Marco Beltrami’s atmospheric score. Despite some reports of snippets of dialogue being lost amidst the cacophony, the overall balance ensures that speech is not overwhelmed by the soundtrack’s more bombastic moments. The bass is deep, resonant, and free from distortion, adding to the richness of the soundscape without ever becoming overpowering. Meanwhile, the surround channels are utilized to full effect, enveloping viewers in a seamless cocoon of sound that is as detailed during quiet moments as it is during the frenetic action sequences.
Though the disc also includes a Dolby Digital-EX 5.1 option, it pales in comparison to the main PCM track, which delivers a superior audio experience that is both more engaging and immersive. The use of the full 7.1 channels contributes significantly to this immersion, creating an aural environment that is unmatched in its ability to draw listeners into the film’s world. In short, "3:10 to Yuma" sounds phenomenal on Blu-ray, thanks to Lionsgate’s commitment to audio excellence, offering an experience that is both thrillingly aggressive and wonderfully nuanced.
Extra: 69
The "3:10 to Yuma" Blu-ray extras deliver a comprehensive package that marries historical authenticity with behind-the-scenes insights, embodying a treasure trove for Western genre aficionados and film-making enthusiasts alike. Noteworthy is the immersive "Inside Yuma" feature which, despite its unconventional approach to Picture-in-Picture (PiP) due to technical limitations, offers creative navigation through script pages, storyboards, and alternate scene interpretations, albeit with potential compatibility issues on older devices. Director James Mangold's commentary emerges as a gem, blending scene-specific analysis with broader reflections on character motivation and the filmmaking process. Additionally, features like "Destination: Yuma" and "Outlaws, Gangs, & Posses" provide both a making-of narrative and a historical context, enriching viewers' understanding of the film's backdrop. Technical extras such as "3:10 to Score," alongside "The Guns of Yuma," delve into the meticulous crafting of the film's score and the period-authentic arsenal, underscored by contributions from historians and weaponry experts. Moreover, the inclusion of deleted scenes offers further dimensions to the narrative, while "From Sea to Shining Sea" and interactive elements like the "Historical Timeline of the West" extend the discourse beyond the film, encapsulating the transformative era of the American West. Although certain features like a conversation with Elmore Leonard might leave audiences craving more depth, the overall assemblage is a commendable fusion of entertainment and education, poised to enhance any home cinema library.
Extras included in this disc:
AUDIO COMMENTARY WITH JAMES MANGOLD: A director’s insight into the making of the film.
DESTINATION YUMA: Making-of segment exploring settings, props, and deeper meanings.
OUTLAWS, GANGS & POSSES: Historical context on outlaws in media over the years.
AN EPIC EXPLORED: Looks at the history of Westerns in cinema.
3:10 TO SCORE: Behind-the-scenes look at the film's music creation.
FROM SEA TO SHINING SEA: Chronicles the impact of the transcontinental railroad.
A CONVERSATION WITH ELMORE LEONARD: A brief piece on the Western in literature and Leonard’s story.
THE GUNS OF YUMA: Focus on characters’ firearms and selection process by the prop department.
HISTORICAL TIMELINE OF THE WEST: Interactive text supplement on late 19th Century events.
INSIDE YUMA: Interactive feature with script pages, storyboards, and separate encoded versions of scenes with PiP windows.
DELETED SCENES: Seven scenes offering additional footage.
THEATRICAL TRAILER & OTHER PREVIEWS: Film’s trailer and previews for other movies.
Movie: 70
"3:10 to Yuma" stands as a testament to the enduring appeal and adaptability of the Western genre, brilliantly updated for a modern audience while preserving its classic essence. Directed with a deft hand by James Mangold, the film transcends the simple dichotomy of good vs. evil, delving deep into themes of morality, redemption, and the complexity of human nature. With standout performances by Christian Bale and Russell Crowe, the dynamic between the impoverished rancher Dan Evans and the charismatic outlaw Ben Wade is electrifying, enriched by a supporting cast that brings depth and texture to this gritty narrative. The inclusion of historically accurate firearm use adds a layer of authenticity to the action, heightening the tension in well-staged shootouts that punctuate a story of surprising emotional depth.
Technically, "3:10 to Yuma" shines on Blu-ray, showcasing cinematography that captures the stark, untamed beauty of the Western landscape, complemented by an evocative score from Marco Beltrami. The sound design is particularly noteworthy for its realistic portrayal of gunfire, bringing a visceral intensity to each exchange. Amidst thrilling action sequences, the film weaves a rich tapestry of character development, led by Bale's portrayal of desperation and dignity, and Crowe's nuanced turn as a man torn between his nefarious impulses and a latent desire for redemption. Their journey towards the film's climax is as much internal as it is physical, making for a captivating watch.
While rooted in the classic tropes of the genre, "3:10 to Yuma" transcends traditional Western boundaries through its exploration of the characters' complex moral landscapes and its revisionist take on iconic archetypes. Mangold's direction combines with stellar performances and technical prowess to deliver a film that is as thought-provoking as it is visually arresting. Its success reaffirms the Western's capacity to offer fresh insights into the human condition, making "3:10 to Yuma" a compelling modern classic that revitalizes its genre for a new generation.
Total: 75
"3:10 to Yuma" on Blu-ray stands as a monumental release that piqued both audiophiles' and cinephiles' interests, cementing its place as a must-have in any collection. Despite some believing it did not entirely rejuvenate the Western genre, the film offers a captivating experience filled with stellar performances, compelling direction, and a story that aligns with the traditional ethos of Western cinema. It might fall short for viewers not enamored with Westerns, as it proudly embraces its "old school" roots without attempting to reinvent the genre. Where the Blu-ray release truly excels is in its technical presentation. Boasting an audio-visual quality that can only be described as a benchmark for the format, it delivers an immersive experience that complements the film's intense atmosphere and outstanding cinematography. The picture quality is nothing short of exemplary, providing lifelike reproductions that are both stunning and breathtaking.
The supplementary materials included in the Blu-ray package add substantial value, offering a wealth of background information, particularly those offering historical context, which enriches the viewing experience. Although there was a minor oversight with the Picture-in-Picture feature, this does not detract from the overall quality of the release, which is bolstered by an array of extras that fans will find thoroughly rewarding. These aspects affirm its status not just as a film but as a comprehensive package that showcases what the Blu-ray format can achieve.
In conclusion, "3:10 to Yuma" on Blu-ray is an essential acquisition for aficionados of the genre and collectors alike. Its high-caliber blend of gripping narrative, robust performances, and a masterful technical presentation ensures it commands a venerable position among home media releases. It offers exceptional value and is unequivocally recommended, making it a standout title that beautifully marries content with quality, thereby securing its recommendation with high praise.
avforums review by Chris McEneanyRead review here
Video: 80
Audio: 90
Three-dimensionality is definitely revealed with numerous shots of characters striding or riding down streets, standing against the vast western vistas on offer and, most engagingly, when pointing guns...
But here with a live-action drama that is regularly bolstered by gunplay, horses and wagons thundering over the desert and the odd explosion or two, the mix is rendered with altogether more realism and...
Extra: 90
Movie: 80
I like Mangold's take on the concept - how all these archetypal elements of the outlaws, the gunfights, the Indian Wars and the railroads only came together for a very brief moment in history, yet created...
Mangold gets some mileage out of the story and it would be difficult to think of a modern audience sitting through it if he had kept strictly to the original set-up - although with two terrifically intense...
Total: 90
Therehasbeen a gaffe made with the PiP feature as, really, this should have been a bonafide Profile 1.1 release, but the sheer wealth of extras is thoroughly rewarding in many other respects....
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
Audio: 100
Not only are close-up images, such as human faces, presented with a naturalistic grace that seems almost too perfect to be anything but reality, but there is a clarity to the mundane in the background...
Lionsgate has really stepped up their game recently, delivering incredible uncompressed tracks on many of their newer titles, and 3:10 to Yuma's 7.1 PCM mix is without question the best of the bunch....
Extra: 80
Movie: 100
Displayed on screen is the name of the chapter, the current runtime, and time remaining showing both a clock and a progress bar....
While they are simple men on the surface--a poor rancher and a criminal--they reveal a deep and profound sense of humanity, and the slow reveal of this trait, especially in the Wade character, makes for...
Total: 100
In addition to an absolutely fantastic, Oscar caliber film with marvelous acting, direction, cinematography, and music, Blu-ray owners are treated to mesmerizing video quality and a stunning audio track...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Audio: 80
The movie's photography is moderately grainy in some scenes, which wouldn't be a problem in itself except that the edge enhancement sometimes makes the grain look quite noisy....
The disc also has a standard Dolby Digital-EX 5.1 option, which is very nice in itself, but the PCM track takes the audio experience to another level entirely....
Extra: 60
Movie: 60
Among the content are behind-the-scenes production footage, visual effects demonstrations, and "dailies" (a showcase of all the unedited footage from every camera angle that the editor had to work with,...
And yet, by and large, modern audiences remain apathetic to the whole thing, convinced that Westerns were their granddaddy's genre and offer little of interest for them....
Total: 80
'3:10 to Yuma' didn't quite revitalize the Western genre as its makers may have hoped, but it's an entertaining (if flawed) movie....
Director: James Mangold
Actors: Russell Crowe, Christian Bale, Ben Foster
PlotIn the arid expanses of the Arizona Territory, struggling rancher Dan Evans witnesses the notorious outlaw Ben Wade, and his vicious gang, ravage an armored stagecoach. Following the deadly heist, Wade is captured through a stroke of fate, and the desperate rancher volunteers to deliver the captured outlaw to the town of Contention from where he will be sent to the Yuma Prison on the 3:10 train. Evans, motivated by a $200 reward that would save his drought-stricken farm and yearning for the respect of his wife and sons, embarks on the perilous mission.
Tasked with the transport is a mismatched posse, including a determined, yet crippled Civil War veteran, a few lawmen, and a mercenary. With Wade's gang led by the psychopathic Charlie Prince on their trail, the group navigates the treacherous landscape while grappling with their own moral codes and sense of duty. Along the way, the interactions between Evans and Wade intensify, weaving a complex dynamic of psychological warfare and grudging mutual respect between captive and captor. The journey to Contention becomes a tense survival quest as they face not only Wade's relentless gang but also treachery from within their ranks and the threats posed by the unforgiving wilderness.
MoreWriters: Halsted Welles, Michael Brandt, Derek Haas
Release Date: 07 Sep 2007
Runtime: 122 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English, Chinese